bitpro가 원문에서 글자만 모은 내용이에요. 표·그림·수식은 빠지거나 깨질 수 있어요. 전체 2쪽 중 2쪽
lure We have some ideas on how to overcome this and we’ll
be sharing them in upcoming blog and product updates. There are many ways to tackle this problem. For
now, this initial implementation gets us on the right track to realize these innovations in following versions.
By leveraging the platforms we have chosen, we have reduced the centralization risk to one singular
responsibility: the creation and redemption of tokens. All other aspects of the system are decentralized.
12 See section on Legal and Compliance for more information
13 Same as footnote #10
11
Main Applications
In this section we’ll summarize and discuss the main applications of tethers across the Bitcoin/blockchain
ecosystem and for other consumers globally. We break up the beneficiaries into three user groups:
Exchanges, Individuals, and Merchants.
The main benefits, applicable to all groups:
● Properties of Bitcoin bestowed upon other asset classes
● Less volatile, familiar unit of account
● World’s assets migrate to the Bitcoin blockchain
For Exchanges
Exchange operators understand that accepting fiat deposits and withdrawals using legacy financial systems
can be complicated, risky, slow, and expensive. Some of these issues include:
● Identifying the right payment providers for your exchange
○ irreversible transactions, fraud protection, lowest fees, etc
● Integrating the platform with banks who have no APIs
● Liaising with these banks to coordinate compliance, security, and to build trust
● Prohibitive costs for small value transfers
● 37 days for international wire transfers to clear
● Poor and unfavorable currency conversion fees
By offering tethers, an exchange can relieve themselves of the above complications and gain additional
benefits, such as:
● Accept cryptofiats as deposit/withdrawal/storage method rather than using a legacy bank or
payment provider
○ Allows users to move fiat in and out of exchange more freely, quickly, cheaply
● Outsource fiat custodial risk to Tether Limited just manage cryptos
● Easily add other tethered fiat currencies as trading pairs to the platform
● Secure customer assets purely through accepted cryptoprocesses
○ Multisignature security, cold and hot wallets, HD wallets, etc
12
○ Conduct audits easier and more securely in a purely crypto environment
● Anything one can do with Bitcoin as an exchange can be done with tethers
Exchange users know how risky it can be to hold fiat currencies on an exchange. With the growing number
of insolvency events it can be quite dangerous. As mentioned previously, we believe that using tethers
exposes exchange users to less counterparty risk than continually holding fiat on exchanges. Additionally,
there are other benefits to holding tethers, explained in the next section.
For Individuals
There are many types of individual Bitcoin users in the world today. From traders looking to earn profits
daily; to long term investors looking to store their Bitcoins securely; to techsavvy shoppers looking to avoid
credit card fees or maintain their privacy; to philosophical users looking to change the world; to those looking
to remit payments globally more effectively; to those in third world countries looking for access to financial
services for the first time; to developers looking to create new technologies; to all those who have found
many uses for Bitcoin. For each of these individuals, we believe tethers are useful in similar ways, like:
● Transact in USD/fiat value, pseudoanonymously, without any middlemen/intermediaries
● Cold store USD/fiat value by securing one’s own private keys
● Avoid the risk of storing fiat on exchanges move cryptofiat in and out of exchanges easily
● Avoid having to open a fiat bank account to store fiat value
● Easily enhance applications that work with bitcoin to also support tether
● Anything one can do with Bitcoin as an individual one can also do with tether
For Merchants
Merchants want to focus on their business, not on payments. The lack of global, inexpensive, ubiquitous
payment solutions continue to plague merchants around the world both large and small. Merchants deserve
more. Here are some of the ways tether can help them:
● Price goods in USD/fiat value rather than Bitcoin (no moving conversion rates/purchase windows)
● Avoid conversion from Bitcoin to USD/fiat and associated fees and processes
● Prevent chargebacks, reduce fees, and gain greater privacy
● Provide novel services because of fiatcrypto features
○ Microtipping, gift cards, more
● Anything one can do with Bitcoin as a merchant one can also do with tether
13
Future Innovations
Multisig and Smart Contracts
Proof of Solvency Innovations
Conclusion
Tether constitutes the first Bitcoinbased fiatpegged cryptocurrencies in existence today. Tether is based on
the Bitcoin blockchain, the most secure and welltested blockchain and public ledger in existence. Tethers
are fully reserved in a onetoone ratio, completely independent of market forces, pricing, or liquidity
constraints. Tether has a simple and reliable Proof of Reserves implementation and undergoes regular
professional audits. Our underlying banking relationships, compliance, and legal structure provide a secure
foundation for us to be the custodian of reserve assets and issuer of tethers. Our team is composed of
experienced and respected entrepreneurs from the Bitcoin ecosystem and beyond.
We are focused on arranging integrations with existing businesses in the cryptocurrency space. Business
like exchanges, wallets, merchants, and others. We’re already integrated with Bitfinex, HolyTransaction,
Omni Wallet, Poloniex, CCEX, and more to come. Please reach out to us to find out more.
Appendix
Audit Flaws: Exchanges and Wallets
Here is a summary of the current flaws found in technologybased exchange and wallet audits. 14
In the Merkle tree[6] approach users must manually report that their balances (user’s leaf) have been
correctly incorporated in the liability declaration of the exchange (the Merkle hash of the exchange’s
database of user balances). This proposed solution works if enough users verify that their account was
included in the tree, and in a case where their account is not included this instance would be reported. One
potential risk is that an exchange database owner could produce a hash that is not the true representation of
14 As opposed to hiring a professional auditor
14
the database at all; it hashes an incomplete database which would reduce its apparent liabilities to
customers, making them appear solvent to a verifying party. Here are some scenarios where a fraudulent
exchange would exclude accounts and :
○ “Bitdust” Accounts: Inactive or low activity accounts would lower the chance that an
uninterested user would check or report inconsistencies. In some cases these longtail
accounts could represent a significant percentage of the exchange’s liabilities.
○ “Colluding Whales” Attack: There is evidence that large Bitcoin traders are operating on
various exchanges and moving markets significantly. Such traders need to have capital
reserves at the largest exchanges to quickly execute orders. Often, traders choose
exchanges that they “trust”. In this way they can be assured that should a hack or liquidity
issue arise, they have priority to get their money out. In this case, the exchange and trader
could collude to remove the whales account balance from the database before it’s hashed.
○ Key Rental Attack: To pass the audit, a malicious exchange could rent the private keys to
bitcoins they do not own. This would make them appear solvent by increasing their assets
without any acknowledgment that those funds were loaned to them. Likewise, they could
“borrow” fiat currency to do the same.
○ There are more attacks not discussed here.
Reaching Statistical Significance (reporting completeness): Even outside of these three attack vectors, a
database that has been manipulated may never be detected if a sufficient number of users are not validating
balances. The probability of getting 100% of the users to verify balances is likely zero, even with proper
incentivization structure for users to verify their balances. Therefore, auditors would need statistical tools to
make statements about the validity of an exchange’s database based on sampling frequency, size, and
other properties.
Currently users have no way to receive compensation by legal means in case something goes wrong with
the exchange. For example, when Mt.Gox closed operations, many users might not have independently
recorded their account balances (prints screens, signed messages to themselves, etc) in a way that could
conclusively prove to law enforcement that this exchange’s I.O.U’s actually existed. Such users are at the
mercy of the exchange to somehow publish a record of that hash tree or original database.
The proposed structure in which these audits would be performed still contains some subtle but important
flaws. In particular, the data reporting (hash tree) on the institution’s website gives no guarantee at all to
15
users, as a malicious exchange could publish different states/balances to different groups of users, or
retroactively change the state. Thus it is fundamental to publish this data through a secure broadcast
channel, e.g. the Bitcoin blockchain.
Privacy is a barrier to entry for the adoption of an automated/open auditing system. While some progress
has been made towards better privacy there is no perfect solution yet. Further, to build up an accurate user
verified liability space, these users will have to report account balances with the exchange and Bitcoin
addresses. Some users likely would not report this information regardless of the incentive, therefore
providing cryptographically secure privacy whilst obtaining the reporting goal is paramount.
Time Series: the Merkle tree hash is a single snapshot of the database at a single point in time. Not having a
somewhat continuous time series of the database opens significant attack vectors. Additionally, a time
series of user reported information would also be required for piecing together the history of any reported
incidents of fraud.
Trusted Third Parties: All of the current exchange audits have relied on some “reputable” trusted third party
to make some type of verification. In the Coinbase audit [7], that was Andreas Antonopoulos, in the Kraken
audit [8], that was Stefan Thomas. If we absolutely must rely on a trusted third party then some audit
standards and procedures should ensure this weaknesses is fortified.
Limitations of Existing Fiatpegging Systems
Here’s a list of some of the common drawbacks and limitations of existing fiatpegging systems.
● The systems are based on closedsource software, running on private, centralized databases,
fundamentally no different than Paypal or any other existing massmarket retail/institutional asset
trading/transfer/storage system.
● Decentralized systems that rely on altcoin blockchains which haven’t been stresstested, developed,
or reviewed as closely as other blockchains, like Bitcoin.
● Pegging processes that rely on hedging derivative metaassets, efficient market theory, or
collateralization of the underlying asset, wherein liquidity, transferability, security, and other issues
can exist.
16
● Lack of transparency and audits for the custodian, either crypto, fiat, or relating to their own internal
ledgers (same as closed source and centralised databases).
● Reliance on legacy banking systems and trusted third parties (bank account owners) as a transfer
and settlement mechanism for reserve assets.
Market Risk Examples
In the collateralization method, market risk exists because the price of the asset being used as collateral can
move in an adverse direction to the price of the asset it’s backing/pegging. This would cause the total value
of the collateral to become less than the total value of the issued asset and make the system insolvent. This
risk is mitigated by the custodian closing the position before this happens; that is, when the collateral price
equals the pegged asset price then the collateral is liquidated (sold on the open market) and the position is
closed. A great approach, with merit, and used in many liquid markets across the traditional banking and
financial markets. However, as we saw from the global financial crisis, situations can arise in which the
acceleration of such events causes a “liquidity crunch” and thus the collateral is unable to be liquidated fast
enough to meet trading obligations, subsequently creating losses. With the cryptocurrency markets being so
small and volatile, this type of event is much more likely. Additionally, the overall approach suffers from other
liquidity and pricing constraints since there must be a sufficient supply of users posting collateral for the
creation of the peggedassets to exist in the first place.
In the derivatives approach, the price of the asset is pegged through entering one of several derivatives
strategies, such as: swap strategies, covered and naked options strategies, various futures and forwards
strategies. Each strategy has their own strengths and weaknesses, the discussion of which we won’t engage
in here. To summarize, each of these pegging processes themselves have similar “market risk”
characteristics as the aforementioned collateralization method. It should be noted that the two methods are
not mutually exclusive and often paired in a specific trading, hedging, or risk management function at legacy
system financial institutions.
Finally, understand that we believe some combination of the above approaches may become a secure,
reliable, and generally riskfree process for backing/pegging assets; however, at this point in time, this is not
a direction we feel is feasible to take to ensure liquidity and price stability. Further, we believe that a
reservebased approach will always be in existence and complement these other approaches as the entire
industry grows. As advances in technology continue, we will evaluate and incorporate any benefits available
while maintaining the guarantee of 100% redeemability.
17
Legal and Compliance
Tether Limited (“Tether”) is a limited company incorporated pursuant to the Hong Kong Companies
Ordinance. It is wholly owned by Tether Holdings Limited, a BVI business company incorporated pursuant to
the BVI Business Companies Act, 2004.
Tether is registered as a Money Services Business with the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network of the
U.S. Department of the Treasury (MSB Registration Number 31000058542968). Tether is establishing a
relationship with a U.S. financial institution for purposes of better servicing Tether users in the United States.
Tether is concluding a principal–agency agreement with RenRenBee Limited (“RenRenBee”). RenRenBee is
licensed as a Money Services Operator by the Hong Kong Customs and Excise Department (Licence No.
130901265). Pursuant to the agreement, RenRenBee will provide antimoney laundering compliance work
and customer due diligence procedures as agent for Tether as principal.
Through these and other measures, Tether is undertaking customer due diligence, recordkeeping, and
reporting procedures consistent with U.S. law and with the Hong Kong AntiMoney Laundering and
CounterTerrorist Financing (Financial Institutions) Ordinance.
Tether Limited currently has accounts with Cathay Bank and Hwatai Bank in Taiwan, both of whom are
aware and confident that Tether’s business model is acceptable.
These banks are satisfied with our processes and also satisfied that our business operates in accordance
with Taiwan offshore banking regulations, as all of the banks had been requested to check this with their
own legal, compliance and headoffice before opening accounts (also at our own request). It was our goal
from the beginning to have a compliant operation and to provide the maximum level of comfort to our
banking partners here. In addition these banks have and are working with other Bitcoin based businesses.
18
Glossary of Terms
Digital currency: As defined by http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_currency
Cryptocurrency or decentralized digital currency: any type of cryptocurrency that is opensource,
cryptographically secure, and uses a distributed ledger. See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cryptocurrency
Realworld currency, or fiat currency, or national/sovereign currency: all types of currency that are
not cryptocurrencies as defined above.
Cryptocurrency system: A collection of software and processes primarily created to enable the existence
of a cryptocurrency.
Legacy financial system: any financial system that is not a cryptocurrency system.
Utilitybacked digital tokens, a.k.a Dapps: A decentralized digital token whose value is derived from the
usefulness of its application rather than just being a value transfer system.
Assetbacked/pegged cryptocurrency: Any cryptocurrency whose price is pegged to a realworld asset,
i.e. its not a “utilitybacked” cryptocurrency.
Tether(s): a single unit (or multiple units) of fiatpegged cryptocurrency issued by Tether Limited
TetherUSD or tUSD: a single unit of cryptoUSD issued by Tether Limited
TUSD: collective amount of tUSD in circulation at any point in time.
Tether System: collectively refers to all process and technologies that enable tethers to exist
Proof of Reserves: The process by which the issuer of any assetbacked decentralized digital token,
cryptographically/mathematically proves that all tokens that have been issued are fully reserved and backed
by the underlying asset.
19
References
[1] https://www.thefinancialist.com/wpcontent/uploads/2012/10/2012GlobalWealthReport.pdf
[2] https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf
[3]http://www.deloitte.com/assets/DcomUnitedStates/Local%20Assets/Documents/FSI/us_fsi_BitcointheNe
wGoldRush_031814.pdf
[4] https://github.com/mastercoinMSC/spec
[5] http://unenumerated.blogspot.com/2005/12/bitgold.html
[6] https://iwilcox.me.uk/2014/provingbitcoinreserves
[7] http://antonopoulos.com/2014/02/25/coinbasereview/
[8] http://www.coindesk.com/krakensauditprovesholds100bitcoinsreserve/
20프로젝트로 돌아가기