bitpro가 원문에서 글자만 모은 내용이에요. 표·그림·수식은 빠지거나 깨질 수 있어요. 전체 2쪽 중 1쪽
Tether: Fiat currencies on the Bitcoin blockchain
Abstract. A digital token backed by fiat currency provides individuals and organizations with a
robust and decentralized method of exchanging value while using a familiar accounting unit. The
innovation of blockchains is an auditable and cryptographically secured global ledger. Assetbacked
token issuers and other market participants can take advantage of blockchain technology, along
with embedded consensus systems, to transact in familiar, less volatile currencies and assets. In
order to maintain accountability and to ensure stability in exchange price, we propose a method to
maintain a onetoone reserve ratio between a cryptocurrency token, called tethers, and its
associated realworld asset, fiat currency. This method uses the Bitcoin blockchain, Proof of
Reserves, and other audit methods to prove that issued tokens are fully backed and reserved at all
times.
1
Table of Contents
Table of Contents
Introduction
Technology Stack and Processes
Tether Technology Stack
Flow of Funds Process
Proof of Reserves Process
Implementation Weaknesses
Main Applications
For Exchanges
For Individuals
For Merchants
Future Innovations
Multisig and Smart Contracts
Proof of Solvency Innovations
Conclusion
Appendix
Audit Flaws: Exchanges and Wallets
Limitations of Existing Fiatpegging Systems
Market Risk Examples
Legal and Compliance
Glossary of Terms
References
2
Introduction
There exists a vast array of assets in the world which people freely choose as a storeofvalue, a
transactional medium, or an investment. We believe the Bitcoin blockchain is a better technology for
transacting, storing, and accounting for these assets. Most estimates measure global wealth around 250
trillion dollars [1] with much of that being held by banks or similar financial institutions. The migration of
these assets onto the Bitcoin blockchain represents a proportionally large opportunity.
Bitcoin was created as “an electronic payment system based on cryptographic proof instead of trust,
allowing any two willing parties to transact directly with each other without the need for a trusted third
party.”[2]. Bitcoin created a new class of digital currency, a decentralized digital currency or cryptocurrency . 1
Some of the primary advantages of cryptocurrencies are: low transaction costs, international borderless
transferability and convertibility, trustless ownership and exchange, pseudoanonymity, realtime
transparency, and immunity from legacy banking system problems [3]. Common explanations for the current
limited mainstream use of cryptocurrencies include: volatile price swings, inadequate massmarket
understanding of the technology, and insufficient easeofuse for nontechnical users.
The idea for assetpegged cryptocurrencies was initially popularized in the Bitcoin community by the 2
Mastercoin white paper authored by J.R. Willett in January 2012[4]. Today, we’re starting to see these ideas
built with the likes of BitAssets, Ripple, Omni, Nxt, NuShares/Bits, and others. One should note that all
Bitcoin exchanges and wallets (like Coinbase, Bitfinex, and Coinapult) which allow you to hold value as a fiat
currency already provide a similar service in that users can avoid the volatility (or other traits) of a particular
cryptocurrency by selling them for fiat currency, gold, or another asset. Further, almost all types of existing
financial institutions, payment providers, etc, which allow you to hold fiat value (or other assets)
subsequently provide a similar service. In this white paper we focus on applications wherein the fiat value is
stored and transmitted with software that is opensource, cryptographically secure, and uses distributed
ledger technology, i.e. a true cryptocurrency.
While the goal of any successful cryptocurrency is to completely eliminate the requirement of trust, each of
the aforementioned implementations either rely on a trusted third party or have other technical,
marketbased, or processbased drawbacks and limitations . 3
1 For definitions throughout, see Glossary of Terms
2 But has been discussed since Dr. Szabo’s proposed BitGold [5]
3 Summarized in the Appendix, here: Limitations of Existing Fiatpegging Systems
3
In our solution, fiatpegged cryptocurrencies are called “tethers”. All tethers will initially be issued on the 4
Bitcoin blockchain via the Omni Layer protocol and so they exist as a cryptocurrency token. Each tether unit
issued into circulation is backed in a onetoone ratio (i.e. one Tether USDT is one US dollar) by the
corresponding fiat currency unit held in deposit by Hong Kong based Tether Limited. Tethers may be
redeemable/exchangeable for the underlying fiat currency pursuant to Tether Limited’s terms of service or, if
the holder prefers, the equivalent spot value in Bitcoin. Once a tether has been issued, it can be transferred,
stored, spent, etc just like bitcoins or any other cryptocurrency. The fiat currency on reserve has gained the
properties of a cryptocurrency and its price is permanently tethered to the price of the fiat currency.
Our implementation has the following advantages over other fiatpegged cryptocurrencies:
● Tethers exist on the Bitcoin blockchain rather than a less developed/tested “altcoin” blockchain nor
within closedsource software running on centralized, private databases.
● Tethers can be used just like bitcoins, i.e. in a p2p, pseudoanonymous, decentralized,
cryptographically secure environment.
● Tethers can be integrated with merchants, exchanges, and wallets just as easily as Bitcoin or any
other cryptocurrencies can be integrated.
● Tethers inherit the properties of the Omni Layer protocol which include: a decentralized exchange;
browserbased, opensource, wallet encryption; Bitcoinbased transparency, accountability,
multiparty security and reporting functions.
● Tether Limited employs a simple but effective approach for conducting Proof of Reserves which
significantly reduces our counterparty risk as the custodian of the reserve assets.
● Tether issuance or redemption will not face any pricing or liquidity constraints. Users can buy or sell
as many tethers as they want, quickly, and with very low fees.
● Tethers will not face any market risks such as Black Swan events, liquidity crunches, etc as 5
reserves are maintained in a onetoone ratio rather than relying on market forces.
● Tether’s onetoone backing implementation is easier for nontechnical users to understand as
opposed to collateralization techniques or derivative strategies.
At any given time the balance of fiat currency held in our reserves will be equal to (or greater than) the
number of tethers in circulation. This simple configuration most easily supports a reliable Proof of Reserves
process; a process which is fundamental to maintaining the priceparity between tethers in circulation and
the underlying fiat currency held in reserves. In this paper we provide evidence that shows exchange and 6
4 More Bitcoin 2.0 protocols will come soon, like Ripple, Nxt, etc
5 See Appendix, section: Market Risk Examples
6 See section: Proof of Solvency Process
4
wallet audits (in their current state) are very unreliable (i.e. flaws in Proof of Solvency[6] methods) and
instead propose that exchanges and wallets outsource the custody of user funds to us via tethers.
Users can purchase tethers from Tether.to (our webwallet) or from supported exchanges such as Bitfinex
who support tethers as a deposit and withdrawal method. Users can also transact and store tethers with any
Omni Layer enabled wallet like Ambisafe, Holy Transaction or Omni Wallet. Other exchanges, wallets, and
merchants are encouraged to reach out to us about integrating tether as a surrogate for traditional fiat
payment methods.
We recognize that our implementation isn’t perfectly decentralized since Tether Limited must act as a 7
centralized custodian of reserve assets (albeit tethers in circulation exist as a decentralized digital currency).
However, we believe this implementation sets the foundation for building future innovations that will
eliminate these weaknesses, create a robust platform for new products and services, and support the growth
and utility of the Bitcoin blockchain over the long run. Some of these innovations include:
● Mobile payment facilitation between users and other parties, including other users and merchants
● Instant or nearinstant fiat value transfer between decentralized parties (such as multiple
exchanges)
● Introduction to the use of smart contracts and multisignature capabilities to further improve the
general security process, Proof of Reserves, and enable new features.
Technology Stack and Processes
Each tether issued into circulation will be backed in a onetoone ratio with the equivalent amount of
corresponding fiat currency held in reserves by Hong Kong based Tether Limited. As the custodian of the
backing asset we are acting as a trusted third party responsible for that asset. This risk is mitigated by a
simple implementation that collectively reduces the complexity of conducting both fiat and crypto audits
while increasing the security, provability, and transparency of these audits.
Tether Technology Stack
The stack has 3 layers, and numerous features, best understood via a diagram
7 See section: Implementation Weaknesses
5
Here is a review of each layer.
1) The first layer is the Bitcoin blockchain. The Tether transactional ledger is embedded in the Bitcoin
blockchain as metadata via the embedded consensus system, Omni.
2) The second layer is the Omni Layer protocol. Omni is a foundational technology that can:
a) Grant (create) and revoke (destroy) digital tokens represented as metadata embedded in
the Bitcoin blockchain; in this case, fiatpegged digital tokens, tethers.
b) Track and report the circulation of tethers via Omnichest.info (Omni asset ID #31, for
example, represents TetherUSD) and Omnicore API.
c) Enable users to transact and store tethers and other assets/tokens in a:
i) p2p, pseudoanonymous, cryptographically secure environment.
ii) opensource, browserbased, encrypted webwallet: Omni Wallet.
iii) multisignature and offline cold storagesupporting system
3) The third layer is Tether Limited, our business entity primarily responsible for:
a) Accepting fiat deposits and issuing the corresponding tethers
b) Sending fiat withdrawals and revoking the corresponding tethers
c) Custody of the fiat reserves that back all tethers in circulation
6
d) Publicly reporting Proof of Reserves and other audit results
e) Initiating and managing integrations with existing Bitcoin/blockchain wallets, exchanges,
and merchants
f) Operating Tether.to, a webwallet which allows users to send, receive, store, and convert
tethers conveniently.
Flow of Funds Process
There are five steps in the lifecycle of a tether, best understood via a diagram.
Step 1 User deposits fiat currency into Tether Limited's bank account.
Step 2 Tether Limited generates and credits the user's tether account. Tethers enter circulation. Amount of
fiat currency deposited by user = amount of tethers issued to user (i.e. 10k USD deposited = 10k tetherUSD
issued).
7
Step 3 Users transact with tethers . The user can transfer, exchange, and store tethers via a p2p 8
opensource, pseudoanonymous, Bitcoinbased platform.
Step 4 The user deposits tethers with Tether Limited for redemption into fiat currency.
Step 5 Tether Limited destroys the tethers and sends fiat currency to the user’s bank account.
Users can obtain tethers outside of the aforementioned process via an exchange or another individual. Once
a tether enters circulation it can be traded freely between any business or individual. For example, users can
purchase tethers from Bitfinex, with more exchanges to follow soon.
The main concept to be conveyed by the Flow of Funds diagram is that Tether Limited is the only party who
can issue tethers into circulation (create them) or take them out of circulation (destroy them). This is the
main process by which the system solvency is maintained.
Proof of Reserves Process
Proof of Solvency, Proof of Reserves, RealTime Transparency, and other similar phrases have been
growing and resonating across the cryptocurrency industry.
Exchange and wallets audits, in their current form, are very unreliable. Insolvency has occurred numerous
times in the Bitcoin ecosystem, either via hacks, mismanagement, or outright fraud. Users must be diligent
with their exchange selection and vigilant in their use of exchanges. Even then, a savvy user will not be able
to fully eliminate the risks. Further, there are exchange users like traders and businesses who must keep
nontrivial fiat balances in exchanges at all times. In financial language, this is known as the “counterparty
risk” of storing value with a third party.
We believe it’s safe to conclude that exchange and wallet audits in their current form are not very reliable.
These processes do not guarantee users that a custodian or exchange is solvent. Although there have been
great contributions to improving the exchange audit processes, like the Merkle tree approach[6], major flaws
still remain. 9
Tether’s Proof of Reserves configuration is novel because it simplifies the process of proving that the total
number of tethers in circulation (liabilities) are always fully backed by an equal amount of fiat currency held
8 See benefits of using tethers in the section: Main Applications
9 See section: Audit Flaws: Exchanges and Wallets
8
in reserve (assets). In our configuration, each tetherUSD in circulation represents one US dollar held in our
reserves (i.e. a onetoone ratio) which means the system is fully reserved when the sum of all tethers in
existence (at any point in time) is exactly equal to the balance of USD held in our reserve. Since tethers live
on the Bitcoin blockchain, the provability and accounting of tethers at any given point in time is trivial.
Conversely, the corresponding total amount of USD held in our reserves is proved by publishing the bank
balance and undergoing periodic audits by professionals. Find this implementation further detailed below:
● Tether Limited issues all tethers via the Omni Layer protocol. Omni operates on top of the Bitcoin
blockchain and therefore all issued, redeemed, and existing tethers, including transactional history,
are publicly auditable via the tools provided at Omnichest.info.
○ The Omnichest.info asset ID for tetherUSD is #31.
■ Here is a link: http://omnichest.info/lookupsp.aspx?sp=31
○ Let the total number of tethers issued under this asset ID be denoted as TUSDissue
○ Let the total number of tethers redeemed under this asset ID be denoted as TUSDredeem
○ Let the total number of tethers in circulation at any time be denoted as TUSD
■ TUSD = TUSDissue TUSDredeem
■ TUSD = “Total Property Tokens” @ http://omnichest.info/lookupsp.aspx?sp=31
● Tether Limited has a bank account which will receive and send fiat currency to users who
purchase/redeem tethers directly with us.
○ Let the total amount deposited into this account be denoted as DUSDdepo
○ Let the total amount withdrawn from this account be denoted as DUSDwithd
○ Let the dollar balance of this bank account be denoted as DUSD
■ DUSD = DUSDdepo DUSDwithd
● Each tether issued will be backed by the equivalent amount of currency unit (one tetherUSD equals
one dollar). By combining the above crypto and fiat accounting processes, we conclude the
“Solvency Equation” for the Tether System.
○ The Solvency Equation is simply TUSD = DUSD.
○ Every tether issued or redeemed, as publicly recorded by the Bitcoin blockchain will
correspond to a deposit or withdrawal of funds from the bank account.
○ The provability of TUSD relies on the Bitcoin blockchain as discussed previously.
○ The provability of DUSD will rely on several processes:
■ We publish the bank account balance on our website’s Transparency page.
■ Professional auditors will regularly verify, sign, and publish our underlying bank
balance and financial transfer statement.
9
Users will be able to view this information from our Transparency Page, which will look like:
For clarity, we’d like to acknowledge that the Tether System is different than the Tether.to webwallet in 10
terms of Proof of Reserves. In this paper, we mostly focus on Proof of Reserves for the Tether System; i.e.
all tethers in circulation at any point in time. The Tether.to wallet is a consumer facing webwallet operating
on closedsource code and centralized servers. Conducting a Proof of Reserves for this wallet is
fundamentally different than what we’ve outlined for the Tether System.
We’re planning the deployment of a PoRbased transparency solution for the Tether.to wallet. We believe it
will be the most advanced PoR system in existence today. It overcomes almost all of the challenges outlined
in the appendix on this topic. Mind you, users can always secure tethers through managing the private 11
keys themselves or through Omni Wallet.
Implementation Weaknesses
We understand that our implementation doesn’t immediately create a fully trustless cryptocurrency system.
Mainly because users must trust Tether Limited and our corresponding legacy banking institution to be the
custodian of the reserve assets. However, almost all exchanges and wallets (assuming they hold USD/fiats)
are subject to the same weaknesses. Users of these services are already subject to these risks. Here is a
summary of the weaknesses in our approach:
● We could go bankrupt
● Our bank could go insolvent
● Our bank could freeze or confiscate the funds
● We could abscond with the reserve funds
10 See Glossary of Terms
11 See Audit Flaws: Exchanges and Wallets
10
● Recentralized of risk to a single point of failure
Observe that almost all digital currency exchanges and wallets (assuming they hold USD/fiat) already face
many of these challenges. Therefore, users of these services are already subject to these risks. Below we
describe how each of these concerns are being addressed.
We could go bankrupt In this case, the business entity Tether Limited would go bankrupt but client funds
would be safe, and subsequently, all tethers will remain redeemable. Most security breaches on Bitcoin
businesses have targeted cryptocurrencies rather than bank accounts. Since all tethers exist on the Bitcoin
blockchain they can be stored by individuals directly through securing their own private keys.
Our bank could go insolvent This is a risk faced by all users of the legacy financial system and by all
exchange operators. Tether Limited currently has accounts with Cathay United Bank and Hwatai Bank in
Taiwan, both of whom are aware and confident that Tether’s business model is acceptable. Additional
banking partners are being established in other jurisdictions to further mitigate this concern.
Our bank could freeze or confiscate the funds Our banks are aware of the nature of Bitcoin and are
accepting of Bitcoin businesses. They also provide banking services to some of the largest Bitcoin
exchanges globally. The KYC/AML processes we follow are also used by the other digital currency
exchanges they currently bank. They have assured us we are in full compliance . 12
We could abscond with the reserve assets The corporate charter is public as well as the business 13
owners names, locations, and reputations. Ownership of the account is legally bound to the corporate
charter. Any transfers in or out of the bank account will have the associated traces and are bound by rigid
internal policies.
Recentralization of risk to a single point of fai프로젝트로 돌아가기