bitpro가 원문에서 글자만 모은 내용이에요. 표·그림·수식은 빠지거나 깨질 수 있어요. 전체 11쪽 중 1쪽
ORBS
POSITION PAPER
V1.7
orbs.com
Public blockchain infrastructure for established consumer applications
orbs.com
V1.7
Position Paper
PUBLIC BLOCKC HAIN INFRASTRUCTURE
FO R ESTABLISHED CONSUMER APPLICATIONS
Motivation 5
The Orbs Vision 5
Purpose of This Paper 5
Introduction 7
Decentralized Consensus 7
The Blockchain to Rule All Blockchains 8
A Requirement Driven Approach 8
The Era of Decentralized Consumer Apps 9
Why Do Consumer Apps Decentralize 10
Kin by Kik Interactive - a Case Study 11
Target Audience for Orbs 14
Building Through Design Partners 14
Infrastructure for Decentralized Apps 16
First Generation (Bitcoin) 16
Second Generation (Ethereum) 16
Third Generation (Orbs) 17
Centralized Infrastructure as a Service 17
Lessons in Pragmatic Systems Design 18
The Orbs Platform 20
Overview 20
Decentralized-Consensus Compute 20
Decentralized-Consensus Storage 20
Consensus as a Service 21
Design Principles 21
Service Level Agreement (SLA) 21
Consumer Scale 22
Consumer Protection and Regulation 22
Modern Deployment Paradigms 22
1
Network Entities 24
Consumers 24
Apps 25
Consensus Nodes 25
Audit Nodes 26
The Orbs Ecosystem 27
Core Infrastructure 27
Specialized Infrastructure 27
Infrastructure Marketplace 28
The ORBS Token 29
Overview 29
Billing Subsystem 29
Programmable Fee Models 30
Economy Incentives 30
Token Implementation 32
Architecture 33
To Fork or Not to Fork 33
Polyglot Microservices 33
Specification as Code 34
Meta Programming 35
Universal Addressing 36
Network-Owned Secrets 36
Orbs Architecture 38
Infrastructure Layers and Services 38
Resources Pools vs. Virtual Chains 40
Consensus 42
Pragmatic Decentralization and Trust 42
Healthy Distribution of Power 43
Real-time Validation Rights 43
Governance Decision Rights 43
2
Proof of Work
45
Proof of Stake
46
Permissioned Models
47
A Layered Approach
48
Helix Consensus Algorithm
49
Finality of Consensus Results
49
Ordering of Opaque Transactions
50
Separation of Ordering From Validation
50
Fast Consensus by Committees
50
Efficient Leader Election by Randomized Sort
50
Node Reputation System
51
Service Level Agreement (SLA)
52
Industry Standard
52
CryptoKitties - a Case Study
52
SLA in a Decentralized Context
54
Predictable Fee Models
55
Dedicated, Reserved and On-Demand Resources
56
Virtual Chains and Blockchain Virtualization
56
Design Principles
58
Consumer Scale
59
Throughput and Latency
59
Scalable Fee Models
60
Ever-Growing Storage
61
Light Clients
62
Separation of Ordering and Validation
62
Efficient Consensus via Committees
64
Sharding via Blockchain Virtualization
65
Elastic Capacity
66
Consumer Protection and Regulation
67
Regulatory Evolution
67
3
Established Consumer Brands 67
Consumer Protection 68
Decentralized Ledger Security 68
Censorship and Front-running 70
Compliance Protocols 71
Privacy and AML 71
The White Chain 72
Modern Deployment Paradigms 73
Network Governance 73
Evergreen Nodes 74
Gradual Migrations 75
Upgradable Contracts 76
Multi Chain Hybrids 76
Polyglot Cross-Chain Contracts 78
Designing for Consumers 79
Brands and Trust 79
Mobile and Web Clients 79
Consumer Patterns of Network Access 80
Infrastructure Implications of Churn 81
Consumer Apps and Open Source 81
The Problem of Private Keys 82
Decentralized Secret Bearing 83
The Orbs Federation 84
Pre-launch Design Partners 84
Governance 85
Definitions 86
Legal Disclaimer 87
4
Motivation
The Orbs Vision
By 2020, large scale consumer applications will have transitioned to the blockchain, bringing
decentralized services to billions worldwide. We see the beginning of this trend today as more
and more established consumer brands– Kodak, Kik and Telegram – launch new,
decentralized businesses and reinvent themselves in this space.
The masses of mainstream consumers present a unique combination of challenges that
general-purpose blockchain solutions find difficult to adequately meet. We see a need to
provide these decentralized consumer apps with a hybrid infrastructure solution that
addresses the multitude of requirements for making this transition possible and seamlessly
integrates them into the emerging standard blockchain infrastructure.
Until now, established consumer brands have been forced to either avoid blockchain
technology altogether; defocus and develop their own custom infrastructure in-house; or settle
for off-the-shelf solutions that don’t scale, fee structures that break business models and a
degree of liability that a real-world business cannot accept.
Orbs mitigates these problems by augmenting current blockchain solutions such as
Ethereum. Rather than competing with current protocols, Orbs complements them in order to
bring scalability to decentralized apps without reinventing the wheel - especially where things
were done well. .
The Orbs project envisions complementing the de facto, emergent blockchain standard of
Ethereum by functioning as a second layer hybrid. Ethereum has unmatched combination of
decentralization, liquidity and ecosystem, yet, an ethereum token requires an overlay network
optimised for micro-transactions in order to perform high-scale and low-fee operations.
Adopting Orbs alongside Ethereum allows DApps to enjoy the best of both chains: unmatched
security, liquidity and ecosystem integration, together with low-fees, production-ready
scalability and suitable fee structure. This combination of Ethereum and Orbs is the optimal
solution for applications with millions of users looking to adopt blockchain, today
5
MOTIVATION
Through innovations like blockchain virtualization (a.k.a., virtual chains) and randomized
proof-of-stake (RPoS), Orbs will blend the common requirements for security with demand for
speed both, while compromising on neither.
We envision a fully decentralized public platform that put the needs of app developers first, by
design. Where consumer brands feel comfortable operating nodes and taking part in a
balanced, decentralized ecosystem, one that makes this transition easier for the industry as a
whole. The platform will be complete with a core product experience inspired by
well-established infrastructure solutions such as Amazon Web Services (AWS) and speak in
familiar terminology like Service Level Agreements (SLA) and dedicated resources.
Purpose of This Paper
We see a stark difference between a white paper and a position paper. A white paper takes a
complex problem and revolves around the solution to that problem. A position paper revolves
around the problem itself. It discusses the problem and provides an arguable opinion on how
it should be approached. This paper is designed to be the position paper for Orbs - discussing
the problem of consumer-oriented blockchain infrastructure and how we approach it.
There’s a tendency in the blockchain space to launch projects with a celebratory technical
white paper. We believe that solving complex problems requires a mix of multiple solutions
over time and that these solutions evolve. Accordingly, the Orbs project will publish a set of
white papers, each dealing with a different aspect of the solution. These white papers will
evolve; some may become obsolete and some may be replaced with different ones, as we
continue to better understand the problems we’re facing.
Nevertheless, we don’t believe a white paper is the first piece of the puzzle. The first piece is
articulating the problem, explaining exactly what we’re trying to solve and why - a stable guide
in the turbulent waters of momentary innovation. This position paper will carve the specific
niche in blockchain infrastructure that the Orbs platform is focused on. It will then go into
details regarding the main requirements we’re optimizing towards and the various tradeoffs
we’re prepared to make. This paper will also introduce some of the solutions we’re working on,
with dedicated technical white papers to be published separately about each one.
6
Introduction
Decentralized Consensus
There’s no argument that cryptocurrencies have an exciting air of disruption about them, with
the potential to change core aspects of everyday life, like creating programmable economies.
It’s difficult to measure the degree of disruption objectively but it is possible to examine the
indicators that historically coincide with profound technological innovation.
One of the largest disruptions of modern time was without a doubt the birth of the Internet,
which created the ability to interconnect the world digitally in a matter of milliseconds. An
indicator coinciding with this event was the dot-com bubble of 1997-2001, a period of
excessive market speculation and wild growth. There are similarities between this period to
today’s crypto bubble and evidence that the crypto bubble is even greater in magnitude . While 1
we should approach bubbles cautiously, they are a requirement for extreme growth over a
short period of time. Many companies did not survive the collapse of the dot-com bubble, but
the giants of today’s digital world, companies like Amazon and Google, emerged from the
wreckage. We believe that the key for doing the same is planting firm roots in substantiated
value and ignoring hype in general. These are guiding principles for Orbs and will be covered in
greater depth throughout this paper.
If the Internet was the technological breakthrough driving the dot-com era, what is the
underlying technology driving today’s crypto era? Cryptocurrencies are not a technology unto
themselves but applications of a technology. This technology is decentralized consensus.
Decentralized systems are distributed systems where a group of independent but equally
privileged nodes operate on local information to accomplish global goals. These systems lack
a central controller that exercises governance, supervision and control over the system, thus
allowing power to be distributed over the network in a more uniform and fair manner.
Distributed systems are not new, with applications such as Napster driving the peer-to-peer
boom of the early 2000s.
1 http://cnbc.com/2017/08/31/bitcons-nearly-five-fold-climb-in-2017-looks-similar-to-tech-bubble-surge
7
INTROD UCTION
Consensus
is
a
shared
view
of
reality
that
is
agreed
upon
between
different
parts
of
a
system.
Consider
the
most
trivial
example
of
a
consumer
application
-
an
instant
messenger
where
users
can
chat
amongst
themselves.
This
system
requires
consensus
to
operate,
allowing
every
user
to
authenticate
and
speak
only
on
their
own
behalf.
All
members
must
reach
a
shared
view
of
reality
regarding
which
user
is
which,
who
owns
every
username
and
so
forth.
The
consensus
property
is
very
easy
to
achieve
in
centralized
systems,
where
a
single
governing body is trusted by all members to define this shared reality.
Whereas
decentralized
systems
are
easy
to
build
without
consensus
and
consensus
is
easy
to
achieve
in
centralized
systems,
maintaining
both
properties
in
the
same
system
proves
difficult.
This
is
the
underlying
innovation
in
the
field
of
decentralized
consensus.
The
ability
to
build
decentralized
systems
where
a
group
of
independent
but
equally
privileged
nodes
are
able
to
reach
a
shared
view
of
reality.
Cryptocurrencies
are
an
excellent
example
of
an
application
that
requires
such
a
system,
where
agreement
upon
the
ledger
of
transactions
and
balances can be reached without a governing body.
The Blockchain to Rule All Blockchains
The
term
blockchain
originates
from
a
core
implementation
construct
of
cryptocurrencies
such
as
Bitcoin
and
refers
to
a
continuously
growing
list
of
records,
called
blocks,
which
are
linked
and
secured
using
cryptography.
This
chain
of
blocks
holds
the
journal
of
all
transactions
in
the
network
and
forms
the
distributed
ledger.
The
term
blockchain
has
become
synonymous
with
the
core
technology
providing
the
infrastructure
for
such
applications.
Building
the
next
generation
of
blockchain
infrastructure
has
become
a
fertile
ground
for
innovation
and
dozens
of
teams
are
currently
racing
to
deliver
the
“best”
one.
Many
of
these
projects
position
themselves,
sometimes
even
explicitly,
as
candidates
for
the
blockchain
to
rule all blockchains
. We believe that this mentality is flawed.
History
shows
that
silver
bullets
are
rare:
complex
problems
are
not
solved
by
a
single,
simple
solution.
We
believe
that
there
will
be
no
blockchain
to
rule
all
blockchains.
A
general-purpose
blockchain
can
only
optimize
for
the
lowest
common
denominator.
.
Similar
to
the
internet,
the
future
of
blockchain
infrastructure
will
include
a
large
number
of
systems
working
together,
each
specifically
designed
and
optimized
for
fundamentally
different
use
cases,
making
them
a powerful and efficient hybrid.
These
systems
complement
each
other.
To
that
end,
we
are
taking
a
different
design
approach.
For
us,
the
first
step
towards
building
a
business-grade
blockchain
is
articulating
a
clear
use
case
-
defining
a
real
world
need
that
this
blockchain
infrastructure
is
attempting
to
resolve and determining whether or not a market for this need actually exists.
8
A Requirement-Driven Approach
The first question asked when presented with a new blockchain infrastructure is “what’s the
key differentiator?” More often than not, the answer to this question is a groundbreaking new
algorithm, a breakthrough based on years of academic research, that takes some arbitrary
narrow aspect of the problem and revolutionizes the industry by addressing it in an innovative
way. That’s not how we believe Orbs should be built.
We’ve decided early on that we’re going to take a more humble approach. We’re not going to
start with the solution; instead, we’re going to start with the problem. Our first step would be to
outline clear needs that current blockchain infrastructure solutions were not designed to
adequately meet. Next, find actual businesses, real customers for this missing infrastructure.
Ideally, the next step would be to work side by side with some of these businesses. In the
beginning, attempt with them to rely on existing blockchain solutions for their production use
case; we need this process to understand the practical limitations of these solutions, where
the actual challenges stem from, which features solve real problems and which are merely
nice to have.
Our mission, apparently, has become to find design partners.
This would make Orbs a requirement-driven blockchain. Consider this as a key differentiator.
The initial design should emerge in an iterative manner with each piece added only to resolve
the most pressing requirement of our design partners. Our experience from building
production systems in the pre-blockchain age teaches us that this approach is more likely to
deliver superior and pragmatic solutions. It is definitely more efficient than concocting a
solution first, designing a system around it and then scrambling to find a market fit.
A good relevant example is the emergence of the modern cloud, the de facto standard for
infrastructure as a service today. AWS, the first and leading cloud provider, emerged from 2
Amazon’s pressing e-commerce needs for solid internal systems to deal with the hyper
growth it was experiencing.
The Era of Decentralized Apps
The crypto space is growing rapidly with more and more businesses joining the ecosystem
every day. The first wave of businesses included mostly early adopters, newly formed
crypto-first businesses or small existing businesses looking to experiment with the
technology. The consumer apps among them, products like Steemit, Gnosis and Augur,
achieved very mild success . This is not surprising since consumer markets are notoriously 3
2 https://techcrunch.com/2016/07/02/andy-jassys-brief-history-of-the-genesis-of-aws/
3 https://steemit.com/statistics/@arcange/steemit-statistics-20171117-en
9
difficult to penetrate, especially when dealing with complex technologies that even the tech
savvy find challenging to master.
We’re starting to see the next wave of businesses join this maturing ecosystem. This wave
consists of established businesses making the transition to blockchain, whether it’s
established venture capital firms joining the crypto funding landscape or established
companies looking to tokenize. The most interesting among these are mature consumer
brands - companies like Telegram, Kakao, LINE, or Kik Interactive, with millions of end users,
companies that have successfully penetrated consumer markets outside the blockchain
world. The transition for these companies is slow and far from straightforward, mostly
because they have so much to lose if the foundations turn out to be inadequate for their
needs.
It is estimated that the total number of active cryptocurrency end users in the world is 6
million as of 2017. This figure is mind boggling in proportion to the total market cap of 4
cryptocurrencies in 2017, which has surpassed 600 billion USD . It is up to these established 5
consumer brands to make the next giant leap for cryptocurrencies and decentralized
technologies and deliver them to the masses.
Why Do Consumer Apps Decentralize
Traditionally, established consumer brands have followed a very strict centralized model. The
question of their motives comes to mind as more and more of these applications take parts of
their business and decentralize them over the blockchain. Critics may claim that the
opportunity to raise funds provides a strong enough incentive for these brands to join this
space. Nonetheless, we have a less cynical perspective which reveals a multitude of different
reasons.
Tokens are becoming the standard for the transfer of value in the digital world. They are
immune to many of the drawbacks that payments in fiat currencies face in a digital setting.
Tokens can be shared instantaneously across borders, removing the need for separate
payment solutions per geography. Businesses can receive tokens directly with minimal
integration, cutting out middlemen such as payment providers and the hefty fees they charge.
Tokens are easier to secure, reducing fees that are traditionally high to offset chargebacks
and fraud. Tokens are also well-suited for flexible payment models such as microtransactions
and can be incorporated seamlessly into larger systems through their programmable
interfaces.
Tokenization also provides the means to create handcrafted micro economies that obey a set
of predefined rules. This allows to design controlled environments where consumer apps can
monetize effectively. Monetization has always been difficult for consumer apps, many of
4 https://jbs.cam.ac.uk/faculty-research/centres/alternative-finance/publications/global-cryptocurrency
5 https://coinmarketcap.com/charts/
10
which
must
resort
to
selling
the
attention
and
data
of
their
consumers
to
advertisers
and
marketers.
The
ad-based
approach
has
resulted
in
advantages
almost
exclusively
for
the
largest applications, concentrating wealth and power in the hands of the few.
Token
economies
today
hold
billions
of
dollars
in
value.
Securing
so
much
value
on
centralized
infrastructure
is
costly
because
criminals
have
huge
incentive
in
breaking
into
it.
Decentralized
ledgers
are
easier
to
secure
because
no
single
entity
can
manipulate
the
ledger,
and
in
particular,
nobody
with
access
to
the
company’s
servers
can
use
this
access
to
steal
money
from
consumers.
In
addition,
multiple
parties
constantly
audit
the
integrity
of
the
ledger and can identify discrepancies from the agreed upon protocol.
Tokenization
also
allows
consumer
apps
to
distribute
the
economic
value
created
in
them,
particularly
to
their
users.
This
ensures
that
users
are
fairly
compensated
for
the
value
they
create
within
the
app.
This
model
resonates
well
in
an
environment
where
monetizat프로젝트로 돌아가기