bitpro가 원문에서 글자만 모은 내용이에요. 표·그림·수식은 빠지거나 깨질 수 있어요. 전체 11쪽 중 2쪽
ion
is
normally not in the best interest of the consumer.
Another
benefit
of
decentralization
for
consumer
apps
is
the
ability
to
band
companies
together
as
equals.
The
consumer
space
is
slowly
consolidating
into
the
hands
of
the
giants
like
Facebook
and
Google.
Decentralization
provides
the
means
for
the
long
tail
of
companies
to
align
together
and
create
combined
ecosystems
where
no
single
entity
can
skew
the
balance
of
power
in
its
favor.
These
ecosystems
can
even
carry
on
after
some
of
the
individual
companies
cease
to
exist,
allowing
consumers
to
have
direct
ownership
of
the
value
they hold, without relying on the services of others.
Kin by Kik Interactive - a Case Study
Kik
Interactive
Ltd.
is
an
established
consumer
brand
based
in
Canada
and
the
US
with
the
6
mission
of
connecting
the
world
through
chat.
Kik
Interactive
has
over
150
employees
in
4
offices
around
the
world
and
is
a
member
of
the
Fortune
Unicorn
List
of
private
companies
with
valuations
of
over
one
billion
dollars.
Its
main
consumer
product
is
Kik
Messenger
,
a
7
popular
mobile
chat
app
and
the
fifth
most-searched
term
in
the
iOS
App
Store
.
Kik
has
been
8
operating for 9 years and has raised $120 million to date from private venture capital.
Kik
is
the
classic
example
of
a
consumer
product
created
with
the
optimistic
vision
of
a
fully
connected
world,
brought
on
by
the
technological
disruptions
of
the
dot-com
and
mobile
eras.
It’s
a
world
where
a
group
of
friends,
at
the
University
of
Waterloo
in
this
case,
can
band
together and create an app in their garage that will eventually find its way to 100 million users.
Over
the
years,
Kik
has
been
searching
for
a
sustainable
monetization
model
that
does
not
compromise
user
experience
or
privacy.
Nevertheless,
it
is
operating
in
a
world
where
digital
services
have
been
organized
largely
around
an
attention-based
economy
and
monetization
6
https://www.kik.com/
7
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kik_Messenger
8
https://www.kinecosystem.org/static/files/Kin_Whitepaper_V1_English.pdf
11
through advertising. The problem is, that the online advertising market is structured in a very
unfair way: bigger players have more data on their users, and are therefore able to sell
advertisements at much higher prices. This means that smaller apps don’t enjoy revenues
that are proportional to their size. Instead, revenue resembles a pattern of exponential growth:
When the market is structured in this way, a very large share of the ads market go to the few
big platforms who also enjoy the highest profit margins. They then use their market
dominance to set the market prices to a level that ensures smaller platforms don’t make a
profit, but the bigger ones still do. This creates a long tail of small products unable to sustain
themselves and a small number of extremely profitable giants.
This revenue graph means that Kik will eventually struggle to become profitable. Despite the
odds and reaching an impressive number of users, Kik was struggling to sustain itself. This
problem is not unique to Kik. Almost every digital service that sits on the “wrong” side of the
exponent - which unfortunately includes almost everybody due to the way exponents behave -
struggles to monetize. This is not surprising, as the 1% usually have 99% of the power. That’s
just how the world works.
This problem worsens every year. One could say that the exponent is getting steeper. The
world is consolidating, making it harder and harder to compete with the giants and less likely
that a group of university friends trying to change the world will be successful. The result is
disadvantageous for consumers as consolidation reduces market competition and hurts
innovation.
Kik Interactive has taken on the challenge to change this reality. Many have tried and failed to
solve the monetization problem of consumer apps in the last decade, but Kik believes that
only a disruption in the magnitude of the one that created the Internet will suffice. This
12
disruption is finally upon us: Cryptocurrencies, or the technology of decentralized consensus,
to be exact.
With this mission in mind, Kik Interactive has launched Kin, a decentralized ecosystem of
digital services for daily life based on a new token named KIN.
This token makes a new economy possible where digital services can monetize without direct
reliance on advertising. The Kin white paper sets forth the vision for the Kin Ecosystem, of 9
aligning incentives of developers and consumers through the Kin Rewards Engine (KRE) . 10
Kik’s Token Distribution Event (TDE) was held in September 2017, selling almost $100 million
in KIN tokens.
We can use our graph example from before to demonstrate the general motivation behind Kin:
The red line in the graph above designates present economic behavior. The blue line is what a
fair economy would look like. If I am a digital service developer with a service that is 1000
times less popular than Facebook, I expect to make 1/1000 of Facebook’s revenue. This
would mean that I am still able to sustain myself because my company is also 1/1000 of the
size of Facebook Inc. While it is true that the 1% usually have 99% of the power, in this case,
the 99% would prefer to move to a world that behaves like the line in blue.
Through the Kin Reward Engine, developers of digital services are incentivized in relation to
their contribution to the overall adoption of Kin. Kin thus constitutes a powerful tool to change
the natural behavior of the economy that results in a linear relationship between the number of
users and revenue.
9 https://www.kinecosystem.org/static/files/Kin_Whitepaper_V1_English.pdf
10 https://kinecosystem.org/static/files/Kin_Rewards_Engine_RFC.pdf
13
This also explains why consumer apps favor decentralization. The KIN token economy could
generate substantial value. Securing a central ledger from theft, hacking or embezzlement is
difficult and expensive. With a decentralized ledger, no one can manipulate the ledger by
gaining access to the company’s servers. This provides a greater degree of protection to its
users. In addition, the success of the Kin ecosystem depends on the number of digital
services that band together. Cooperation between competing digital services would have been
next to impossible without creating a decentralized equilibrium where all parties are equal.
Target Audience for Orbs
The Orbs platform is focused on providing blockchain infrastructure for large-scale consumer
apps. Successful digital brands in the consumer space have access to millions of end users,
usually through websites and mobile apps. The majority of these consumer brands are
already established and have amassed their user base before the blockchain era. The Orbs
platform provides the infrastructure for these consumer brands to build emerging
decentralized businesses for the benefit of their users, such as the ability to utilize blockchain
technology, tokenize, integrate smart contracts and more.
Working with a distinct and well-defined target audience also means the requirements and
goals are clear. Orbs doesn’t try to be a general-purpose blockchain, it’s built from the ground
up for the consumer app market and the very specific set of requirements it entails.
Building Through Design Partners
Orbs is being designed using a strict requirements-driven approach. The founding team has
been working closely with some of the leading consumer brands that are in the process of
transitioning to the blockchain and has been relying on them as design partners. By choosing
partners representing different business domains, we are ensuring that the requirements we
are exposed to cover the essentials for a truly practical solution.
In the domain of social/messaging, we are working with Kin by Kik Interactive. The Orbs team
has been advising the Kin TDE from the beginning and some of its key members have been
employed by the Kin engineering team on its journey to implement Kin using existing
infrastructure solutions. Kik has been vocal about the challenges identified throughout the
process which became a cornerstone to the Orbs design. Orbs maintains a close 11
relationship with the Kin engineering team, cooperating both on architecture and
development.
In the domain of payments/settlements, we are working with Zooz Labs and PumaPay.
Founded in 2010, Zooz is a leading solution provider for cross-border payments with
customers such as Wix.com, Burberry and Gett. Zooz Labs is introducing a protocol for
blockchain-based cross-border payments in prevailing consumer-oriented mobile wallet apps.
11 https://medium.com/kin-contributors/kins-blockchain-considerations-ebd0b60aebd5
14
PumaPay is working on a blockchain-based pull-payment protocol - a decentralized alternative
to PayPal. Among its launch partnerships are businesses interacting with hundreds of millions
of users and processing billions of dollars worth of payments, such as lifestyle media
company FashionTV and adult media giant Vivid Entertainment.
In the domain of online advertising, we are working with Zinc - a blockchain-based advertising
protocol that improves efficiency in the ad industry by increasing user data transparency,
delivering a better user experience, and removing the impact of bad actors. Zinc is working
with IronSource as a design partner, one of the largest advertising technology providers in the
world. IronSource, founded in 2011, has a global reach of over 1 billion users a month, giving
Zinc the potential to exponentially scale to become the next advertising protocol standard.
Another notable domain is business intelligence. Our team has been cooperating closely with
Endor, a business intelligence technology vendor, with customers such as Coca-Cola, Walmart
and MasterCard. While traditionally not a consumer-oriented domain, Endor is bringing
predictive business analytics to end users, developing a decentralized platform with a
Google-like interface for AI queries.
Together, these companies and their partners represent a network containing hundreds of
millions of consumers, billions of app installs and billions of USD in annual revenues. Our team
has been working closely with these projects since their inception, helping design their
solutions both on and off the Orbs network.
15
Infrastructure for Decentralized Apps
First Generation (Bitcoin)
Bitcoin is considered the first generation of blockchain technology. The building blocks used
to create Bitcoin, such as the concept of Proof of Work, have predated Bitcoin by several
years. Nevertheless, Bitcoin is unique in its combination of these elements to solve the
problem of consensus on a decentralized ledger in an open, streamlined, elegant and secure
way. The public success of Bitcoin should not be attributed to its underlying technology,
interesting as it may be, but to its product. After all, Bitcoin is primarily an application and not
an infrastructure. This application has been so successful, in fact, that cryptocurrency has
become the killer app for blockchain technology.
One of the greatest feats of Bitcoin is alleviating any doubt as to whether blockchain
technology is indeed working or that it is secure and solid enough to hold assets of great value
. Furthermore, it can be trusted to a greater degree than any infrastructure solution 12
previously offered by any authority. It did so in a remarkable way by creating an environment
free of central governance, where all nodes are equal but without assuming they are all
honest. And still, it successfully manages an entire financial system worth billions.
Bitcoin naturally has its flaws as a first generation technology. Problems like excessive fees,
long confirmation times and difficult upgrade politics are preventing the system from being
used in production for any purpose other than as an electronic alternative to stored gold.
Second Generation (Ethereum)
Ethereum is considered the second generation of blockchain technology. Its primary
innovation was the separation between the application and the infrastructure layers. Ethereum
has little application on its own, but it provides a solid base for developers to create their own
decentralized applications over the blockchain. This is done by writing smart contracts , 13
12 https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/bitcoin/
13 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smart_contract
16
INFRASTR UCTURE FOR D ECENTRALIZED APP S
immutable pieces of software running in a decentralized manner over all the nodes in the
network under the promise of full consensus upon the execution of its terms.
Before the age of Ethereum, decentralized applications like Bitcoin were implemented as a
monolith, mixing both the application and the custom-fitted infrastructure for running this
specific application. The boom of decentralized application development in recent years can
be largely attributed to this separation of application from its infrastructure, as the barriers for
their implementation have been greatly reduced.
Naturally, as the pioneering project to make this giant leap forward, significant parts of
Ethereum remain as working proofs of concept but ultimately, it was not designed to run
businesses with millions of users on production . Ethereum has become the de-facto 14
standard for issuing application tokens, and for good reason. It has an unmatched
combination of decentralization, liquidity, and ecosystem. However, it is plagued by high and
unpredictable gas fees, as well as a low TPS (transactions per second) capacity. An ethereum
token requires a second layer optimised for microtransactions in order to perform high-scale
and low-fee operations.
Third Generation (Orbs)
Now that the foundations of the technology have been firmly set, the race is on to create the
next generation of blockchain infrastructure that allows real-world businesses to decentralize.
The third generation of blockchain infrastructure projects will go beyond the smart contract
technology proof of concept and into practical business applications in real world production
environments. The question is no longer whether this is possible, but what’s the most efficient
way.
We’ve witnessed how wide the gap is between a platform’s readiness for use by early
adopters and being ripe for mainstream users and companies after working with the Kin
engineering team on bringing Kin to production over Ethereum . Ethereum itself is going 15
through transformations to evolve into a third generation project, with core changes like the
gradual switch to Proof-of-Stake (PoS). Other than that, the number of third generation
candidates is impressive, with excellent projects focusing on different aspects of the
challenge, like EOS and Cardano . 16 17
There isn’t one blockchain to rule all blockchains. We’re hopeful that many of these projects
will reach fruition and each provide a best of its class solution for a distinct scenario.
14 https://medium.com/kin-contributors/kins-blockchain-considerations-ebd0b60aebd5
15 https://medium.com/kin-contributors/ethereum-challenges-while-launching-iplv2-8a33e1ba5a64
16 https://eos.io/
17 https://whycardano.com/
17
Centralized Infrastructure as a Service
Solutions for Infrastructure as a Service (IaaS) for centralized apps have matured significantly
over the last 10 years. Leading cloud providers like Amazon Web Services (AWS) , Microsoft 18
Azure or Google Cloud Platform have become the de facto standard in the industry. There’s a
great deal that can be learned from these services when designing our IaaS solution for
decentralized apps.
Almost all established consumer apps use cloud services as their infrastructure for
centralized IT services. Just as companies like Airbnb , Netflix and Lyft rely on AWS to 19 20 21
provide the infrastructure for their centralized businesses, we expect companies with
decentralized applications to rely on the Orbs platform to provide infrastructure for their
decentralized businesses.
Another observation: emphasis on having a well-rounded product is sorely lacking in existing
blockchain infrastructure solutions. What exactly is a well-rounded product for a blockchain?
This question is often asked in emerging fields which have yet to produce concrete business
applications. Consider, for example, the question of fee structure. Should blockchain fees be
paid by the sender of a transaction or by its recipient? Or maybe by a third party? Should the
fee be paid per transaction or per month with a subscription? Should the fee be predictable
and constant or market-determined? These are all questions that have strong influence over
the product - how to design the user experience when working with the infrastructure.
It seems that so far, the answers to most of these questions in existing solutions did not start
from a product discussion, but from security, fairness or game theoretical considerations.
What would a real business using this infrastructure prefer? A consumer app may want to
subsidize its users’ infrastructure costs. In addition, it may probably want to plan the budget
for these expenditures in advance.
There’s rarely a need to reinvent the wheel: the product for decentralized infrastructure is not
materially different from that of centralized infrastructure like AWS. Mature platforms like
AWS provide us with practices that are proven after years of calibration to fit the needs of
actual businesses.
Lessons in Pragmatic Systems Design
We’ve made several observations that are important from a pragmatic standpoint from
working closely with our design partners on architecting an expansive decentralized system.
First, a decentralized system doesn’t need to be decentralized end-to-end. Depending on your
18 https://aws.amazon.com/
19 https://aws.amazon.com/solutions/case-studies/airbnb/
20 https://media.netflix.com/en/company-blog/completing-the-netflix-cloud-migration
21 https://aws.amazon.com/solutions/case-studies/lyft/
18
goals, significant parts of the system can remain centralized. This has a great effect on
efficiency since centralized infrastructure is usually significantly faster and cheaper than a
decentralized counterpart.
Consider an obvious example: a system that transacts video content securely over the
blockchain. A naive approach would be to store the video data on blockchain storage, but
doing so would be inefficient and immensely expensive. The system will perform better and be
cheaper to operate by orders of magnitude if the raw video data is stored on cheaper and
faster centralized storage and served through a CDN, while the blockchain is only used to
distribute hash codes and keys.
Another important observation is that real-life systems often span over more than one
blockchain. We’ve mentioned before that there’s no one blockchain to rule all blockchains.
Different blockchain implementations are better suited for different goals, even in the same
application.
Immediately after its TDE, Kin launched as an ERC20 token over Ethereum. After
understanding that Ethereum will not be able to hold the transaction throughput and fee
efficiency required for a consumer app with millions of transactions per day, the project
analyzed migrating to an optimized infrastructure solution - such as the Orbs platform. This
migration would have a negative effect on some existing users as ERC20 is currently better
integrated into the ecosystem of exchanges, wallets (including availability of hardware
wallets) and so forth. Whereas Orbs is a great consumer platform, Ethereum is currently better
suited for professional asset management and exchange. An ideal solution would be to enjoy
the benefits of both by making the token available on both platforms with two-way portability
using atomic swaps . 22
22 An exam프로젝트로 돌아가기