bitpro가 원문에서 글자만 모은 내용이에요. 표·그림·수식은 빠지거나 깨질 수 있어요. 전체 4쪽 중 3쪽
oughput as well as scalability to accommodate large
volumes of traffic and their dynamic change. However, public blockchains such as Ethereum currently fall
short when it comes to innately accommodating large volume of transactions. This is due to the transaction
processing mechanism scalability, and economic feasibility (gas fee) of the Ethereum. Such high volume
traffic can create large overhead and can slow down the entire Ethereum network as it was observed in the
case of CryptoKitties. 11 Nevertheless, the Ethereum blockchain is highly useful, as it is currently the most
widely accepted blockchain protocol and it has a huge community base, allowing for future integration
opportunities with Ethereum based dApps and projects.12
While we have decided to utilize ERC -20 as the base of our blockchain design, we had to add some
innovations o f our own to overcome some of the shortfalls of Ethereum (performance, flexibility and
scalability). To resolve these issue, we will be introducing the BORA Chain, an independent modular
blockchain that will be linked to the Ethereum blockchain. The BORA C hain is designed to ensure speed,
scalability, and flexibility while processing mass user traffic and high volume transactions.
As shown above, each content provider in the BORA Ecosystem will be given a private independent
blockchain based on permissioned voting algorithm. This design aims to ensure high performance
transaction, flexibility, fault -tolerance, and scalability on the content provider’s side and prevents noisy -
neighbor issue and disruption during transactions.
The BORA Chain handles the sub -chain role, responding to each content provider while fulfilling
11 The Ethereum main -chain's transaction processing rate was fully saturated for around 3 days starting Dec. 3r d of 2017. This is
assumed to be due to the effects of 'CryptoKitties', which was responsible for 15 - 20% of all Ethereum transactions during the
aforementioned dates.
12 For example, projects such as OmiseGO plan to provide White -label Digital Wallets, allowing the usage of decentralized payment
and transaction functions without the need to independently develop a wallet solution dealing in various tokens and assets.
Contents Provider 2
Contents Provider 1
User
App
Voting node
Voting node
Voting node
Voting node
Voting node
Voting node
App
User
Figure 2. BORA Chain Architecture
16
independent functions. Independent sub-chains are assigned and operated by individual content provider
(application) units. There are several benefits to this architecture. First, the massive transactions generated
by commercial applications in the platform can be handled reliably and rapidly using distributed processing.
Second, this architecture ensures a level of service independence that allows remaining application services
within the platform to be unaffected, even if there are critical defects in a specific application or other
security/service related issues.
BORA Chain has an internal token system called BORA Point that can only be circulated within the platform.
Smart contracts are executed for this internal token. The internal token (BORA Point) belongs to the platform,
and may be generated in several different ways depending on the platform growth stage and business
needs. For example, tokens can be generated and operated as follows: BORA-Play for game circulation and
incentives, BORA-Community for community operation financing and incentives, and BORA-Ticket for event
generation and management services. Content application providers do not need to generate separate
tokens, and can immediately apply the BORA Point that i s appropriate for their individual purposes. Users
are provided with a unified asset management environment and user experience. Thus, even if individual
services cease or disappear, the existing assets may immediately be utilized in other content provider ’s
services.
Internal tokens (BORA Points) within the BORA Chain are mutually exchangeable with ERC-20 tokens (BORA)
in the Ethereum blockchain -based on set rules. And BORA Token holders may easily exchange them for
BORA Point at any time to use the platfo rm content services. This architecture is linked and executed by
the BORA Token Manager.
Content providers do not need to store all service information on the BORA Chain. They can select which
information is necessary and valuable to store in the blockchai n, and can use the content provider's own
database and logs for the remaining information, as before. For example, in an MMORPG game, the user
login/logout record, movement from field A to B, amount of damage dealt to a monster in battle, are
information that is unsuitable to store in the blockchain, and the blockchain cannot generate additional
value from this. But major results from in -game activity and the user's in -game major asset changes are
details that are meaningful to store in the blockchain. A po ker player's game results and asset processing
information, or a rare game item's system generation, acquisition, ownership and transaction related
information are also good examples. This allows the content provider to be free from the development and
maintenance burden of having to convert everything into the blockchain, while at the same time, reducing
the expense to the platform ecosystem of managing such massive amounts of data, in turn allowing the
user to experience a pleasant and fair service usage environment.
17
2.2.2. Service Layer
The service layer provides development tools (API, SDK) to content providers (applications), who want to
join the platform ecosystem. Internal tokens (BORA Point) within the BORA Chain may be linked and used,
and user transactions may be recorded in the blockchain.
This layer also provides BORA Chain Explorer, which externally reviews and audits the information recorded
in the BORA Chain. This provides external transparency for BORA Chain records, allowing anyone to verify
them. This layer also provides se rvice tools for platform ecosystem operation and management, such as
user authentication and token transfer. The tools and environment for business operations (such as data
analysis and monitoring tools) as well as the policies and rules for platform gover nance are also included
in the service layer.
2.2.3. Application Layer
This layer is where the applications of content providers joining the BORA Ecosystem are located, operating
while linked to the BORA Platform. The BORA Platform's own application (BORA App) i s provided here,
allowing users to view and freely access content applications incorporated into the BORA Ecosystem. Digital
asset management and ERC-20 token (BORA) exchange functions are also provided by the BORA App.
To form an ecosystem that grows with its many participants, the BORA Platform has plans to support third
party content providers in order to generate additional content. Support is available for the creation of
additional value by accessing, using, and processing the various data in the BOR A Chain, through the
tentatively-named “BORA Data Hub”.13
3. Solution 2 - Economic System and Incentive Mechanism
3.1. Design Purpose
The contents in solution 1 have been written from a design -centric perspective with the purpose of
circulating content applications based on the blockchain platform. In this part, we will deal with the structure
of promoting and sustaining content circulation and user activity through the BORA Token mechanism and
13 Op.gg that uses the API provided by Riot Games to provide player record statistics servi ce for 'League of Legends', and solutions
that analyze data based on publicly available poker hand histories (e.g. Poker Tracker, etc.) are some exemplary case studies.
18
economic systems.
BORA is an ecosystem that has the form of a multi-sided platform in which both content provider and user
participates. Thus, we have designed an economic system and incentive mech anism that benefits all
participants, while allowing for free, rational, and sustainable value generating activities.
3.2. Token Mechanism
The BORA Ecosystem has a dualistic structure, with the token 'BORA Token' following Ethereum's ERC -20
standards, and the internal token 'BORA Point' based on the BORA Chain. BORA Tokens may be freely
traded between users, whereas BORA Point are tokens for circulation within the platform ecosystem. The
internal and external tokens are almost identical in terms of their techni cal structure, as they are both
cryptocurrencies based on blockchain technology, but are different in that BORA Point are managed
independently within the BORA Blockchain and may only be circulated within the platform ecosystem. BORA
Tokens are initially generated by the Ethereum mainnet, but BORA Points are only generated through usage
transfer requests on already generated BORA Tokens.
For example, users who wish to play games within the BORA Ecosystem may change their BORA Tokens to
BORA Points. When a transfer request is received, the 'BORA Token Manager' generates BORA Points
according to the requested amount, and the requested BORA T okens are retrieved from the user to be
stored. Users can play the game using the issued BORA Points. Users may also transfer held BORA Points
to BORA Tokens at any time. To accomplish this, the BORA Token Manager retrieves the requested BORA
Tokens from the stored balance of BORA Points and provides them to the user. The BORA Points are retrieved
BORA
BORA
(ERC-20)
BORA Point
(BORA Chain)
Token Manager
BORA
BORA
Point
• Transaction Fee
• BORA Point Incentive Program
⑤Play
BORA Point
Game A
Game B
①
①
②
③
④
⑥
⑦
⑧
⑩
⑩
⑨
Figure 3. Linkage and Flow of BORA Token and BORA Point
19
and disappear.
To further clarify the phrase 'retrieve and disappear,' BORA Points can be seen as loan coupons that are
only circulated within the platform, and which the value of BORA Tokens is provided as collateral. The user’s
request to transfer BORA Points back to B ORA Tokens is akin to the retrieval of a loan coupon, and the
return of BORA Tokens takes place according to the value retrieved. Theoretically, the amount of BORA Point
that can be generated through smart contracts will be the total supply of BORA Tokens issued in the market
multiplied by the exchange rate to BORA Point. This structure means that the issuance and circulation of
BORA Points managed in the BORA Chain are fully controlled by BORA Tokens (the ERC-20 tokens). In other
words, not only will the B ORA Chain have a technical characteristic guaranteeing execution and record
keeping based on blockchain technology, there also cannot be any discretionary engagement by individuals
or specific organizations in the issuance and circulation mechanism. As such, these specific encrypted tokens
for platform circulation are, strictly speaking, different from existing in-game currencies and content service
points that may be additionally issued, removed, or modified policy -wise at the sole discretion of the
operating business.
3.3. Incentive for Ecosystem Vitalization and Growth
3.3.1. Design Purpose
As written above, the design goals for the token mechanism and economic system are to generate
ecosystem value and sustain growth. This is only possible if reasonable motivatio ns and expected values
are provided to basically all platform ecosystem participants (all users, content providers, and platforms). To
accomplish this, we operate the ' BORA Point Incentive Program ,' and adhere to the following design
principles.
(A) We can call a platform ecosystem successful if it is possible for participants to generate value, and if
such activities are sustained.
(B) 'Value' here can be determined by participant scale and participant activity scale.
(C) As the number of participants increases and the activity of participants increases, the volume of BORA
Points increases also.
(D) The volume increase of BORA Points means that the BORA Ecosystem will eventually grow.
(E) Thus, we place a high value in the usage and circulatory activities for BORA Play, and will create an
incentive system in order to promote and sustain such activities.
(F) The incentive system is not operated at the discretion of the platform, and its execution is guaranteed
based on the BORA Chain according to pre-defined rules.
20
3.3.2. Incentive Program Purpose and Expected Effect
As user and activity levels increase, the ecosystem’s value becomes greater and more BORA Points can be
circulated. Some portion of the distributed BORA Points will be saved to the BORA Point Incentive Program,
to be re-utilized as a resource for platform ecosystem vitalization. Saved assets will be distributed among
the participants in ecosystem value generation (users, businesses, platform operators) according to the
BORA Platform characteristics. Distribution execution and results are carried out according to the blockchain
and smart contracts, with consistency, transparency, and credibility. These distributed values are beneficial
to everyone.
First, the user will receive incentive rewards based on the rational criteria of ecosystem contribution from
one's activities (e.g. game play, content purchase). These rewards may be exchanged at any time for BORA
Tokens. This is an attractive and rational reward to the user, continuously stimulating user activity.
Content providers can utilize BORA Point incentives originated from the BORA Point Incentive Program, as
a variety for additional service resources. This program may be used as a business operation asset to
increase system reliability, or exchanged for BORA Tokens. This kind of financial benefit mechanism can be
a clear motivating factor for content providers to continue providing or increasing their ecosystem
contributions. The service provider also uses the shared platform circulation token (BORA Po ints), instilling
solidarity and a sense of responsibility. BORA Points also allows for value generation through normal
activities, reducing the motivation for improper behavior within the ecosystem. Ultimately, BORA Points
progressively leads towards bett er content service quality, and allows for the promotion of good faith
competition among businesses.
The BORA Platform can also be used to secure a reward pool for ecosystem operations. Thus, it is possible
to secure a healthy and sustainable source workin g as a reward pool for ecosystem operations, even if
dependencies on other profit mechanisms (e.g. market commission, revenue sharing) are lowered . This
allows for the removal of the excessive profit structure from the platform design, which can directly o r
indirectly increase the willingness of external content providers to participate in the BORA Ecosystem.
3.3.3. Incentive Program Operation Method
The BORA Point Incentive Program's execution is fundamentally guaranteed by smart contracts in the BORA
Chain. It manages: the asset savings, distribution target and rule setting, execution of asset distribution, and
the balancing of BORA Points within the Program that exist as a result of savings and distribution.
The reward pool for the Incentive Program can largely be classified into two parts. First, to execute BORA
Ecosystem operations, some of the distributed BORA Tokens are converted into BORA Points and saved in
the BORA Point Incentive Program. This amount becomes the seed for the first incentive program. Second,
21
part of revenue generated from the platform operation will be credited to incentive program and used as
continuous resource.
Incentives can be distributed to everyone who participated and was active in the ecosystem during a set
period of time to enc ourage greater participation. The aforementioned BORA Points saved in the BORA
Point Incentive Program are used as reward . The method of payment target assessment, payment cycle,
payment scale, and other issues will be made public when operational stabilit y has been secured through
future testing and other activities. These will all be executed through smart contracts. To aid your
understanding, here is a simple example: as an incentive, 10% of the BORA Point Incentive Program's balance
can be paid every we ek to all address accounts that generated BORA Point transactions according to the
stake of each individual transaction. Payment can be made to each address directly, or may incorporate
some entertainment factors such as mini-games. Or, operations can utilize a combination of the two.
3.4. BORA Point's Flexible Extension Architecture
The BORA Platform ecosystem can accommodate various types of content providers such as video games,
social communities and entertainment. As each of these have different service architectures, monetization
models and user environment characteristics, it may make it inappropriate for BORA Point to be operated
as the sole economics system. For example, in the case of mobile games, it can use the application's own
in-app purchase to entice players to make purchases, but blog services will find it difficult to charge fees
to writers; instead it may be more appropriate to provide a writing-friendly environment and tools for free.
These differences make their economic mechanisms different as well. It is the same when providing services
like 'CryptoKitties' or issuing / circulating limited edition celebrity digital avatars.
BORA Point
(BORA Chain)
BORA
Token Manager
BORA Token
(ERC-20)
BORA-
Play
BORA-
Community
BORA-
······
Game A
Game B
Game C
Comm. A
Comm. B
Comm. C
······ A
······ B
······ C
Figure 4. BORA Point's Flexible Extension Architecture
22
BORA Points have a flexible and expandable architecture that allow them to cope with diverse service
environments. BORA Point is the generic term for the token circulated within the platform ecosystem by
the BORA Chain, and there may be several different types of BORA Points depending on the platform
operation needs. BORA-Play will first be launched to cope with the needs of regular game play. Subsequently,
new types of BORA Points may be launched (e.g. BORA -Ticket, BORA-Community, etc.) depending on the
situation.
3.5. Monetization
The BORA Platform can apply a monetization model for ecosystem maintenance and growth. Various models
utilized in existing industries will be referenced, but appropriate methods will be decided on a rational level
that fits the architecture and direction of the BORA Ecosystem.
1) Fees for changing BORA Points to BORA Tokens:
Within the BORA Ecosystem, BORA Points may be exchanged for BORA Tokens at any time, at the
discretion of the holder. From the user's perspective, this means a change from activity value to
external market value; and from a bio-ecosystem's perspective, this means internal activity energy
exiting the ecosystem. To perform this change, the requester must pay a fixed fee, and the collected
fees will be used for platform network operations and for supplying the ecosystem's internal energy.
Fees will also contribute to the prevention of the abuse and network spam caused by meaningless
transactions.
2) Transaction fees for some large-scale content providers using the BORA Chain:
BORA Platform is an ecosystem shared by multiple participants. Thus, if a content provider requiring
massive transactions (extreme example would be Facebook) participates, the services ecosystem
transaction processing share will increase, which could have negative effects on the services of
other providers. As such, it will be provided for free at a base level, but fees may be claimed from
participants requiring transactions that exceed a certain level. Participants with such transaction fee
charges should be limited to a fraction of content services.
4. BORA Platform Ecosystem Usage Cases
The BORA Platform프로젝트로 돌아가기