bitpro가 원문에서 글자만 모은 내용이에요. 표·그림·수식은 빠지거나 깨질 수 있어요. 전체 4쪽 중 2쪽
a heavy burden. Unfortunately, the current sta te of developmental
support and mitigating risks for blockchain-related projects are still lacking.
The BORA Platform ecosystem is a solution designed to resolve these issues. The BORA Platform design
consists of an internal blockchain (BORA Chain) and the Ethereum public blockchain linked together. It aims
to provide the high transaction throughput and expandability required for commercial content application
services. BORA Chain is designed with a modular architecture, and the modular design allows each
application on the platform to enjoy independent service environments.
Tokens for internal circulation (BORA Points) within the ecosystem exist within the BORA Chain, and are
linked to ERC-20 tokens (BORA Tokens). Through this structure, user assets are protected, and the transfer
process to BORA Tokens and execution is ensured. As a result, user assets are no longer in a structure that
is dependent on existing content providers, but rather exist with the user and ecosystem. Content providers
do not need t o separately develop new blockchains, and can participate in the decentralized ecosystem
using the web interface and API provided by the BORA Platform.
The BORA Platform ecosystem will also consist of the BORA Point Incentive Program, which aims to benefit
all ecosystem participants and is operated based on smart contracts. Blockchain -based promotion
campaigns and rewards programs can be applied to radically improve user retention, ultimately resulting in
an increased service Lifetime Value (LTV).
The BORA Ecosystem is designed so that all participants can contribute to the ecosystem and receive
reasonable rewards, with voluntary and continuous user activity all driven by the token -based economic
system and incentive mechanisms. Behavior that is inappropria te for the ecosystem can be self -regulated
as it does not benefit anyone in the ecosystem (including the perpetrator), and content providers within
the ecosystem can share the goal and motivation to compete in good faith through service quality
improvements rather than unfair practices.
The BORA Platform's first goal is to use trial services for fast network and ecosystem verification, leading to
commercialization. Video game fits this goal best, considering its factors of popularity and intuitiveness.
Thus, the developer that entered a partnership with the BORA team is developing a game for the trial
8
service that will be linked with the BORA Chain. The blockchain technology industry is still in its infancy but
is continuously advancing and growing. The BORA Platform also has a road map to enhance the platform
and BORA Chain while extending the ecosystem range, matching the advances in technology and ecosystem
growth. Through a series of processes, we ultimately seek to build and grow an ecosystem that promot es
content business circulation and continuous user activity within a decentralized platform environment.
9
1. Definition of the Problem
1.1. Problems with the Existing Industry
1.1.1. Credibility - Veracity, Transparency, and Security of Information
There have always been credibility issues between the content information sender and receiver in the
existing digital industry. In our view, this is due to the difficulty in confirming the veracity of the information
provided, the lack of transparency in the provision of sa id information, and the fact that the information
could be modified or lost at any time.
Even if the content provider provided valid information, it is difficult for the user to verify the information.
It is similarly difficult for the provider to prove an d impress on the user the integrity of the information.
Take for example, the video game industry. It is difficult for game players to accept at face value that the
game randomly shuffles the cards for each new game, and deals the cards fairly for each new hand. Players
may still refuse to believe the information provided with the randomized loot box that they have a 1%
chance of obtaining a rare game item, and refrain from purchasing the product.1
Apart from the questionable accuracy of the information fro m content providers, the transparency in
disclosing information is also lacking. Content providers with their own servers and databases could directly
control which information is recorded, stored, and shared. As such, it is difficult for users to know whi ch
information was recorded, and what level of information was shared. For instance, most mobile games do
not provide individual probabilities or expected values for probability -based items sold through in -app
purchases as well.2
Beyond this, the information in databases can be modified or falsified at any time as a result of a bug, and
administrator mistake or by a deliberate action. Sometimes, information can be lost, or even omitted (not
recorded). This reversibility of information can cause a negative effect on the service’s credibility.
These issues have also caused considerable waste of resources. For instance, in the online poker service 3
we studied: 60% of the customer inquiries were related to 'suspicion of manipulation of game probability
1 http://www.koreaherald.com/view.php?ud=20180402000884
2 South Korea and some jurisdictions require disclosure of information related to these probability-based items, but there is a limit to
the disclosure method and level. The App Store also made the disclosure of probabilities for loot boxes (probability -based items)
mandatory through its new App Store Review Guidelines on Dec. 21st, 2017. But Apple does not technically verify the disclosed
probability, and it is still difficult to judge the veracity of the information actually provided.
3 An online game service that once recorded $32M in monthly sales, which was proven by source code and log data review, had no
no manipulation of in-game probabilities.
10
and mistrust of game records', and another 25% were that 'game money has been lost or hacked. 4 A
separate customer service group with a large number of personnel had to be opened to handle these
complaints and inquiries.
1.1.2. User Asset Value - Dependency, Severity, and Loss
Content providers in the areas of video game, online social communities, and entertainment create and/or
circulate content with complementing services. Users enjoy and consume the content through a variety of
means and often times they involve a great deal of time, effort, and money. Through this process, content
providers may profit from the content’s popularity and users on the other hand obtain - quite often -
emotionally attached, hard-won digital assets. Although, the assets are obtained through value trade-offs,
the majority of user assets cannot become the sole propert y of the user. This is because the digital assets
of a user are linked to the content provider’s services. The '100M in-game money' accumulated by the user,
the 'Platinum status l evel' built up in the community, and the '100,000 -strong army' that was completed
with the user’s time and money will all disappear once the relevant content services are suspended. They
will all disappear, regardless of how much time, effort, or money the user has spent to obtain and accumulate
them.5 It is our view that this type of user asset dependency reduces the participation, immersion, and
payment of the users, who are aware of this limited asset ownership. As such, content providers must put
more effort and cost into finding high-loyalty users.
In addition, in cases such as the 'one -to-many' relationship structure between the user and the content
service provider, assets accumulated in different services cannot be consolidated, and cannot be value -
determined using a unified criteria even if they belong to the same user. If an asset’s value cannot be
determined, then it is not fit for ownership, tr ade, or transaction. Therefore, the number of users who put
their time and resource to acquire these assets can only be a small portion of the whole population of
users. For this reason, providers of content such as those in the video game industry incur a large cost to
increase the user purchase rate - even though it is for a small fraction of increase - via in-app-purchasing
or freemium model.
Also, the asset value of content services may be easily harmed or lost. The value of 100 million in -game
money, which the user has accumulated through years of play, may plummet to 1/100 of its original value
if there are game money duplication hacks or abuses. The game money value will also plummet if the game
business suddenly decides to provide 100 million of in -game money every day, for free, to bring in new
4 A vast majority of these inquiries stemmed from user misunderstanding. According to the result, the rando mization function from
game server, that oversees the game logic was running fairly. Most of the game record related complaints and inquiries stemme d
from erroneous memories from user experience.
5 Of course, there are instances of blog service termination where entries are backed up or transferred to another service. However,
the user's own entries are most likely only a part of the blog's user accumulated assets.
11
users. Situations such as these occasionally occur in video game services. 6
Thus, it is difficult to determine and maintain the value of user’s digital assets as they are dependent on
the content providers, difficult to consolidate and liable to loss by outside force. Obviously, it will also be
difficult to engage in trade or transaction activities with the assets of this nature. This effect demotivates
and reduce participation from the users, causing a vicio us cycle for the content providers due to the
increased cost of securing loyal users, which increases the operating cost, resulting in lower service quality,
and so forth.
1.1.3. Broker Transactions
Digital assets for some content services have trades or transactions taking place through brokers, with their
value acknowledged in the process. In mobile RPG games for example, there may be brokered transactions
of game money (e.g. gold, gems), which are purchased from users and then sold to others at a lower price
than the in-game shop. In highly trade-activated game services, there are specialized brokers who purchase
in-game money from users to resell. In our experience, they usually purchase chips at around 80% of the
in-game shop price, then resell them at around 90% for a 10 - 15% profit. Sometimes the scale of brokered
transactions is larger than the sales occurring within the game service itself.7
However, transaction fraud and excessive fees during the broker transaction processes increase the
transaction risks and expenses, while decreasing transaction quality. Some malicious broker and traders steal
in-game money using hacks and also resell the stolen merchandise at low prices. Item trading specialty
sites8 have emerged to resolve these issues, but there are still fraudulent transactions between buyers and
sellers when the transaction process is complex, and the transaction fees can be steep.
1.2. Review on Existing Projects
1.2.1. Performance and Expandability
Internet-based commercial content services such as video game and communities require massive and rapid
transaction processing. As such, each project that is preparing for a decentralized application platform is
taking its own approach to resolving transaction performance issues. However, there are also some projects
6 The Stone of Jordan ring was the valued currency in Diablo 2, but became mass circulated through item duplication. Blizzard applied
a special event system patch called Uber Diablo as a means of retrieving the rings. The action of selling the Jordan ring tri ggered
special monsters to appear, which had chance to drop highly-valued items, which made users sell Jordan ring to shop.
7 Reference about account hijacking https://www.cnet.com/news/no-end-in-sight-to-hacking-of-wow-accounts-1/
8 Representative sites include opskins.com, itembay.com, and itemmania.com.
12
that they do not show much concern in these areas. One such project, claiming to be a blockchain casino
service, does not mention whether it has sufficient capacity to handle hundreds to thousands of blackjack
tables operating simultaneously. A game of blackjack lasts 1 minute 30 seconds at most and a new one is
created right after multiple chip transactions occur during the game, and hundreds to tens of thousands of
players can simultaneously generate these transactions. As such, a sufficient level of performance to meet
such service requirements must be secured.
1.2.2. Burdens of Entering a New Industry
It is rare to see completely ground breaking innovation projects appear in the blockchain landscape. Most
projects that appear in the blockchain market curr ently utilize blockchain technology for incremental
improvements, addressing one or two existing shortfalls in the current system. While there are dozens of
distinct projects that seek to disrupt the current money transfer and payment systems and have as a result,
gained wide recognition and popularity, there are not as many famed projects in other industries beyond
the finance sector. In our view, the foremost reason for this is that the blockchain industry is still in its early
stages, with yet more time required for the completion of projects that are preparing for the fully
decentralized application ecosystems. But even considering this, there are other issues that should be
highlighted.
Content providers attempting blockchain -based application services cannot help but feel greatly at risk.
Content providers must sufficiently understand the new technology from the initial phase and develop
accordingly, but the development tools and environmental support are still insufficient. Content providers
also feel a great deal of concern at the prospect of giving up their existing centralized service method and
adopting into a new environment. For these businesses, utilizing blockchain technology may mean
abandoning an existing market with hundreds of millions of u sers for the multi-year challenge of entering
a small and newly-formed platform ecosystem. The many projects developing blockchain -based platforms
must be able to resolve these issues. If not, it may be a long time until the blockchain -based ecosystem
fully matures.
1.2.3. Economic Systems and Monetization
For a single application or ecosystem to be sustainable, it must have beneficial value to all members,
including the users. Many projects are planning for decentralized wallets and payment solutions instead of
the existing payment modules and credit cards. However, these new solutions alone cannot provide more
significant value to the ecosystem participants (e.g. game developers and users) compared to the Apple
App Store or Google Play. If the content provider still needs to pay a platform commission of around 30%,
and the user does not perceive any difference other than using a decentralized payment solution underneath
13
it, it will be difficult for blockchain -based platform ecosystems to become widely adopted and used. As
such, blockchain projects building application platforms must also consider economic systems that can
handle these issues.
In addition, projects such as blockchain -based game services (not ecosystem applications) must consider
economic feasibility and monetization. For example, if a project generates ERC-20 based tokens and provides
a game that run on these tokens, players are burdened with high transaction costs. 9 Specifically, if there
are frequent transactions within a fixed commission fee structure, the user’s expense burden will grow.
For instance, let’s suppose there is an Ethereum (ETH) based dice game.
The two players (A and B) with the same participation fee (0.1 ETH) for each player and per round, and they
both have the same win ratio, the player who gets the highest number will win both players’ participation
fee but Ethereum blockchain will require transaction fees (gas 0.01 ETH) to be paid for each round. It would
eventually make both players lose 2 ETH after 200 rounds of playing. 10 This simple example does not
include the additional service fees that may be imposed by the dice game provider, which (if included) will
increase the burden experienced by the user. While this is an extreme and simplified scenario, there is little
chance that the user would continue playing this game, and it would be difficult for such a service to grow
and sustain its business. Ultimately, the service provider must be concerned about these economic issues
and find a way to resolve them. Otherwise, the probability of projects such as '0 Fee Ethereum Dice Game'
providing meaningful value to potential users will be low. But there are projects that do not provide clear
information on these subjects, and it seems that significant sums of money have been put into these
projects with unclear economic feasibilities, as noted above.
1.3. Conclusion
Blockchain takes the existing centralized system and restructures it to a decentralized system. As this new
technology begins to spread, gains wider adoption and improvements are made, the issue raised above will
be addressed, and the shortfalls of early projects will overcome the adaptation stage.
Our decentralized blockchain base aims to ensure the security and transparency of transaction activities,
creating an application platform network in which it is possible to protect user digital assets and generate
innovations. This will allow the resolution of existing issues, while providing solutions that vitalize content
service circulation and user participation. We call this platform ecosystem 'BORA'.
9 Of course, transaction processing performance issues exist within these types of structures, as was noted previously. That is still the
case as of now, although it is expected that the performance and exp andability of blockchain technology will continue to grow and
evolve.
10 2 players playing 200 rounds of dice game will take a maximum of 120 min.
14
2. Solution 1 - Blockchain Structure
2.1. Summary
We define BORA as 'a blockchain -based platform ecosystem for circulating and stimulating content
applications'. Various types of service providers that deal with content, such as video game , social
communities and entertainment, can use the BORA Platform to provide their services easily and quickly.
The BORA Platform has been designed with a modular architecture that enables independent blockchain
execution by the content provider. This ensu res undisturbed autonomous execution and prevents noisy -
neighbor issue. Users will be given a unified user experience across the various content services of the
BORA Ecosystem. Personal identity, account, and assets are will be unified and will be inter -compatible
within the platform. Assets and their values accumulated through every content service interaction will be
compatible and accepted within the platform. Above all, the BORA Platform has the performance and
scalability to reliably process the amount of activities required for these content services.
2.2. Platform Layer Architecture
BORA Infrastructure, Data Network
BORA Chain
BORA Point, BORA Token Manager
BORA API, SDK
Identification, Operating Tools, BI
Policy
BORA Application, Web
Content Provider (Application, Web)
Application Layer
Service Layer
Core Layer
Figure 1. BORA Platform Layer Architecture
15
2.2.1. Core Layer
In platform businesses such as video games, social communities and entertainment, it is important to quickly
apply/remedy changes and bugs in the system without causing downtime. It is also critical for a platform
provider to reliably provide high performance thr프로젝트로 돌아가기