bitpro가 원문에서 글자만 모은 내용이에요. 표·그림·수식은 빠지거나 깨질 수 있어요. 전체 9쪽 중 2쪽
responsible global community. Together, our impact will be multiplied across a network of
networks, connecting people, governments, and entire industries to sustainable outcomes that will benefit
us all. In these trusted ecosystems, individuals and institutions will link their efforts to ensure the full value of
every action is recognised and rewarded.
At vechain, we believe in the power of blockchain to transform individual action into collective steps that
incentivise cooperation and improve how we perceive value. In such a world, one plus one no longer equals
two, but three, or four, or five. With these new models of interaction, we can all participate in defining,
creating, scaling, and sustaining new value systems that will protect our shared world and unleash our
collective potential.
To build a trust-free and distributed business
ecosystem platform to enable transparent
information flow, efficient collaboration,
and high-speed value transfers
2017
2019
2023
…lowering the barrier and enabling established
business with blockchain technology to create
value and solve real world economic problems…
Multiply individual impact
to unleash our collective
potential for sustainability.
“
““
“
“ “
Figure 4 - Our Journey of Inspiration
10
11
The previous sections detailed how Web3 can
be used to promote a more sustainable future.
Now, we will examine what sustainability really means
in this context.
Sustainability is often instinctively associated with
environmental consciousness and broad actions such
as reducing emissions, reusing goods, and recycling
waste. However, the concept of sustainability is much
broader. Indeed, sustainability encompasses the total
functioning of our global society. Sustainability entails
granting access to essential goods and services
to all people, protecting vulnerable individuals and
communities, providing humane working conditions
to employees, ensuring that consumer products
and services are healthy and safe, and enabling the
regeneration of natural resources.
Building a global culture of sustainability requires
a common definition. In the business community,
sustainability is typically discussed under the rubric of
Environment, Social, Governance (ESG). We go a step
further and break down this universe of sustainability-
related topics into five primary dimensions
and 24 sustainability needs.
7
How We Identify
Sustainability Needs
7. The five dimensions and 24 sustainability needs are based on the Sustainability Accounting Standards
Board’s (SASB) taxonomy. See appendix 1 for further details. Source of the sidebar: “Why do we need to
protect biodiversity?”, European Commission
Environment: greenhouse gas emissions
(e.g., CO2, methane, nitrous oxide) and
air quality; energy management; water
and wastewater management; waste
management circularity; natural
resource use; biodiversity protection
Social conditions: human rights and
community relations; customer privacy
and data security; customer welfare;
selling practices and accessibility
Labour conditions: human rights and
community relations; customer privacy
and data security; customer welfare;
selling practices and accessibility
Business model and innovation: supply
chain and responsible sourcing; business
resilience
Leadership and governance: business
ethics and competitive behaviour;
management of the legal and regulatory
environment; risk management
12
When we apply the five dimensions of
sustainability to different industries, the
most pressing issues vary considerably.
A carmaker might be more concerned
about emissions, while a clothing
manufacturer or distributor might pay
more attention to labour conditions in
factories.
To account for this variability, we have
built a Sustainability Topics Matrix
which highlights the most important
sustainability needs in different industries.
The Sustainability Topics Matrix was
developed using the Materiality Maps
published by hundreds of companies in
each sector as part of their most recent
sustainability reports (2019-2021) (see
appendix 3 for the methodology of
the Sustainability Topics Matrix).
The Matrix helps us identify the most
pressing issues for each sector today. It
can be updated to take account for how
those needs evolve over time.
When we apply the five dimensions of
sustainability to different industries, the
most pressing issues vary considerably. A
carmaker might be more concerned about
emissions, while a clothing manufacturer
or distributor might pay more attention to
labour conditions in factories.
To account for this variability, we have built
a Sustainability Topics Matrix
8
which
highlights the most important sustainability
needs in different industries. The Sustainability
Topics Matrix was developed using the
Materiality Maps published by hundreds of
companies in each sector as part of their
most recent sustainability reports (2019-2021)
(see appendix 3 for the methodology of the
Sustainability Topics Matrix).
9
The Matrix helps us identify the most pressing
issues for each sector today. It can be
updated to take account for how those needs
evolve over time.
8. See appendix 3 for the methodology, 9. Maps used by
firms to disclose the sustainability needs they consider
most relevant (see appendix 2 for further details)
12
“Biodiversity” refers to the variety of
life on Earth (species, genera within
a single species, ecosystems). Every
living being, including human beings,
is involved in complex networks of
interdependent relationships, which
are called ecosystems. Many such
ecosystems are currently endangered.
For example, the global animal
population has declined 68%
since 1970, highlighting an urgent
need to act.
Healthy ecosystems provide us with food,
clean our water and air, regulate the
climate, provide resources for medicines
and other benefits. For this reason,
biodiversity must be protected and,
where needed, restored.
Protecting biodiversity:
a key challenge for the future
13
The Sustainability Topics Matrix is the tool we developed to identify and show the relevance of
sustainability needs across industries
GHG EMISSIONS
(& AIR QUALITY)
MINING & NATURAL RESOURCES AGRICULTURE, FOOD & BEVERAGE MFG.FASHION MFG.FURNITURE MFG. & DESIGNCHEMICALS MFG.PHARMA MFG.METAL & NON-METAL MINERAL PRODUCTS MFG.MACHINERY & EQUIPMENT MFG.IT & TECH MFG.ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT MFG.AUTOMOTIVE MFG.NON-AUTOMOTIVE TRANSPORT MFG.ENERGY & UTILITIES SUPPLY CONSTRUCTION & REAL ESTATETRANSPORTATION & LOGISTIC SERVICESHORECATELCO & MEDIA, (INCL. SOFTWARE)FINANCIAL SERVICESPROFESSIONAL, SCIENTIFIC AND TECHNICALEDUCATIONHEALTHCAREE-COMMERCEFOOD & DRUGS RETAILOTHER PRODUCTS RETAIL
ENERGY MANAGEMENT
WATER & WASTEWATER
MANAGEMENT
CIRCULAR ECONOMY
& WASTE MANAGEMENT
PROTECTING BIODIVERSITY
RESPONSIBLE
RESOURCE USE
HUMAN RIGHTS &
COMMUNITY RELATIONS
CUSTOMER PRIVACY
& DATA SECURITY
CUSTOMER WELFARE
SELLING PRACTICES
& ACCESSIBILITY
EMPLOYEE HEALTH & SAFETY
EMPLOYEE ENGAGEMENT,
DIVERSITY & INCLUSION
SUPPLY CHAIN &
RESPONSIBLE SOURCING
BUSINESS RESILIENCE
BUSINESS ETHICS &
COMPETITIVE BEHAVIOR
MGMT OF THE REGULATORY
ENVIRONMENT
RISK MANAGEMENT
Figure 5 - Sustainability Topics Matrix
ENVIRONMENTSOCIAL CONDITIONSLABORCONDITIONSBUSINESS MODEL & INNOVATION LEADERSHIP & GOVERNANCE
14
The complexity of sustainability derives both from the broad environmental and societal scope it
encompasses and from an inherent need for collaborative action. A wide variety of actors must work
together to move the needle on sustainability, even at the local level.
Consider the everyone involved in the life cycle of a simple chocolate bar: Farms provide the raw
materials and the energy and labor to cultivate them; power companies supply the electricity used
during the production process by the manufacturer; logistics companies manage transportation;
and wholesalers and retailers handle distribution. Finally, consumers buy and consume it, leaving
municipalities to dispose of or recycle the waste generated by wrappers and shipping materials. And then
the process begins again.
If citizens wish to consume a product without causing an excessive environmental impact, they must
be sure that the raw materials have been obtained in a manner that protects biodiversity, that the
manufacturer uses renewable energy to run its plants and has employed an efficient and low-polluting
production process, that the greenest possible forms of shipping are used, and that retailers have
been careful to manage orders in such a way as to avoid waste. The citizen must then make a personal
commitment to properly dispose of packaging and food waste, ultimately relying on the municipality to
recycle them.
Specific trends in materiality of sustainability needs
Environmental needs are particularly important to heavy industry and sectors that use natural resources.
Those needs include addressing emissions in industries with carbon-intensive production processes,
like oil and gas, and improving waste management in industries where hazardous waste is produced, such as
chemical manufacturing.
Social and Labour conditions are more significant in sectors that are customer centric or labour-
intensive. Needs related to social conditions range from ensuring safety and quality in pharmaceuticals
and healthcare to protecting customer privacy and data security in e-commerce and financial services.
Employee health and safety is particularly relevant for sectors where production sites present a risk of
safety incidents.
Leadership, governance and business model innovation needs apply to all industries that are subject
to sudden changes stemming from, among other causes, energy transition, new regulations, disruptive
technologies, or consumer innovation.
15
All these actors should have an interest in making their actions sustainable. Moreover, since they are
interconnected, they can multiply the impact of their individual sustainability actions and unleash their
collective potential by collaborating and acting in a coordinated, synergistic manner.
More often than not, the greatest sustainability challenge is getting every player on board and coordinated
with the others. This requires inspiring, facilitating, and managing long-term cooperation and collective
action. However, several obstacles may prevent the creation of effective collaborative ecosystems:
Figure 6 – Collaboration systems
Example of each actor’s contribution to sustainability needs
16
A lack of trust and proof of authenticity can prevent
different players from cooperating and addressing
sustainability needs. Everyone must trust each other
and possess sufficient visibility into each other's work.
They must know that the information they receive from
their counterparts is trustworthy in order to collaborate
productively. Similarly, customers must be sure the
products they are buying are authentic and sustainably
manufactured, which means they need insight into how
the goods were produced and distributed. Without this
assurance, consumers will be reluctant to recognise the
full value of these goods. For example, if retailers and
end consumers cannot trust information on emissions
or wastewater generated though manufacturing and
transportation of products, they cannot base their
purchasing behaviour on environmental impacts. If
consumers do not account for environmental impacts
when choosing products, then manufacturers will not
be incentivised to improve their environmental policies.
Another obstacle to collaboration is a lack of data
ownership and privacy. People and organisations with
a common sustainability goal must be able to safely
store data and make it accessible to each other in a
secure fashion. If they are reluctant to share sensitive
information due to privacy concerns, this will reduce
visibility into each other’s sustainability actions.
Conversely, more data sharing and greater visibility
will make collaboration easier and more successful.
Indeed, the lack of innovative and fast ways to safely
share data may slow down necessary activities (e.g.,
if the sale of medical products requires individuals to
provide a medical prescription on paper).
Need for trust and
Proof of Authenticity
Data ownership &
privacy challenges
Poor digital maturity and tools
for data collection and sharing
(E.g., when refugees flee war zones
without proper documentation,
there is no unified platform where
their home country and NGOs or
host countries can collect and
share information needed to
identify them.)
Concerns about the sharing and
protection of sensitive data (E.g.,
companies may be reluctant to join
ecosystems that require them to
share data with competitors.)
Incomplete or incorrect tracking of
customer information (E.g., despite
loyalty programs companies do not
know how consumers interact with
their products after point of sale, if
they use them, waste them, recycle
the packaging, etc.)
Lack of visibility into the
sustainability of suppliers’
operations (e.g., difficulties for
retailers in identifying the amount
of emissions generated by their
suppliers when manufacturing a
specific product)
No traceability and brand
liability regarding the usage
and end-of-life of products (e.g.,
no opportunities for municipalities
to verify whether end consumers
dispose of products correctly)
Inadequate or absent proof of
authenticity or definitive product
identification (e.g., difficulties in
identifying whether second-hand
luxury products are authentic)
Absence of traditional trust
mechanisms among specific
actors in a digitized and hyper-
connected world (e.g., lack of
trust among players who have
never met one another in person
when interacting in an online
marketplace)
17
Furthermore, people and organisations can only
effectively collaborate if the externalities generated
by their actions are valued correctly . If someone’s
actions produce positive effects for others, but go
unrecognised, they will be less inclined to repeat the
behaviour. Conversely, if someone’s harmful actions
go unnoticed and are not penalised, they may be more
inclined to replicate the conduct, either because they
are unaware of the harm created or because they lack
incentives to improve. For instance, consumers who
choose environmentally conscious options, such as
food packaged in compostable or reusable materials,
often do not receive a reward for their choice, leading
to lower consumer demand and minimal investment
from companies in compostable packaging; if there is
no demand from consumers, firms are not motivated
to go the extra mile
Need for attribution of
value to externalities
Absence of ways to monetize
positive externalities or incentives
to reduce negative ones (E.g., there
are no incentives for consumers
to bring their clothes back to
manufacturers to allow
for the recycling of fabric.)
Lack of penalisation for generation
of negative externalities (E.g., No
effective measures are in place to
penalise firms that outsource their
operations to foreign countries that
employ child labour.)
Figure 7 - Obstacles to Collective Sustainability Action
• Lack of visibility on sustainability of suppliers’ operations
• No traceability and brand liability on the usage and end-of-life of products
• Inadequate or absent proof of authenticity and definitive product identification
• Absence of traditional trust mechanisms among specific actors
Need for trust and Proof of Authenticity
• Poor digital maturity and tools for data collection and sharing
• Concerns about the protection of sensitive data shared
• Incomplete or incorrect tracking of customer information
Data ownership & privacy
• Absence of ways to monetize positive externalities
or incentives to reduce negative ones
• Lack of penalization for generation of negative externalities
Need for attribution of value to externalities
17
18
18
The obstacles detailed above obstruct lasting,
collective, positive action. Indeed, when the impact
on society caused by certain actions fails to be
fully captured, or there is lack of trust and privacy in
data exchange, actors in the value chain are more
reluctant to pursue virtuous behaviours.
On the other hand, well-structured compensation
mechanisms can encourage people and
organisations to join forces and collaborate. When
individuals act in an environment that recognises
and values actions beneficial to the community
(on a social, financial, or legal level, for instance), it
generates a virtuous circle of positive improvements.
If the system encourages choices that create
more sustainable value for society, then we can
count on a rising number of people, enterprises,
and organisations addressing sustainability needs
collectively, while also reaping a personal benefit: a
true win-win situation.
Today, most sustainability focused regulations, enforcement regimes, taxation policies, and even the SDG
infrastructure itself, are centred on the actions and initiatives of governments and enterprises. As a result,
individuals are rarely directly involved in sustainability efforts, and their actions and contributions are not
fully captured nor credited. This also reduces the effectiveness of initiatives undertaken by governments
and companies.
Presently, companies can design their products so that their components are recyclable, but if consumers
are not encouraged to dispose of them properly, or if their municipalities tax them equally regardless
of whether they recycle or not, such efforts will be in vain. It is crucial to identify methods for measuring,
evaluating, and recognising individual contributions.
This is a substantial opportunity.
Consequently, vechain partners with enterprises that serve as facilitators and advocates of collaborative
systems aimed at engaging institutions, local governments, and — most importantly — citizens themselves.
Examples of positive or
negative compensation
mechanisms
Adding a charge for shopping bags
in supermarkets creates an incentive
for customers to re-use bags they
already have.
Congestion charge zones discourage
citizens from using private vehicles,
thereby reducing emissions (e.g.,
congestion charge zone in London).
Emissions trading systems incentivise
companies to finance carbon-removal
projects in exchange for a monetary reward.
19
Borrowing from the concept of Earth’s biosphere, we aim to enable and support the Blockchain Biosphere
for Sustainability . This will eventually consist of many ecosystems dedicated to solving specific needs,
everything from monitoring logistics to get food from point A to point B safely to reducing emissions by
shortening a supply chain.
The Biosphere represents a framework within which we can develop blockchain powered solutions
for sustainability challenges around the globe. These solutions, connected with Web3 technology, will
galvanise the collective action required to overcome the challenges we see today.
The Biosphere will provide a platform for developing ecosystems to solve different sustainability needs, such
as by establishing a circular economy for the fashion sector or mitigating emissions in the energy industry.
Through an interconnected network , individuals will be able to seamlessly explore and participate in
the full spectrum of ecosystems and build or grow their own ecosystems as well.
Two critical components make up the Blockchain Biosphere for Sustainability: the platform infrastructure
and disparate but interconnected ecosystems .
Blockchain Biosphere for Sustainability Framework
In the previous chapter we discussed the Sustainability Topic Matrix and areas where there is an acute
sustainability need. We also outlined several challenges that prevent collaboration to address those
sustainability needs. In this chapter, we propose a new conceptual solution to the프로젝트로 돌아가기