bitpro가 원문에서 글자만 모은 내용이에요. 표·그림·수식은 빠지거나 깨질 수 있어요. 전체 3쪽 중 1쪽
Stacks: A Bitcoin Layer for Smart Contracts
Stacks is a Bitcoin layer for smart contracts; it enables smart contracts and decentralized
applications to trustlessly use Bitcoin as an asset and settle transactions on the Bitcoin
blockchain. The initial version of Stacks, launched in early 2021, introduced Bitcoin settlement
of transactions, the Clarity language for safe contracts that can respond to Bitcoin transactions,
and atomic swaps of assets with BTC. The next major proposed upgrade of Stacks, the
Nakamoto release (expected 2023), adds important capabilities that will enhance the power of
Stacks as a Bitcoin layer: (a) a decentralized, two-way Bitcoin peg to move BTC in/out of the
layer and write to Bitcoin, (b) transactions secured by Bitcoin finality, and (c) fast transactions
between Bitcoin blocks. The resulting Stacks layer makes Bitcoin a fully programmable asset
in a trustless manner. This can make hundreds of billions of dollars of passive Bitcoin capital
productive, unlock it for decentralized applications, and make Bitcoin the backbone of a more
secure web3.
Bitcoin is the most decentralized, secure, and durable blockchain. BTC is a unique, widely held
asset and the Bitcoin blockchain is the best final settlement layer for transactions. Applications
that want to maximize decentralization and durability should use BTC as their asset and
perform final settlement on the Bitcoin blockchain. However, to preserve its valuable
properties, the Bitcoin blockchain is—by design—slow, minimal, and resistant to change. For
example, it does not natively provide fully-expressive smart contracts or fast performance, so
sophisticated applications cannot be built directly on it. Therefore, BTC remains a passive asset
and most applications are instead built on Ethereum and other layer-1 (L1) blockchains that
have less powerful native assets than BTC.
Bitcoin layers extend the functionality and improve the performance of Bitcoin without
changing the Bitcoin L1. Examples include fast payments (Lightning) and general smart
contracts (Stacks and RSK). In its conservatism toward changes, Bitcoin is comparable to
FedWire as a settlement layer and to TCP/IP as the internet protocol: Higher-level layers are
built on top of these, with additional functionality and innovation, but the base remains simple
and stable. Bitcoin layers enable sophisticated applications that require fully-expressive smart
contracts, high performance, or greater privacy.
The Stacks layer for smart contracts has the following innovations that make it unique:
S Secured by the entire hash power of Bitcoin (Bitcoin finality).
T Trust-minimized Bitcoin peg mechanism; write to Bitcoin.
A Atomic BTC swaps and assets owned by BTC addresses.
C Clarity language for safe, decidable smart contracts.
K Knowledge of full Bitcoin state; read from Bitcoin.
S Scalable, fast transactions that settle on Bitcoin.
The decentralized Bitcoin peg (see the sBTC paper [1]), fast transactions, and Bitcoin finality
1
are proposed for the Nakamoto release, and other properties are already live on Stacks. More
specifically, the Nakamoto release of Stacks:
1. Secured by Bitcoin: enables Bitcoin finalization for Stacks transactions; after about 100
Bitcoin blocks or approximately a day of confirmations, the transactions that happened on
the Stacks layer will be secured by the entire hash power of Bitcoin. Meaning that to
reverse these transactions, an attacker will need to reorg Bitcoin. Such transactions settle on
Bitcoin and have Bitcoin finality. Further, the Stacks layer forks with Bitcoin, so any state
on Stacks automatically follows the Bitcoin forks.
2. Trust-minimized Bitcoin peg: introduces a novel decentralized, non-custodial, Bitcoin-
pegged asset, sBTC, so smart contracts can run much faster and more cheaply using the
Bitcoin-pegged asset without compromising safety. This also enables contracts on the
Stacks layer to trustlessly write to Bitcoin through the peg-out transactions. Atomic swaps
and assets: Stacks already has atomic BTC swaps and enables Bitcoin addresses to own and
move assets defined on the Stacks layer. Magic swaps [2] and Catamaran swaps [3] are
examples of trustless atomic swaps between BTC on Bitcoin L1 and assets on the Stacks
layer that are already live. Further, users can own Stacks layer assets like STX, stablecoins,
and NFTs on Bitcoin addresses and transfer them using Bitcoin L1 transactions if they
prefer.
3. Clarity language: supports Clarity, a safe, decidable language for provable smart
contracts. With Clarity, developers can know with mathematical certainty what a contract
can and cannot do, even before executing it [5]. The decentralized peg contract will benefit
from the safety properties of the Clarity language. As of Dec 2022, there are 5,000+ Clarity
contracts already deployed on the Stacks layer [6].
4. Knowledge of Bitcoin state: has knowledge of the full Bitcoin state; it can trustlessly read
Bitcoin transactions and state changes and execute smart contracts triggered by Bitcoin
transactions. The Bitcoin read functionality helps to keep the decentralized peg state
consistent with BTC locked on Bitcoin L1, amongst other things.
5. Scalable, fast transactions: will provide high performance and scalability through several
mechanisms, including faster Stacks layer blocks between Bitcoin blocks. Further,
scalability layers like subnets~\ref{sec:subnets} can make different tradeoffs between
performance and decentralization than the main Stacks layer. Subnets can support other
programming languages and execution environments (e.g., Ethereum’s Solidity and EVM,
which allows all Ethereum smart contracts to use the Bitcoin-pegged asset and settle on the
Bitcoin chain).
If users can easily move BTC in and out of a Bitcoin layer, and smart contracts at the layer are
able to trustlessly read and write Bitcoin state then that unlocks the deployment of hundreds of
billions of dollars of latent Bitcoin capital into applications like decentralized Bitcoin-backed
lending, Bitcoin-backed stablecoins, and more. All these applications increase demand for
Bitcoin, making it more valuable and increasing its utility to the world. Increased application
activity through Stacks can result in higher transaction fees for Bitcoin miners, aiding Bitcoin’s
security in the long term, as Bitcoin coinbase incentives must be replaced by transaction fees in
the coming years. The Nakamoto release of Stacks, with trustless writes and a decentralized
Bitcoin peg, is a major step towards growing the Bitcoin economy.
The Stacks layer’s consensus protocol, Proof of Transfer (PoX), inspired by Bitcoin’s Proof of
2
Work (PoW), is extremely energy-efficient and recycles PoW energy. The design of the
decentralized peg is integrated with, and made possible by, PoX consensus. The Stacks layer’s
native token (STX) is essential to PoX consensus: STX is needed for (a) incentivizing Stacks
miners to maintain the Stacks layer global ledger outside the Bitcoin L1, and (b) providing
liveness guarantee to the sBTC peg and incentives for threshold signers that participate in the
peg mechanism. Existing approaches to Bitcoin pegs, which lack a native token, cannot support
a permissionless, open system and fallback to using custodians or trusting known federation
members.
The Stacks Bitcoin layer project has followed the path of legal compliance with public
disclosures and transparency, along with an explicit focus on decentralization. STX was
distributed to the public through the first-ever SEC-qualified token offering in US history. The
project explicitly decentralized before the Stacks mainnet launch in Jan 2021. Currently, more
than 30 independent entities are working in the decentralized ecosystem.
1. Bitcoin Layers
The decentralization of trust is the primary innovation and promise of blockchains. Even in the
world of cryptocurrencies, recent failures in 2022 have been of centralized entities, further
highlighting the importance of systems that don’t rely on “trusted” centralized intermediaries.
Bitcoin is the most secure, durable, and valuable blockchain; it is already used as a store of
value by millions of people. It is robust, "hard" money, with unprecedented non-custodial
ownership and lack of inflation. The Bitcoin blockchain is also the best settlement layer for
transactions, as it is the most decentralized, censorship-resistant, and durable blockchain.
However, Bitcoin is relatively slow and minimal by design and conservative in its evolution to
preserve these powerful properties. It produces blocks on average every 10 minutes, with only
5-7 transactions per second [7]. It does not provide native support for fully-expressive smart
contracts and hence for sophisticated applications that can utilize its properties. The result is
that Bitcoin has remained a passive rather than a productive asset. Despite its attractive and
unique properties, it has not been a platform for applications besides a store of value and
infrequent money movement.
Bitcoin layers change this. Bitcoin layers extend the functionality and performance of the
Bitcoin blockchain without requiring any changes to it. Several Bitcoin layers exist today at
different stages of development and maturity, such as Liquid for asset issuance, Lightning for
fast payments, and Stacks and RSK for smart contracts. Lightning, for example, is a Bitcoin
layer for scaling payments, enabling faster and cheaper payments in a trust-minimized manner.
Lightning has a peer-to-peer design with no global interactions or state. Payments occur off-
chain through peer-to-peer channels, which perform final net settlement on the Bitcoin main
chain (via Bitcoin transactions) when the channels are closed. Peer-to-peer layers like
Lightning do not provide global state or an execution environment for general computation,
such as a virtual machine.
Many applications, however, need smart contracts and a full execution environment. They
require global rather than just point-to-point interactions with global state, and they need the
fuller expressive capability of smart contracts beyond what Bitcoin Script and Taproot provide
on the Bitcoin main chain. Examples of applications that need fully-expressive smart contracts
3
include Automated Market Makers (AMMs), liquidity pools, marketplace contracts for NFT
trading, decentralized lending pools, and other known or yet-to-be-discovered applications in
various disciplines. It is, therefore, essential to have Bitcoin layers that support fully-expressive
smart contracts, and for those smart contracts to be able to use Bitcoin as their asset and the
Bitcoin blockchain as the final settlement layer. This would generalize Bitcoin’s capabilities
while preserving full L1 security for the smart contract layer transactions.
1.1. Bitcoin Layers for Smart Contracts
Fully-expressive smart contracts enable developers to build any application logic that they
desire. Such smart contracts require global accessibility and persistent storage for their state
and code (whether compiled or not). The Bitcoin blockchain does not allow for arbitrary
contract publishing and storing complex contract state, so contract logic and state must be
stored and executed outside the Bitcoin L1. Because smart contracts should be immutable, they
must be published on a global ledger that is immutable i.e., a separate blockchain.
Existing attempts to enable fully-expressive smart contracts in the broader Bitcoin ecosystem
have focused on the sidechain approach. Sidechains are a type of Bitcoin layer that can support
smart contracts, e.g., RSK and Liquid. In sidechains, BTC is “pegged-in” to a different
blockchain (the sidechain) as a derived asset pegged 1:1 in value to BTC. Smart contracts run
on that other blockchain and operate on the pegged asset there, without much interaction with
the Bitcoin blockchain. BTC is “pegged out” to the Bitcoin blockchain when desired. The only
connection with Bitcoin is through the peg-in and peg-out operations and possibly through
leveraging Bitcoin mining power in merged-mining approaches. Smart contracts on the
sidechain typically do not interact with Bitcoin transactions and BTC; there is no record of
them on the Bitcoin blockchain. This differs from Bitcoin L2 layers, like Lightning, that can
directly interact with Bitcoin transactions and settle transactions on Bitcoin L1. As of 2022,
sidechains in the Bitcoin ecosystem (Liquid, RSK, etc) don’t implement open-membership
Bitcoin peg-outs. They rely on a federation of known, trusted entities or centralized custodians
to do this. Nomic has implemented a decentralized Bitcoin bridge/peg in the Cosmos ecosystem
which is at an early stage. Projects like tBTC [8] and renBTC have attempted decentralized
approaches to Bitcoin-pegged assets for Ethereum (recently renBTC is moving to a federated
design).
RSK uses merged mining for block production and consensus, whereas Liquid uses a known
federation of entities. The security of a merge-mined sidechain depends on how many Bitcoin
miners also choose to mine the sidechain. If all do, the sidechain is very secure. However, if
only some do—or during periods when only some do—it can be insecure as it becomes easy for
a minority of Bitcoin miners to attack the sidechain (for example, the Namecoin chain was at
risk of such attacks for long periods [9]). Mining a smart contract chain is not the same as
mining Bitcoin, as it requires running arbitrary contracts (programs) and dealing with much
larger quantities of data and logic, not just solving hashes. Once there is substantial smart
contract traffic, which current Bitcoin sidechains have not experienced, this can either become
less attractive to miners or can reduce the decentralization of Bitcoin mining. So, relying on
Bitcoin miners for mining smart contract layers may not be a good long-term idea.
4
1.2. Desirable Properties of a Bitcoin Layer for Smart Contracts
How should we implement a Bitcoin layer for general-purpose smart contracts that use BTC as
their asset and settle on the Bitcoin blockchain? One way to look at this is by comparing what
would happen if Bitcoin natively supported smart contracts (like Ethereum does [4]). Such
contracts would, of course, have their code and state on the Bitcoin chain, i.e., on a global
ledger. They would also:
1. have a ledger secured by the entire hash power of Bitcoin,
2. be triggered to execute by normal Bitcoin transactions,
3. be able to write (broadcast) signed transactions to the Bitcoin blockchain in a decentralized,
trustless manner, i.e., without relying on any fixed set of entities,
4. have transactions settle on the Bitcoin chain, so a record of all smart contracts and
transactions is verifiable in a trustless manner by anyone, like other Bitcoin transactions
are, and
5. be subject to Bitcoin short-lived forks (i.e., if the Bitcoin chain experiences short-lived
forks, then (a) only the contracts and transactions that end up on the canonical Bitcoin fork
are valid, and (b) contracts and transactions should not become inconsistent with Bitcoin as
a result of forks on Bitcoin).
While these are desirable characteristics, we also want mechanisms to achieve higher
transaction throughput and lower latency of transaction completion than Bitcoin allows.
Evaluating the sidechain approach against the properties of hypothetical native Bitcoin smart
contracts, we see that it does not satisfy a number of the properties:
1. The Bitcoin layer or its smart contracts are not secured by the full hash power of Bitcoin,
unless every Bitcoin miner mines the sidechain too.
2. Its smart contracts are not triggered by ordinary Bitcoin transactions (in current sidechain
implementations).
3. They can write Bitcoin transactions, though not in a trustless manner (given federated
pegs).
4. Other than peg operations, their transactions don’t settle on the Bitcoin chain but are
entirely separate, and transaction settlements cannot be verified on Bitcoin.
5. They do not fork with Bitcoin as there is no close ongoing relationship between them, and
they are largely unaware of Bitcoin forks.
The fact that a sidechain operates independently of Bitcoin, other than the peg, enables it to
operate with higher transaction throughput and lower latency, largely unconstrained by the
speed of Bitcoin, but without transactions settling on the Bitcoin blockchain. The Stacks
Bitcoin layer is designed to come as close to these desirable properties of native Bitcoin
smart contracts as possible but also enables high performance. In the next section, we
present the Stacks Bitcoin layer for smart contracts and examine how it does with regard to
these ideal properties of native Bitcoin smart contracts.
5
2. The Stacks Bitcoin Layer
Stacks is a different type of Bitcoin layer for smart contracts than sidechains, with a deeper,
ongoing connection to Bitcoin. The Stacks layer enables applications and smart contracts to use
BTC as their asset or money and to settle their transactions on the Bitcoin main chain. The goal
of the Stacks layer is to grow the Bitcoin economy, by turning BTC into a productive
rather than passive asset, and by enabling various decentralized applications. Like
sidechains such as RSK and Liquid, the Stacks layer has its own global ledger and execution
environment, to support smart contracts and to not overwhelm the Bitcoin blockchain with
additional transactions. However, the Stacks layer is unique as it has most of the ideal
properties that native Bitcoin smart contracts would have. It also provides mechanisms for
higher performance, such as fast blocks, the decentralized peg ( Section 2.3 ), and subnets (
Section 3.1).
Unlike RSK and Liquid, Stacks also has its own native asset (STX) . This is not merely a
governance or speculative token, but it is central to the consensus mechanism of the Stacks
Bitcoin layer, discussed below, and is essential for two key goals: (i) it incentivizes mining of
Stacks blocks with a “new block subsidy,” which is critical since transaction fees are not
enough to sustain a ledger at least in the early days (as is the case with Bitcoin itself), and (ii) it
serves as the liveness incentive and the basis for the economically secured decentralized Bitcoin
peg. Despite having its own native asset, the Stacks layer helps grow Bitcoin and does not
compete with Bitcoin (see Section 2.2).
The Stacks layer relies on STX and on BTC for its novel consensus mechanism, called Proof
of Transfer (PoX), that utilizes both the Stacks and Bitcoin layers. PoX is similar in spirit to
Bitcoin’s Proof of Work (PoW) consensus: Like how Bitcoin PoW miners spend electricity and
are rewarded in BTC, Stacks PoX miners spend (already mined) BTC and are rewarded in STX.
Like PoW, PoX uses a Nakamoto-style single-leader election: PoX miners bid by simply
spending BTC, and they have a bid-weighted random probability of becoming a leader. Leader
election happens on the Bitcoin chain and new blocks are written on the Stacks layer. In this
way, PoX reuses work already done by Bitcoin miners, and does not consume any significant
amount of additional electricity: only the cost of running normal laptops/computers for Stacks
nodes to bid using BTC.
Like PoW, PoX is permissionless: Anyone can be a Stacks miner, as long as they are willing
to spend BTC. Also, any STX holder can lock their STX (called “stacking”) to participate in
PoX consensus, and earn Bitcoin rewards for doing useful work for the system, i.e., for being a
signatory for the decentralized Bitcoin peg. In keeping with Bitcoin ethos, Stackers are
rewarded for their positive contributions to the system and inhibited by economic disincentives
from behaving poorly (but unlike in bonded Proof of Stake systems, they are not "slashed").
Finally, the nature of PoX consensus is such that the price ratio between BTC and STX is
continually recorded and available on-chain, serving as an on-chain Bitcoin pr프로젝트로 돌아가기