bitpro가 원문에서 글자만 모은 내용이에요. 표·그림·수식은 빠지거나 깨질 수 있어요. 전체 3쪽 중 1쪽
POL:
One
token
for
all
Polygon
chains
Mihailo
Bjelic
Sandeep
Nailwal
Amit
Chaudhary
Wenxuan
Deng
mihailo@polygon.org
sandeep@polygon.org
amit@chainsolid.com
wdeng@polygon.org
Abstract
This
paper
proposes
POL,
the
native
token
of
the
revised
Polygon
protocol
architecture,
commonly
referred
to
as
Polygon
2.0.
As
the
successor
of
MATIC,
POL
is
envisioned
to
become
an
instrumental
tool
for
coordination
and
growth
of
the
Polygon
ecosystem
and
the
main
driver
of
the
vision
of
Polygon
as
the
Value
Layer
for
the
Internet.
We
start
by
analyzing
relevant
work,
identifying
opportunities
and
threats
and,
based
on
that,
we
establish
POL
design
goals.
We
propose
design,
utility
and
tokenomics
of
POL
that
achieve
all
the
design
goals.
We
describe
the
concept
of
the
Staking
Layer,
a
one-of-a-kind,
POL-powered
chain
coordinator,
capable
of
supporting
a
practically
unlimited
number
of
Polygon
chains
with
arbitrary
features
and
configurations.
We
believe
the
introduction
of
the
Staking
Layer
and
the
wider
Polygon
2.0
architecture
can
establish
Polygon
as
the
third
most
important
and
impactful
breakthrough
in
Web3
(the
first
two
being
Bitcoin
and
Ethereum),
given
the
magnitude
of
innovation
and
adoption
it
can
facilitate.
We
introduce
the
Community
Treasury,
an
in-protocol,
community-governed
fund
designed
to
provide
ongoing
economic
support
for
further
development
and
growth
of
the
Polygon
ecosystem.
We
describe
the
process
of
migration
from
MATIC
to
POL.
To
analyze
the
proposed
design,
we
define
an
economic
simulation
model
and
run
simulations
to
confirm
the
hypothesis
of
the
model,
derived
from
the
aforementioned
design
goals.
Based
on
everything
above,
we
conclude
that
POL
is
a
novel,
next
generation
asset
that
provides
a
solid
foundation
for
the
ambitious
vision
of
the
Value
Layer.
Contents
1.
Polygon
vision
…………………………………………………………………………………
3
2.
Relevant
work
………………………………………………………………………………….
4
2.1
Bitcoin
(BTC)
…………………………………………………………………………..……
4
2.2
Etherum
(ETH)
………………………………………………………………………..……
5
2.3
Cosmos
(ATOM)
……………………………………………….……………………..……
5
2.4
Polkadot
(DOT)
………………………………………………………………………..……
6
2.5
Aave
(AAVE)
…………………………………………………………………………..……
7
3.
Design
Goals
…………………………………………………………………………….…….
7
4.
Utility
…………………………………………………………………………………………….
8
4.1
Validator
staking
…………….………………………………………………………..……
8
4.2
Validator
rewards
……..……………………………………………………………………
9
4.3
Governance
……..…………………………………….……………………………………
9
5.
Supply
……………………………………….………………………………………………….
9
5.1
Initial
supply
…………….……………………………………………………………..……
9
5.2
Emission
……..…………………………………………….………………………………
10
6.
Staking
Layer
……………………………………………………………………….………..
12
6.1
Design
and
implementation
………...………………………………………………...…
13
6.2
Polygon
chains
management
………………………………………………………...…
14
6.3
Validator
management
…………………..………………………….……………………
16
7.
Community
Treasury
………………………….…..………………………………………...
17
8.
Migration
…………………………………………….……………………………………..….
18
9.
Model
…………………………………………………………………………………….…….
19
9.1
Hypothesis
…………………………………………………………………………...……
19
9.2
Inputs
………………………………………………………………………………....……
20
9.3
Methodology
……………...…………………………………….…………………………
22
9.4
Results
…………..…………………………………………………………………………
23
10.
Conclusion
……………………………………………….………………………………..….
24
2
1
Vision
The
vision
behind
Polygon
as
the
Value
Layer
of
the
Internet
is
to
usher
a
world
in
which
value
can
be
created
and
exchanged
freely
and
globally,
similarly
to
how
we
create
and
exchange
information
today.
A
world
which
enables
new
–
fairer,
more
inclusive
and
more
efficient
–
forms
of
human
organizations
and
governance.
We
strongly
believe
that
realizing
this
vision
can
significantly
advance
our
society.
In
order
to
make
this
ambitious
vision
a
reality,
Polygon’s
infrastructure
must
improve.
Specifically,
it
must
become
exponentially
more
scalable,
without
sacrificing
security
and
user
experience.
To
address
this,
a
reimagined
protocol
architecture
is
being
introduced
as
part
of
the
Polygon
2.0
effort.
This
radical
redesign
turns
Polygon
into
a
network
of
ZK-powered
L2
chains,
unified
via
a
novel
cross-chain
coordination
protocol.
The
network
can
support
a
practically
unlimited
number
of
chains,
and
cross-chain
interactions
can
happen
seamlessly
and
instantly
without
additional
security
or
trust
assumptions.
This
design
fully
delivers
on
the
aforementioned
requirement
–
exponential
scalability
without
sacrificing
security
and
user
experience.
Figure
1.
Polygon
protocol
architecture
To
coordinate,
secure
and
grow
this
powerful
network,
an
advanced,
well-designed
protocol
economy
and
mechanism
design
are
necessary.
This
inspired
the
creation
of
POL.
3
2
Relevant
work
In
this
chapter
we
outline
relevant
native
token
design
examples,
the
utility
they
assign
to
the
token
as
well
as
notable
advantages
and
disadvantages.
2.1
Bitcoin
(BTC)
BTC
is
the
native
token
of
the
Bitcoin
protocol,
and
it’s
the
first
prominent
native
token
implementation.
The
utility
of
BTC
is
twofold:
●
Miner
rewards:
The
protocol
emits
BTC
and
distributes
it
to
protocol
validators,
aka
miners;
●
Transaction
fees:
Users
pay
fees
in
BTC
for
every
transaction,
which
prevents
spam
and
provides
additional
incentives
for
miners.
One
advantage
of
the
BTC
design
is
a
deterministic,
i.e.
predictable
supply.
Normally,
tokens
with
deterministic
supply
are
more
attractive
to
holders
and
can
capture
value
better
than
those
with
non-deterministic
supply.
We
consider
BTC
a
legacy
token
design
and
we
argue
its
disadvantages
are
multifold:
●
It
is
an
unproductive
asset,
it
does
not
give
its
holders
any
meaningful
role
in
the
protocol
nor
the
incentives
to
performs
such
a
role;
●
It
does
not
leverage
the
opportunity
to
require
stake
in
the
native
token
for
protocol
validators
and
instead
requires
them
to
stake,
i.e.
invest
external
resources
(mining
equipment
and
electricity),
thus
making
protocol
less
resilient
and
self-sustainable;
●
It
gradually
reduces
emission
for
mining
rewards
until
it
reaches
zero,
which
introduces
sustainability
and
security
concerns
(it
is
unclear
if
the
security
can
be
maintained
once
the
emission
rate
becomes
low
or
reaches
zero);
●
It
does
not
introduce
any
type
of
economic
support
to
the
ecosystem;
●
It
does
not
give
any
governance
rights
to
holders,
although
it
can
be
argued
that
Layer
1
protocols
such
as
Bitcoin
should
not
utilize
tokens
for
governance.
2.2
Ethereum
(ETH)
ETH
is
the
native
token
of
the
Ethereum
protocol
and
ecosystem.
With
its
innovative
design,
it
established
the
next
generation
of
native
protocol
tokens.
4
The
utility
of
ETH
is
multifold:
●
Validators
staking:
Ethereum’s
PoS
(Proof-of-Stake)
protocol
requires
validators
to
stake
ETH
in
order
to
join
the
validator
pool;
●
Validator
rewards:
The
protocol
emits
ETH
and
distributes
it
to
protocol
validators;
●
Transaction
fees:
Users
pay
fees
in
ETH
for
every
transaction,
which
prevents
spam
and
provides
additional
incentives
for
validators.
The
design
of
ETH
has
multiple
advantages:
●
It
is
a
productive
asset,
its
holders
can
participate
in
securing
the
network
and
they
receive
incentives
for
doing
that;
●
It
disincentivizes
malicious
behavior
of
validators
via
in-protocol
slashing,
i.e.
destroying
tokens
of
malicious
validators;
●
It
does
not
introduce
security
and
sustainability
concerns,
given
that
it
doesn’t
have
supply
cap
like
BTC;
●
It
provides
economic
support
to
the
ecosystem
via
a
predetermined
portion
of
the
initial
supply
allocated
to
the
stewarding
foundation.
One
potential
disadvantage
of
the
ETH
design
is
that
it
does
not
have
fully
predictable
supply,
given
that
token
emission
for
validator
rewards
increases
as
more
tokens
get
staked.
However,
this
is
successfully
countered
by
the
built-in
mechanism
that
burns
1
a
portion
of
every
transaction
fee,
thus
countering
the
impact
of
token
emission
for
validator
rewards.
Another
disadvantage
is
that
the
aforementioned
economic
support
can
not
last
indefinitely;
the
initial
token
allocation
to
the
stewarding
foundation
will
eventually
get
depleted.
Lastly,
it
does
not
assign
any
governance
right
to
token
holders,
although,
as
mentioned
above,
it
can
be
argued
that
Layer
1
protocols
should
not
utilize
tokens
for
governance.
2.3
Cosmos
(ATOM)
ATOM
is
the
native
token
of
the
Cosmos
Hub,
the
intended
central
blockchain
of
the
Cosmos
multi-chain
ecosystem.
It
has
multifold
utility,
but
only
within
Cosmos
Hub:
●
Validators
staking;
●
Validator
rewards;
●
Transaction
fees;
1
https://github.com/ethereum/EIPs/blob/master/EIPS/eip-1559.md
5
●
Governance.
The
design
of
ATOM
has
the
following
advantages:
●
It
is
a
productive
asset,
its
holders
can
participate
in
securing
Cosmos
Hub
and
receive
incentives
for
doing
that;
●
It
does
not
introduce
security
and
sustainability
concerns,
given
that
it
doesn’t
have
supply
cap;
●
It
provides
economic
support
to
the
ecosystem
via
a
predetermined
allocation
to
the
stewarding
foundation;
●
It
gives
its
holders
governance
rights
via
a
comprehensive
governance
model.
The
disadvantages
of
ATOM
design:
●
It
only
has
utility
within
Cosmos
Hub;
it
is
not
used
to
run
and
secure
other
chains
in
the
ecosystem,
although
there
are
initiatives
to
enable
this;
●
It
facilitates
a
token-only
governance
model,
which
excludes
other
relevant
stakeholders
of
the
ecosystem
(developers,
prominent
contributors,
applications
etc.)
from
decision
making;
●
Economic
support
it
facilitates
can
not
last
indefinitely,
since
the
token
treasury
will
eventually
get
depleted.
2.4
Polkadot
(DOT)
DOT
is
the
native
token
of
the
Polkadot
multi-chain
ecosystem.
It
has
the
same
utility
as
ATOM,
but
generally
across
the
whole
Polkadot
ecosystem:
●
Validators
staking;
●
Validator
rewards;
●
Transaction
fees;
●
Governance.
The
design
of
DOT
has
the
following
advantages:
●
It
is
a
productive
asset;
●
It
does
not
introduce
security
and
sustainability
concerns,
given
that
it
doesn’t
have
supply
cap;
●
It
provides
economic
support
to
the
ecosystem
via
a
predetermined
allocation
to
the
stewarding
foundation;
●
It
gives
its
holders
governance
rights
via
a
comprehensive
governance
model;
6
●
It
provides
security
for
the
whole
ecosystem,
i.e.
all
participating
blockchains.
The
disadvantages
are:
●
It
mandates
the
usage
of
DOT
as
the
validator
staking
token
for
all
participating
chains,
thus
reducing
architectural
options
for
developers
of
Polkadot
chains;
●
It
introduces
a
significant
level
of
friction
for
developers
of
Polkadot
blockchains
who
are
required
to
bid
and
lock
significant
amounts
of
DOT
in
order
for
their
chains
to
become
part
of
the
ecosystem;
●
It
facilitates
a
token-only
governance
model,
which
excludes
other
relevant
stakeholders
of
the
ecosystem
from
decision
making;
●
Economic
support
it
facilitates
can
not
last
indefinitely,
since
the
token
treasury
will
eventually
get
depleted.
2.5
Aave
(Aave)
AAVE
is
the
native
token
of
Aave,
an
on-chain
token
lending
platform.
Given
that
AAVE
is
not
a
protocol
but
an
application
token,
we
do
not
analyze
its
design,
advantages
and
disadvantages.
The
relevance
of
AAVE
for
POL
design
is
twofold:
●
AAVE
is
the
successor
of
LEND,
the
initial
native
token
of
Aave;
the
Aave
community
executed
a
successful
and
beneficial
migration
from
LEND
to
AAVE;
●
AAVE
provides
its
holders
governance
rights
via
a
comprehensive
governance
model.
3
Design
goals
Based
on
the
analysis
of
relevant
work,
several
major
opportunities
for
POL
to
benefit
the
Polygon
ecosystem
were
identified.
These
opportunities
are
brought
forward
here
as
POL
design
goals.
1.
Ecosystem
security
.
POL
should
help
establish
a
highly
decentralized
pool
of
validators
that
can
run
and
secure
any
Polygon
chain.
Validators
should
be
incentivized
to
join
and
stay
in
the
validator
pool
and
help
secure
as
many
chains
as
possible,
and
at
the
same
time
disincentivized
to
do
anything
malicious.
2.
Infinite
scalability.
POL
should
support
exponential
growth
of
the
Polygon
ecosystem
and
eventual
“hyperblochainization”
of
the
world.
Primarily,
it
should
enable
the
validator
pool
to
scale
to
support
thousands
of
Polygon
chains.
7
3.
Ecosystem
support.
Being
a
global
network
in
the
making,
Polygon
will
require
ongoing
economic
support
for
further
development
and
growth.
POL
should
help
establish
a
self-sustaining
funding
mechanism
for
those
activities.
This
funding
“vehicle”
should
be
governed
by
the
Polygon
community.
4.
No
friction
.
Blockchain
networks
often
require
both
users
and
developers
to
hold,
stake
or
consume
their
native
tokens
in
order
to
use
the
network.
This
causes
friction
and
degrades
user
and
developer
experience.
POL
should
be
designed
in
a
way
that
does
not
introduce
any
such
friction.
5.
Community
ownership.
Polygon
is
envisioned
as
a
decentralized
network
governed
by
its
community.
Assigning
governance
rights
to
POL
holders
can
enable
creation
of
effective
governance
models
in
which
decision
makers
are
directly
incentivized
to
support
proposals
that
are
in
the
best
interest
of
the
Polygon
ecosystem.
4
Utility
POL
is
the
native
token
of
Polygon,
and
as
such
represents
the
major
tool
for
coordination
and
incentivization
of
the
whole
Polygon
ecosystem.
It
has
multi-fold
utility,
namely:
●
Validator
staking;
●
Validator
rewards;
●
Community
ownership,
i.e.
governance.
4.1
Validator
staking
Polygon
validators
are
required
to
stake
POL
in
order
to
join
the
validator
pool.
Validator
staking
increases
security
of
the
ecosystem
by:
●
Preventing
Sybil
attacks;
●
Aligning
validators
with
the
success
of
the
ecosystem;
●
Enabling
slashing,
i.e.
punishment
of
malicious
validators.
By
staking
POL
and
joining
the
validator
pool,
validators
become
eligible
to
subscribe
to
validate
any
Polygon
chain.
Validation
and
its
benefits
for
validators
are
further
explained
in
§
6.3.
8
4.2
Validator
rewards
Decentralization
and
size
of
the
validator
pool
is
critically
important
for
security,
resilience
and
neutrality
of
the
whole
Polygon
ecosystem.
To
incentivize
validator
onboarding
and
retention,
predefined
amounts
of
POL
should
be
continuously
distributed
to
Polygon
validators
as
protocol
rewards.
Protocol
rewards
should
be
distributed
to
validators
proportionally
to
the
amount
of
POL
they
stake.
POL
emission
is
described
in
§
5.2.
Protocol
rewards
provide
base
incentives
for
validators
and
establish
a
level
playing
field
for
the
whole
validator
pool.
On
top
of
it,
validators
can
then
secure
additional
incentives
by
validating
individual
Polygon
chains.
Additional
validator
incentives
are
described
in
§
6.3.
4.3
Governance
To
facilitate
efficient,
community-run
governance
of
important
aspects
of
the
Polygon
ecosystem,
POL
should
be
technically
enabled
to
hold
governance
rights,
i.e.
be
utilized
in
governance
frameworks.
Describing
the
Polygon
governance
framework
is
out
of
the
scope
of
this
paper.
5
Supply
Here
we
cover
the
initial
supply
and
the
emission
policy
of
POL,
and
describe
the
rationale
behind
both.
5.1
Initial
supply
The
initial
supply
of
POL
is
10
billion
tokens.
The
entirety
of
the
initial
supply
should
be
dedicated
for
migration,
i.e.
token
swap
from
MATIC
to
POL.
This
migration
would
need
to
take
place
in
order
for
POL
to
succeed
MATIC
as
the
native
token
of
the
Polygon
ecosystem,
and
it
is
discussed
in
§
8.
The
initial
supply
of
POL
matches
the
supply
of
MATIC,
which
should
make
the
migration
quite
straightforward.
Once
the
migration
is
complete,
the
distribution
of
POL
would
essentially
match
the
current
distribution
of
MATIC.
MATIC
has
already
gone
through
an
extensive
process
of
token
distribution
which
has
resulted
in
more
than
600,000
holder
addresses
2
,
and
likely
even
more
2
Source:
https://etherscan.io/token/0x7d1afa7b718fb893db30a3abc0cfc608aacfebb0#balances
9
actual
holders,
given
that
centralized
crypto
exchanges’
and
DeFi
protocols’
addresses
represent
multiple
users.
This
implies
that
POL
would
be
widely
distributed
from
day
one,
which
is
instrumental
for
overall
decentralization
and
resilience
of
the
ecosystem.
5.2
Emission
POL
is
emitted
at
a
predefined,
deterministic
rate
for
two
purposes:
1.
Validator
rewards.
To
incentivize
validator
onboarding
and
retention,
POL
should
be
continuously
emitted
at
a
predetermined
rate
and
distributed
to
validators
as
the
base,
protocol
reward.
We
propose
a
yearly
emission
rate
of
1%
of
the
POL
supply
for
this
purpose.
The
emission
rate
would
not
be
possible
to
change
for
the
initial
10
years,
and
after
that
period
the
community
can
decide
to
decrease
it
in
an
arbitrary
way
via
the
governance
framework.
The
emission
rate
can
never
be
increased
beyond
1%.
2.
Ecosystem
support.
To
provide
ongoing
support
for
further
development
and
growth
of
the
Polygon
ecosystem,
we
propose
to
introduce
the
Community
Treasury,
a
community-governed
ecosystem
fund,
described
in
§
7.
We
propose
a
yearly
emission
rate
of
1%
of
the
POL
supply
for
this
purpose.
Just
like
the
emission
for
validator
rewards,
this
emission
rate
can
be
decreased
after
10
years
via
a
governance
framework,
and
it
can
never
be
increased
beyond
1%.
Figure
2.
Possible
POL
emission
rate
scenarios
The
rationale
for
the
proposed
emission
and
the
emission
rates
is
that
the
Polygon
ecosystem
and
Web3
in
general
will
need
time
to
mature
and
reach
mainstream
adoption.
Based
on
the
10
historical
Internet
and
computing
platforms
adoption
cycles,
the
maturity
phase
could
be
realistically
expected
to
happen
in
about
10-15
years.
During
that
period,
the
ecosystem
will
need
economic
support.
Once
the
Polygon
ecosystem
and
Web3
reach
maturity,
transaction
fees
and
other
incentives
secured
by
validating
Polygon
chains
(described
in
§
6.3)
should
alone
generate
sufficient
returns
for
Polygon
validators.
Once
that
happens,
the
community
can
decide
to
intervene
and
reduce
or
completely
discontinue
the
emission
for
validator
rewards,
without
impacting
security
and
decentralization
of
the
ecosystem.
Similarly,
the
community
can
then
decide
to
decrease
or
discontinue
the
emission
for
the
Community
Treasury
as
well,
given
that
the
ecosystem
will
not
need
significant
economic
support
anymore.
Obviously,
the
adoption
cycle
of
Web3
might
look
slightly
or
completely
different.
In
case
it
turns
out
that
reaching
mainstream
adoption
takes
more
time
and
the
ecosystem
still
needs
support
after
10
years,
the
community
can
choose
not
to
intervene
and
the
emission
will
continue
to
happen
for
as
long
as
required.
We
consider
the
proposed
emission
policy
optimal,
as
it
achieves
the
equilibrium
between:
●
Sufficient
ecosystem
support.
Sufficient,
future-proof
support
to
the
Polygon
ecosystem
is
critically
important
for
security
and
success
of
Polygon.
To
validate
the
hypothesis
that
the
proposed
emission
rates
are
indeed
sufficient,
we
developed
an
economic
model,
ran
simulations
and
presented
results
in
§
9.
●
Security
via
scarcity.
Scarcity
of
native
tokens
is
instrumentally
important
for
blockchain
networks;
high
token
dilution
can
dramatically
affect
security.
To
estimate
POL
scarcity,
we
can
compare
the
proposed
emission
rate
to
the
emission
rate
of
BTC,
which
is
currently
at
≈1.8%
3
,
and
has
been
significantly
higher
in
the
past.
Also,
although
gradually
declining,
BTC
emission
is
guaranteed
to
happen
for
more
than
another
century,
whilst
POL
emission
could
potentially
be
reduced
or
discontinued
even
after
10
years.
Given
that
(i)
Bitcoin
is
considered
a
highly
scarce
asset,
and
(ii)
total
POL
emission
rate
is
comparable
to
(and
potentially
more
strict
than)
BTC,
we
conclude
that
POL
is
sufficiently
scarce,
i.e.
its
emission
does
not
introduce
protocol
security
concerns.
3
Source:
https://charts.woobull.com/bitcoin-inflation/
11
Lastly,
it
is
important
to
note
that
the
emission
policy
we
propose
has
a
high
degree
of
predictability.
The
predetermined
emission
schedule
makes
POL
supply
predictable
in
the
long
term,
even
if
the
community
decides
to
intervene.
As
explained,
the
community
can
only
decrease
the
rates,
thus
effectively
complementing
the
predetermined
emission
policy
and
potentially
increasing
scarcity
of
POL.
Predictability
and
scarcity
attract
protoc프로젝트로 돌아가기