POL 백서

bitpro가 원문에서 글자만 모은 내용이에요. 표·그림·수식은 빠지거나 깨질 수 있어요. 전체 3쪽 중 1쪽

POL: One token for all Polygon chains Mihailo Bjelic Sandeep Nailwal Amit Chaudhary Wenxuan Deng mihailo@polygon.org sandeep@polygon.org amit@chainsolid.com wdeng@polygon.org Abstract This paper proposes POL, the native token of the revised Polygon protocol architecture, commonly referred to as Polygon 2.0. As the successor of MATIC, POL is envisioned to become an instrumental tool for coordination and growth of the Polygon ecosystem and the main driver of the vision of Polygon as the Value Layer for the Internet. We start by analyzing relevant work, identifying opportunities and threats and, based on that, we establish POL design goals. We propose design, utility and tokenomics of POL that achieve all the design goals. We describe the concept of the Staking Layer, a one-of-a-kind, POL-powered chain coordinator, capable of supporting a practically unlimited number of Polygon chains with arbitrary features and configurations. We believe the introduction of the Staking Layer and the wider Polygon 2.0 architecture can establish Polygon as the third most important and impactful breakthrough in Web3 (the first two being Bitcoin and Ethereum), given the magnitude of innovation and adoption it can facilitate. We introduce the Community Treasury, an in-protocol, community-governed fund designed to provide ongoing economic support for further development and growth of the Polygon ecosystem. We describe the process of migration from MATIC to POL. To analyze the proposed design, we define an economic simulation model and run simulations to confirm the hypothesis of the model, derived from the aforementioned design goals. Based on everything above, we conclude that POL is a novel, next generation asset that provides a solid foundation for the ambitious vision of the Value Layer. Contents 1. Polygon vision ………………………………………………………………………………… 3 2. Relevant work …………………………………………………………………………………. 4 2.1 Bitcoin (BTC) …………………………………………………………………………..…… 4 2.2 Etherum (ETH) ………………………………………………………………………..…… 5 2.3 Cosmos (ATOM) ……………………………………………….……………………..…… 5 2.4 Polkadot (DOT) ………………………………………………………………………..…… 6 2.5 Aave (AAVE) …………………………………………………………………………..…… 7 3. Design Goals …………………………………………………………………………….……. 7 4. Utility ……………………………………………………………………………………………. 8 4.1 Validator staking …………….………………………………………………………..…… 8 4.2 Validator rewards ……..…………………………………………………………………… 9 4.3 Governance ……..…………………………………….…………………………………… 9 5. Supply ……………………………………….…………………………………………………. 9 5.1 Initial supply …………….……………………………………………………………..…… 9 5.2 Emission ……..…………………………………………….……………………………… 10 6. Staking Layer ……………………………………………………………………….……….. 12 6.1 Design and implementation ………...………………………………………………...… 13 6.2 Polygon chains management ………………………………………………………...… 14 6.3 Validator management …………………..………………………….…………………… 16 7. Community Treasury ………………………….…..………………………………………... 17 8. Migration …………………………………………….……………………………………..…. 18 9. Model …………………………………………………………………………………….……. 19 9.1 Hypothesis …………………………………………………………………………...…… 19 9.2 Inputs ………………………………………………………………………………....…… 20 9.3 Methodology ……………...…………………………………….………………………… 22 9.4 Results …………..………………………………………………………………………… 23 10. Conclusion ……………………………………………….………………………………..…. 24 2 1 Vision The vision behind Polygon as the Value Layer of the Internet is to usher a world in which value can be created and exchanged freely and globally, similarly to how we create and exchange information today. A world which enables new – fairer, more inclusive and more efficient – forms of human organizations and governance. We strongly believe that realizing this vision can significantly advance our society. In order to make this ambitious vision a reality, Polygon’s infrastructure must improve. Specifically, it must become exponentially more scalable, without sacrificing security and user experience. To address this, a reimagined protocol architecture is being introduced as part of the Polygon 2.0 effort. This radical redesign turns Polygon into a network of ZK-powered L2 chains, unified via a novel cross-chain coordination protocol. The network can support a practically unlimited number of chains, and cross-chain interactions can happen seamlessly and instantly without additional security or trust assumptions. This design fully delivers on the aforementioned requirement – exponential scalability without sacrificing security and user experience. Figure 1. Polygon protocol architecture To coordinate, secure and grow this powerful network, an advanced, well-designed protocol economy and mechanism design are necessary. This inspired the creation of POL. 3 2 Relevant work In this chapter we outline relevant native token design examples, the utility they assign to the token as well as notable advantages and disadvantages. 2.1 Bitcoin (BTC) BTC is the native token of the Bitcoin protocol, and it’s the first prominent native token implementation. The utility of BTC is twofold: ● Miner rewards: The protocol emits BTC and distributes it to protocol validators, aka miners; ● Transaction fees: Users pay fees in BTC for every transaction, which prevents spam and provides additional incentives for miners. One advantage of the BTC design is a deterministic, i.e. predictable supply. Normally, tokens with deterministic supply are more attractive to holders and can capture value better than those with non-deterministic supply. We consider BTC a legacy token design and we argue its disadvantages are multifold: ● It is an unproductive asset, it does not give its holders any meaningful role in the protocol nor the incentives to performs such a role; ● It does not leverage the opportunity to require stake in the native token for protocol validators and instead requires them to stake, i.e. invest external resources (mining equipment and electricity), thus making protocol less resilient and self-sustainable; ● It gradually reduces emission for mining rewards until it reaches zero, which introduces sustainability and security concerns (it is unclear if the security can be maintained once the emission rate becomes low or reaches zero); ● It does not introduce any type of economic support to the ecosystem; ● It does not give any governance rights to holders, although it can be argued that Layer 1 protocols such as Bitcoin should not utilize tokens for governance. 2.2 Ethereum (ETH) ETH is the native token of the Ethereum protocol and ecosystem. With its innovative design, it established the next generation of native protocol tokens. 4 The utility of ETH is multifold: ● Validators staking: Ethereum’s PoS (Proof-of-Stake) protocol requires validators to stake ETH in order to join the validator pool; ● Validator rewards: The protocol emits ETH and distributes it to protocol validators; ● Transaction fees: Users pay fees in ETH for every transaction, which prevents spam and provides additional incentives for validators. The design of ETH has multiple advantages: ● It is a productive asset, its holders can participate in securing the network and they receive incentives for doing that; ● It disincentivizes malicious behavior of validators via in-protocol slashing, i.e. destroying tokens of malicious validators; ● It does not introduce security and sustainability concerns, given that it doesn’t have supply cap like BTC; ● It provides economic support to the ecosystem via a predetermined portion of the initial supply allocated to the stewarding foundation. One potential disadvantage of the ETH design is that it does not have fully predictable supply, given that token emission for validator rewards increases as more tokens get staked. However, this is successfully countered by the built-in mechanism that burns 1 a portion of every transaction fee, thus countering the impact of token emission for validator rewards. Another disadvantage is that the aforementioned economic support can not last indefinitely; the initial token allocation to the stewarding foundation will eventually get depleted. Lastly, it does not assign any governance right to token holders, although, as mentioned above, it can be argued that Layer 1 protocols should not utilize tokens for governance. 2.3 Cosmos (ATOM) ATOM is the native token of the Cosmos Hub, the intended central blockchain of the Cosmos multi-chain ecosystem. It has multifold utility, but only within Cosmos Hub: ● Validators staking; ● Validator rewards; ● Transaction fees; 1 https://github.com/ethereum/EIPs/blob/master/EIPS/eip-1559.md 5 ● Governance. The design of ATOM has the following advantages: ● It is a productive asset, its holders can participate in securing Cosmos Hub and receive incentives for doing that; ● It does not introduce security and sustainability concerns, given that it doesn’t have supply cap; ● It provides economic support to the ecosystem via a predetermined allocation to the stewarding foundation; ● It gives its holders governance rights via a comprehensive governance model. The disadvantages of ATOM design: ● It only has utility within Cosmos Hub; it is not used to run and secure other chains in the ecosystem, although there are initiatives to enable this; ● It facilitates a token-only governance model, which excludes other relevant stakeholders of the ecosystem (developers, prominent contributors, applications etc.) from decision making; ● Economic support it facilitates can not last indefinitely, since the token treasury will eventually get depleted. 2.4 Polkadot (DOT) DOT is the native token of the Polkadot multi-chain ecosystem. It has the same utility as ATOM, but generally across the whole Polkadot ecosystem: ● Validators staking; ● Validator rewards; ● Transaction fees; ● Governance. The design of DOT has the following advantages: ● It is a productive asset; ● It does not introduce security and sustainability concerns, given that it doesn’t have supply cap; ● It provides economic support to the ecosystem via a predetermined allocation to the stewarding foundation; ● It gives its holders governance rights via a comprehensive governance model; 6 ● It provides security for the whole ecosystem, i.e. all participating blockchains. The disadvantages are: ● It mandates the usage of DOT as the validator staking token for all participating chains, thus reducing architectural options for developers of Polkadot chains; ● It introduces a significant level of friction for developers of Polkadot blockchains who are required to bid and lock significant amounts of DOT in order for their chains to become part of the ecosystem; ● It facilitates a token-only governance model, which excludes other relevant stakeholders of the ecosystem from decision making; ● Economic support it facilitates can not last indefinitely, since the token treasury will eventually get depleted. 2.5 Aave (Aave) AAVE is the native token of Aave, an on-chain token lending platform. Given that AAVE is not a protocol but an application token, we do not analyze its design, advantages and disadvantages. The relevance of AAVE for POL design is twofold: ● AAVE is the successor of LEND, the initial native token of Aave; the Aave community executed a successful and beneficial migration from LEND to AAVE; ● AAVE provides its holders governance rights via a comprehensive governance model. 3 Design goals Based on the analysis of relevant work, several major opportunities for POL to benefit the Polygon ecosystem were identified. These opportunities are brought forward here as POL design goals. 1. Ecosystem security . POL should help establish a highly decentralized pool of validators that can run and secure any Polygon chain. Validators should be incentivized to join and stay in the validator pool and help secure as many chains as possible, and at the same time disincentivized to do anything malicious. 2. Infinite scalability. POL should support exponential growth of the Polygon ecosystem and eventual “hyperblochainization” of the world. Primarily, it should enable the validator pool to scale to support thousands of Polygon chains. 7 3. Ecosystem support. Being a global network in the making, Polygon will require ongoing economic support for further development and growth. POL should help establish a self-sustaining funding mechanism for those activities. This funding “vehicle” should be governed by the Polygon community. 4. No friction . Blockchain networks often require both users and developers to hold, stake or consume their native tokens in order to use the network. This causes friction and degrades user and developer experience. POL should be designed in a way that does not introduce any such friction. 5. Community ownership. Polygon is envisioned as a decentralized network governed by its community. Assigning governance rights to POL holders can enable creation of effective governance models in which decision makers are directly incentivized to support proposals that are in the best interest of the Polygon ecosystem. 4 Utility POL is the native token of Polygon, and as such represents the major tool for coordination and incentivization of the whole Polygon ecosystem. It has multi-fold utility, namely: ● Validator staking; ● Validator rewards; ● Community ownership, i.e. governance. 4.1 Validator staking Polygon validators are required to stake POL in order to join the validator pool. Validator staking increases security of the ecosystem by: ● Preventing Sybil attacks; ● Aligning validators with the success of the ecosystem; ● Enabling slashing, i.e. punishment of malicious validators. By staking POL and joining the validator pool, validators become eligible to subscribe to validate any Polygon chain. Validation and its benefits for validators are further explained in § 6.3. 8 4.2 Validator rewards Decentralization and size of the validator pool is critically important for security, resilience and neutrality of the whole Polygon ecosystem. To incentivize validator onboarding and retention, predefined amounts of POL should be continuously distributed to Polygon validators as protocol rewards. Protocol rewards should be distributed to validators proportionally to the amount of POL they stake. POL emission is described in § 5.2. Protocol rewards provide base incentives for validators and establish a level playing field for the whole validator pool. On top of it, validators can then secure additional incentives by validating individual Polygon chains. Additional validator incentives are described in § 6.3. 4.3 Governance To facilitate efficient, community-run governance of important aspects of the Polygon ecosystem, POL should be technically enabled to hold governance rights, i.e. be utilized in governance frameworks. Describing the Polygon governance framework is out of the scope of this paper. 5 Supply Here we cover the initial supply and the emission policy of POL, and describe the rationale behind both. 5.1 Initial supply The initial supply of POL is 10 billion tokens. The entirety of the initial supply should be dedicated for migration, i.e. token swap from MATIC to POL. This migration would need to take place in order for POL to succeed MATIC as the native token of the Polygon ecosystem, and it is discussed in § 8. The initial supply of POL matches the supply of MATIC, which should make the migration quite straightforward. Once the migration is complete, the distribution of POL would essentially match the current distribution of MATIC. MATIC has already gone through an extensive process of token distribution which has resulted in more than 600,000 holder addresses 2 , and likely even more 2 Source: https://etherscan.io/token/0x7d1afa7b718fb893db30a3abc0cfc608aacfebb0#balances 9 actual holders, given that centralized crypto exchanges’ and DeFi protocols’ addresses represent multiple users. This implies that POL would be widely distributed from day one, which is instrumental for overall decentralization and resilience of the ecosystem. 5.2 Emission POL is emitted at a predefined, deterministic rate for two purposes: 1. Validator rewards. To incentivize validator onboarding and retention, POL should be continuously emitted at a predetermined rate and distributed to validators as the base, protocol reward. We propose a yearly emission rate of 1% of the POL supply for this purpose. The emission rate would not be possible to change for the initial 10 years, and after that period the community can decide to decrease it in an arbitrary way via the governance framework. The emission rate can never be increased beyond 1%. 2. Ecosystem support. To provide ongoing support for further development and growth of the Polygon ecosystem, we propose to introduce the Community Treasury, a community-governed ecosystem fund, described in § 7. We propose a yearly emission rate of 1% of the POL supply for this purpose. Just like the emission for validator rewards, this emission rate can be decreased after 10 years via a governance framework, and it can never be increased beyond 1%. Figure 2. Possible POL emission rate scenarios The rationale for the proposed emission and the emission rates is that the Polygon ecosystem and Web3 in general will need time to mature and reach mainstream adoption. Based on the 10 historical Internet and computing platforms adoption cycles, the maturity phase could be realistically expected to happen in about 10-15 years. During that period, the ecosystem will need economic support. Once the Polygon ecosystem and Web3 reach maturity, transaction fees and other incentives secured by validating Polygon chains (described in § 6.3) should alone generate sufficient returns for Polygon validators. Once that happens, the community can decide to intervene and reduce or completely discontinue the emission for validator rewards, without impacting security and decentralization of the ecosystem. Similarly, the community can then decide to decrease or discontinue the emission for the Community Treasury as well, given that the ecosystem will not need significant economic support anymore. Obviously, the adoption cycle of Web3 might look slightly or completely different. In case it turns out that reaching mainstream adoption takes more time and the ecosystem still needs support after 10 years, the community can choose not to intervene and the emission will continue to happen for as long as required. We consider the proposed emission policy optimal, as it achieves the equilibrium between: ● Sufficient ecosystem support. Sufficient, future-proof support to the Polygon ecosystem is critically important for security and success of Polygon. To validate the hypothesis that the proposed emission rates are indeed sufficient, we developed an economic model, ran simulations and presented results in § 9. ● Security via scarcity. Scarcity of native tokens is instrumentally important for blockchain networks; high token dilution can dramatically affect security. To estimate POL scarcity, we can compare the proposed emission rate to the emission rate of BTC, which is currently at ≈1.8% 3 , and has been significantly higher in the past. Also, although gradually declining, BTC emission is guaranteed to happen for more than another century, whilst POL emission could potentially be reduced or discontinued even after 10 years. Given that (i) Bitcoin is considered a highly scarce asset, and (ii) total POL emission rate is comparable to (and potentially more strict than) BTC, we conclude that POL is sufficiently scarce, i.e. its emission does not introduce protocol security concerns. 3 Source: https://charts.woobull.com/bitcoin-inflation/ 11 Lastly, it is important to note that the emission policy we propose has a high degree of predictability. The predetermined emission schedule makes POL supply predictable in the long term, even if the community decides to intervene. As explained, the community can only decrease the rates, thus effectively complementing the predetermined emission policy and potentially increasing scarcity of POL. Predictability and scarcity attract protoc
프로젝트로 돌아가기