bitpro가 원문에서 글자만 모은 내용이에요. 표·그림·수식은 빠지거나 깨질 수 있어요. 전체 2쪽 중 2쪽
s
knowledge
mining
and
paranet-specific
AI
services.
●
A
supported
blockchain
on
which
the
paranet
is
running
and
assembling
Knowledge
Assets,
The
characteristics
of
a
paranet,
including
its
knowledge
asset
parameters
and
how
services
are
provisioned,
are
all
defined
by
the
paranet
operator,
which
can
be
an
individual,
an
organization,
or
a
Decentralized
Autonomous
Organization
(DAO).
Paranets
together
form
the
DKG,
leveraging
the
common
underlying
network
infrastructure.
Given
the
DKG
is
a
permissionless
system,
anyone
can
initiate
a
paranet.
7
Figure
5:
Paranets
as
a
collection
of
Knowledge
Assets
Paranets
provide
a
powerful
substrate
for
AI
systems,
leveraging
network
effects
of
verifiable
inputs
from
multiple
sources
to
receive
accurate
answers
through
dRAG,
allowing
it
to
gather
information
from
the
(1)
graph
of
public
knowledge
and
(2)
privately
held
knowledge
in
relevant
Knowledge
Assets
that
it
has
access
to.
Paranets
can
form
around
topics
of
different
nature
and
size,
for
example:
●
Industry
4.0
●
Decentralized
Science
●
Sustainability
●
Public
company
reports
●
LLM
training
data
●
Metaverse
●
Video
content
networks
●
Social
media
●
Art
discovery
networks
●
Prediction
markets
●
Sports
and
betting
●
Entertainment
While
some
of
the
examples
are
inspired
by
the
ongoing
adoption
seen
on
the
DKG,
the
list
is
by
no
means
exhaustive
and
serves
as
a
showcase
of
the
variety
and
inclusiveness
of
different
autonomous
paranets
that
DKG
can
support
and
make
available
to
AI
systems.
All
paranets
are
together
part
of
the
DKG
and
can
be
queried
and
accessed
in
combination.
5
Incentivising
Verifiable
Internet
for
AI
on
NeuroWeb
The
dRAG
framework
offers
a
strong
approach
to
addressing
many
of
the
key
challenges
of
AI,
however,
the
value
of
using
dRAG
grows
exponentially
with
the
amount
of
knowledge
AI
tools
can
access
in
the
DKG.
To
bend
the
adoption
curve
steeper,
incentivization
mechanisms
are
a
key
element
.
The
incentivization
of
Verifiable
Internet
for
AI
is
implemented
by
allowing
paranets
operators
to
leverage
NeuroWeb
incentives
to
fuel
the
paranet
8
growth
.
The
size
of
emissions
and
proposed
rules
to
drive
knowledge
mining
on
a
particular
paranet
are
decided
on
with
decentralized
governance.
The
core
activity
of
creating
knowledge
on
paranets
to
earn
incentives
is
Knowledge
Mining.
5.1
Knowledge
Mining
When
launching
an
autonomous
paranet,
the
paranet
operators
define
the
key
characteristics.
One
of
the
most
important
ones
is
the
incentivization
mechanism
for
knowledge
mining
on
their
paranet.
Such
mechanisms
may
include
conditions
like
topic
relevance,
ontology
compliance,
size
limitations,
and
many
others.
In
addition
to
knowledge
miners,
incentivization
mechanisms
may
also
reward
service
providers.
Services
can
range
from
simple
ontology
compliance
checks
to
AI-powered
chat
applications.
A
paranet
can
be
proposed
and
operated
by
anyone
and
they
can
be
in
any
size
that
the
operators
feel
is
relevant
-
they
can
be
functional
both
as
narrow
and
wide.
Paranet
operators
compete
to
obtain
the
rewards
for
their
paranets
with
other
paranets
through
NeuroWeb
governance
voting
.
Each
operator
creates
a
reward
proposal
specifying
the
reward
emissions
they
require,
the
knowledge
mining
mechanism,
incentivized
services,
and
other
key
elements
that
operators
or
the
voting
NeuroWeb
community
may
find
to
be
important.
Figure
6:
Incentives
flow
in
autonomous
paranet
In
this
way,
there
is
an
ongoing
motivation
to
publish
knowledge
on
the
DKG
which
is
tailored
to
the
relevant
domains,
increasing
the
value
of
DKG
for
those
building
dRAG
solutions.
6
AI
-
powered
Autonomous
DKG
The
combination
of
the
DKG,
dRAG,
and
Verifiable
Internet
for
AI
incentives
creates
a
structure
that
supports
the
constant
growth
of
global
knowledge.
Knowledge
miners
will
start
to
mine
knowledge
in
a
particular
paranet
by
gathering
data
from
relevant
sources
using
manual
and
automated
techniques.
However,
once
more
knowledge
becomes
available
in
a
paranet,
the
possibility
of
autonomous
knowledge
mining
is
unlocked.
As
high-quality,
annotated,
ontology-fit
data
is
present
in
a
paranet,
we
can
run
deductive
reasoning
which
is
a
logical
process
where
new
knowledge
is
deterministically
made
from
existing
knowledge
based
on
ontology
rules
and
connections/relationships
between
knowledge.
The
autonomous
knowledge
graph
equally
offers
opportunities
for
inductive
reasoning
where
new
knowledge
can
be
created
in
a
probabilistic
manner,
by
using
AI
to
identify
patterns
and
regularities
in
existing
knowledge
and
create
predictions
on
the
best
new
knowledge.
9
An
important
body
of
work
advancing
this
field
is
being
created
with
foundation
models
for
knowledge
graph
reasoning
[6]
which
merge
the
foundation
models
used
in
AI
systems
onto
a
knowledge
graph
structure.
This
introduces
the
possibility
of
universal
and
transferable
graph
representations
which
would
allow
an
AI
system
[7]
to
infer
and
populate
any
knowledge
graph
using
its
foundation
model
and
vice-versa,
get
fine-tuned
by
consuming
graph
representations
from
existing
knowledge
graphs.
Particularly
powerful
at
such
predictive
tasks
are
the
previously
mentioned
Graph
Neural
Networks
(GNNs),
since
this
is
one
of
their
key
use
cases.
The
autonomous
Decentralized
Knowledge
Graph
will
effectively
use
both
types
of
reasoning
(logical
and
probabilistic)
to
enrich
and
expand
the
DKG,
driving
a
better
understanding
of
relationships
and
entities,
and
making
more
informed
predictions
and
recommendations
to
autonomously
create
new
knowledge.
7
Economics
of
Verifiable
Internet
for
AI
The
Verifiable
Internet
fosters
a
cohesive
approach
towards
the
vision
of
more
inclusive
and
democratic
AI
with
two
basic
concepts
driving
its
unit
economics:
1.
AI-ready
Knowledge
Assets
2.
Knowledge
paranets
Each
of
these
units
is
supported
with
a
tokenomics
design
ensuring
the
OriginTrail
DKG
network
is
enhanced
in
security,
resilience,
and
usability.
The
incentive
structure
enacted
on
the
NeuroWeb
blockchain
ensures
that
activities
contributing
to
the
DKG
network
growth
receive
attractive
rewards
and
create
further
opportunities
for
building
knowledge
as
a
foundation
for
Verifiable
Internet
for
AI.
7.1.
TRAC
utility
token
driving
Verifiable
Internet
for
AI
infrastructure
Knowledge
Assets
are
the
most
basic
unit
economics
concept
discussed
as
part
of
the
Verifiable
Internet
for
AI.
Each
Knowledge
Asset
generated
consumes
a
certain
unit
of
service
within
the
OriginTrail
DKG
which
is
provisioned
in
a
permissionless
way
by
node
runners
and
delegated
stakers.
Every
time
knowledge
publishers
add
a
new
Knowledge
Asset
to
the
DKG,
they
use
TRAC
to
compensate
for
the
use
of
the
DKG
network
services
and
use
a
gas
token
for
transactions.
The
gas
token
depends
on
the
blockchain
the
DKG
is
being
used
for
publishing
(e.g.
NEURO
on
NeuroWeb,
DAI
on
Gnosis,
ETH
on
Ethereum,
etc).
The
nodes
in
the
DKG
network
compete
to
collect
publishing
fees
provided
by
knowledge
publishers.
They
compete
on
three
core
elements
of
(1)
providing
adequate
service
(storage
and
availability
of
published
knowledge)
for
paranets,
(2)
the
amount
of
TRAC
stake
on
their
node,
and
(3)
node
paranet
address
required
for
efficient
distribution
of
knowledge
and
rewards
across
the
network.
The
nodes
with
the
highest
scores
according
to
the
criteria
are
eligible
to
collect
their
portion
of
rewards
throughout
the
duration
of
the
period
a
Knowledge
Asset
has
been
published
for.
Since
TRAC
staked
is
a
critical
component
to
the
node’s
success,
node
operators
can
also
allow
other
TRAC
holders
to
delegate
their
TRAC
to
their
node
stake.
In
exchange
for
their
delegated
stake,
node
operators
share
a
portion
of
the
node
rewards
with
delegators,
according
to
the
relative
size
of
their
delegations.
TRAC
stake
also
has
a
vital
security
role
as
it
ensures
that
the
DKG
nodes
are
performing
their
services
adequately.
If
they
act
maliciously,
their
stake
can
get
slashed.
7.2.
NEURO
native
token
of
NeuroWeb
-
incentivizing
Verifiable
Internet
for
AI
Knowledge
paranets
,
as
explained
in
previous
chapters,
are
a
collection
of
Knowledge
Assets
on
a
particular
topic
and
associated
services.
Paranets
are
proposed
by
paranet
operators
,
an
entity
that
also
defines
the
core
rules
of
the
paranet.
In
addition
to
the
technical
rules
(e.g.
ontologies,
data
processing
rules,
service
requirements,
etc),
paranet
operators
may
also
define
the
paranet
incentive
system.
The
operators
may
choose
to
incentivize
knowledge
mining
(publishing
of
new
Knowledge
Assets
to
their
paranet),
knowledge
validation
services
(ensuring
a
required
level
of
data
quality),
knowledge
access
services
(e.g.
running
an
AI
discoverability
service,
public
interfaces,
or
AI
agent
service)
or
other
paranet
specific
services.
10
Once
defined,
the
paranet
proposal
for
incentives
can
be
submitted
to
a
governance
vote
towards
the
DKG
incentives
pool
on
the
NeuroWeb
blockchain
.
The
NEURO
token
community
then
acts
as
a
(de)central(ized)
bank
and
decides
which
areas
of
the
knowledge
economy
will
create
the
most
positive
effects
for
the
ecosystem
and
vote
on
them
receiving
the
proposed
amount
of
NEURO
emission
for
running
their
incentive
structure.
Important
to
highlight
is
that
NEURO
incentives
can
also
be
issued
for
paranets
running
on
other
blockchains
by
providing
verifiable
proof
of
activity.
The
NEURO
rewards,
however,
have
to
always
be
collected
on
NeuroWeb
as
that
is
where
they
are
issued.
In
addition
to
being
used
for
voting
on
paranet
incentives,
NEURO
has
utility
as
the
native
asset
of
the
NeuroWeb
blockchain
on
Polkadot
.
By
being
a
native
asset,
NEURO
is
used
as
gas
for
transactions,
for
running
and
staking
on
parachain
collators,
and
for
governance
voting
on
NeuroWeb.
7.3
Token
economics
overview
Growing
and
using
the
Verifiable
Internet
for
AI
via
the
OriginTrail
DKG
means
always
interacting
with
at
least
two
decentralized
networks,
the
DKG,
and
a
corresponding
blockchain.
For
this
reason,
using
the
infrastructure
always
requires
at
least
one
more
utility
token
besides
TRAC.
Below
is
an
overview
of
key
actions
you
can
perform
on
the
two
layers
and
the
corresponding
asset
you
would
have
to
use
to
execute
them.
Table
1:
Overview
of
key
actions
and
corresponding
assets
for
two
layers
TRAC
NEURO
Other
assets
Knowledge
Assets
Publishing
Knowledge
Assets
Compensating
for
use
of
DKG.
Gas
token
for
txs
if
using
NeuroWeb.
Gas
tokens
for
txs
(e.g.
DAI,
ETH)
if
using
other
chains
Running
the
DKG
infrastructure
(Delegated)
staking
on
DKG
nodes.
Gas
token
for
txs
if
using
NeuroWeb.
Gas
tokens
for
txs
(e.g.
DAI,
ETH)
if
using
other
chains
Knowledge
Paranets
Incentivizing
Knowledge
mining
Used
when
publishing
Knowledge
Assets
Providing
incentives
for
publishers.
Not
applicable
Incentivizing
Knowledge
services
(e.g.
knowledge
validation,
discoverability...)
Not
applicable
Providing
incentives
for
service
providers.
Not
applicable
NeuroWebAI
Blockchain
use
Not
applicable
Gas
token
for
txs
on
NeuroWeb.
Not
applicable
Collators
system
Not
applicable
Running
and
staking
on
collators.
Not
applicable
Governance
Not
applicable
Voting
on
updates
and
treasury
and
paranets
growth
incentives
for
knowledge
mining.
Not
applicable
11
8
Conclusion
The
exploration
of
the
Verifiable
Internet
for
Artificial
Intelligence
requires
us
to
look
into
the
details
of
three
converging
technologies
of
AI,
Internet,
and
blockchain.
The
fusion
of
these
cutting-edge
domains
promises
to
reshape
our
digital
landscape,
creating
unprecedented
opportunities
while
addressing
critical
challenges.
This
paper
introduces
an
AI
ecosystem
that
is
not
only
powerful
and
dynamic
but
also
trustworthy
and
transparent.
The
OriginTrail
Decentralized
Knowledge
Graph
(DKG),
with
Knowledge
Assets
as
its
primary
resource,
is
a
pivotal
innovation
in
this
context,
offering
a
robust
framework
for
ensuring
the
ownership,
discoverability,
and
verifiability
of
information
utilized
by
AI
systems
through
the
dRAG
framework.
Autonomous
paranets,
characterized
by
their
self-operating
and
community-owned
nature,
offer
a
modular
and
scalable
approach
to
organizing
Knowledge
Assets
and
growing
the
DKG.
The
incentives
for
continued
growth
of
Verifiable
Internet
for
AI
span
across
multiple
networks.
Different
assets
are
used
according
to
their
respective
designs
-
TRAC
for
operating,
securing,
and
using
the
DKG
infrastructure
and
NEURO
for
incentivizing
growth
in
addition
to
the
utility
as
the
native
NeuroWeb
blockchain
token.
The
convergence
of
AI,
the
Internet,
and
crypto
as
embodied
in
the
Verifiable
Internet
for
AI
represents
a
transformative
step
towards
a
more
transparent,
equitable,
and
intelligent
digital
world.
9
References
[1]
Chui
M,
Roberts
R,
Yee
L.,
Hazan
Z.,
Singla
A.,
Smaje
K.,
Sukharevsky
A,
Zemmel
R,
(2023)
The
economic
potential
of
generative
AI:
The
next
productivity
frontier.
URL:
https://www.mckinsey.com/capabilities/mckinsey-digital/our-insights/the-economic-potential-of-generative-AI-the-n
ext-productivity-frontier
[2]
Shumailov,
I.,
Shumaylov,
Z.,
Zhao,
Y.,
Gal,
Y.,
Papernot,
N.,
Anderson,
R.
(2023)
The
curse
of
Recursion:
Training
on
generated
data
makes
models
forget.
New
York,
May
31.,
URL:
https://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17493
[3]
Lewis,
P.,
Perez,
E.,
Piktus,
A.,
Petroni,
F.,
Karpukhin,
V.,
Goyal,
N.,
Küttler,
H.,
Lewis,
M.,
Yih,
W.,
Rocktäschel,
T.,
Riedel,
S.
and
Kiela,
D.
(2021)
Retrieval-Augmented
Generation
for
Knowledge-Intensive
NLP
Tasks.
New
York,
April
12.,
URL:
https://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17493v2
[4]
Pan,
S.,
Luo,
L.,
Wang,
Y.,
Chen,
C.,
Wang,
J.,
Wu,
X.,
Fellow.
(2024)
Unifying
Large
Language
Models
and
Knowledge
Graphs:
A
Roadmap.
Jan
25.,
URL:
https://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.08302.pdf
[5]
Sporny
M.,
Longley
D.,
Chadwick
D.,
Steele
O.,
Verifiable
Credentials
Data
Model
v2.0
URL:
https://www.w3.org/TR/vc-data-model-2.0/
[6]
Galkin
M.,
Yuan
X.,
Mostsafa
H.,
Tang
J.,
Zhu
Z.,
(2023)
Towards
Foundation
Models
for
Knowledge
Graph
Reasoning.,
URL:
https://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.04562.pdf
[7]
LeCun,
Y.
(2022)
A
Path
Towards
Autonomous
Machine
Intelligence.
New
York,
June
27.,
URL:
https://openreview.net/pdf?id=BZ5a1r-kVsf
12프로젝트로 돌아가기