MetaDAO 백서

MetaDAO

원문

bitpro가 원문에서 글자만 모은 내용이에요. 표·그림·수식은 빠지거나 깨질 수 있어요. 전체 6쪽 중 1쪽

# For Entrepreneurs Source: https://docs.metadao.fi/benefits/founders Why should you launch your project on MetaDAO? A note from the founders ## Introduction One way to frame MetaDAO is “a place for crypto-native enterprises to raise money that doesn’t suck.” That is, if you need capital to build or grow your business, you have a few options available to you today: 1. Follow the standard path, selling token warrants to VCs and launching a token in 2-3 years 2. Raise venture capital and never launch a token 3. Collect creator fees from Pump / Believe / Heaven or a similar platform 4. ICO on Metaplex or a similar platform 5. Launch on MetaDAO Of these five options, only the fifth is purpose-built for building a long-term crypto-native business. ### The standard path is bricked and will continue to get worse The standard way of launching tokens (hyped TGE, paid CEX listings, 10% airdrop, Labs / Foundation / DAO, linear vesting, etc.) is not optimized for building a long-term business - it’s a playbook for extracting money from retail investors while evading securities laws. If you try to use it to build a long-term business, you're going to have a bad time: <iframe title="YouTube video player" /> Some may believe that doing a venture round doesn’t lock you into this path. But we find that once teams raise money, they feel pretty locked into it. ### Never launching a token is reasonable, even if it’s not maximally crypto-native Some teams don’t plan to do tokens, instead accruing value to their equity as a normal start-up would. We think this approach is reasonable. If you can raise money from investors who don’t expect a token, you should seriously consider it. ### Launching on a bonding curve is terrible Recently, a few projects have launched on or considered launching on a platform like Pump, Believe, or Heaven. The main problems with these are as follows: * You don’t raise much money - the median token only makes \$10k - \$100k in creator fees. * These tokens don’t have any intrinsic value, and the market will recognize them as such. You may have lots of traders, but you will have few long-term holders * Snipers will scoop up large percentage of your supply and sell onto your believers. * “Hey, would you like to come work for our start-up for a below-market salary and 1% of the supply? Yes, someone was able to purchase 1% of the supply for \$150, but what does that matter?” ### Normal ICOs can work if you have enough trust, do the legal work, and avoid the pitfalls of the standard path Another option is to launch at a place like Metaplex. Essentially, a 2018-style ICO where you’re given discretion over the money. The problem you’ll encounter is that historically many, if not most, of these ICOs rugged. This has led to wariness among serious investors. So you may be able to get short-term token flippers, but it’ll be harder for you to attract long-term holders. But if you have sufficient trust, and are willing to put in the legal work to align the token and the business and also to avoid following the “low float / high FDV” playbook, then this can be reasonable. ### MetaDAO is *the* place if you want to align a community the right way But if you want to align a community by launching a token and you don’t want to do a bunch of legal, smart contract, and marketing work, MetaDAO is today the place to go. On MetaDAO you get: * A valuable token, which leads to longer-term and higher-quality holders * Provable transparency - noone will wonder whether you've "OTCed" * To enter the arena early * A mintable token - you won't need to worry about running out of supply * A potential community of early believers It's not a free launch - there are plenty of trade-offs, including the psychological effects of having a liquid token that can go down. But if we were launching a new crypto project today, MetaDAO is the place we’d want to be. -Proph3t and Kollan House # For Investors Source: https://docs.metadao.fi/benefits/investors For token investors, the pitch is simple - reduce the risk that you get rugged ## Overview MetaDAO helps token investors in two ways: * Mechanistic protection against treasury rugs * Legal protection against revenue rugs ## Mechanistic protection against treasury rugs On Solana in 2021 there were four big ICOs: * **Parrot:** raised \$85M, [the team walked away with \$72M of it](https://www.coindesk.com/markets/2023/07/21/defi-project-parrot-puts-fate-of-over-70m-treasury-prt-token-to-vote) * **UXD:** raised \$57M, [insiders walked away with \$46M of it](https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1VYv7qHD9kpfFeY_nBjT6jkqbA0HHf4w5gBVFRuN5OPU/edit?gid=1572994615#gid=1572994615) * **Mango:** raised \$70M, [the founders are suing each other for stealing from the project](https://x.com/dj_d_sol/status/1843666330429600216) * **Aurory:** raised \$108M, [the token is down 99.5% and it's unclear where the money has gone](https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/aurory/) On MetaDAO, all of the funds go to a market-governed treasury. If someone tries to rug, anyone can raise a proposal to return capital to tokenholders. ## Legal protection against revenue rugs Famously, the [\$30m](https://dune.com/Marcov/uniswap-revenue) Uniswap has made from its frontend is retained solely by Uniswap Labs and will likely never end up in the hands of tokenholders. Less famously, the Unibot team built Trojan, which made [\$206M in fees](https://defillama.com/protocol/fees/trojan), and decided to keep the revenue for themselves rather than integrating the \$UNIBOT token. Because of the legal entity created at launch, tokenholders could sue teams that misappropriate the project’s revenues or compel service providers (domain name registrars, social media companies, etc.) to transfer control of IP to a new team. # Ownership Coins Source: https://docs.metadao.fi/benefits/ownership-coins ### **Overview** Most tokens don't give you real ownership. The team controls the treasury, the IP, and a huge chunk of the supply. Token holders have no power. Founders can do whatever they want, including shutting it down and walking away with the money. Ownership coins work differently. The valuable parts of the organization—intellectual property, treasury, mint authority—are controlled by decision markets.\[1] Legal documents and smart contracts enforce that this is the case. Teams must work to create tokenholder value or risk getting ousted by the markets. There's no legal document saying that tokenholders own anything. But decision markets protect you from poor or biased decisions that would tank your tokens. What's good for the token is good for the token holder. ## **What makes a token an Ownership Coin?** Two things: * **Treasury governed by decision markets**: money sits in a treasury with market oversight so that the team can’t easily rug it. * **Key IP governed by decision markets:** the key IP, which includes social media accounts, domain names, created software, and the like is assigned to an entity with decision market oversight. The team can’t build a product with tokenholder money and then rug them once the product is successful. ## **How "ownership" works under decision markets** | Normal ownership | Decision markets | | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------ | | Shareholders have a say and can vote | Market price *is* the decision | | Shareholders have a contractual claim on residual equity value in the event of a liquidation or sale | Market price *is* the decision | | Operators have a fiduciary duty to shareholders (or lienholders, in the case of insolvency) and can be sued for breach of that duty | Market price *is* the decision | Even if teams maintain day-to-day control of decisions, they are ultimately responsible to a market that has a good deal of control over the organization. Funds can be withdrawn, operators can be replaced, key assets can be divested all by the market and without the approval of an executive team or board of directors. \[1]: MetaDAO is currently in beta and the MetaDAO team currently has the ability to override decision markets in extreme scenarios, similar to Polymarket’s backdoor into the oracle. We have yet to use this power and expect it to disappear as the system matures. # Trading Proposals Source: https://docs.metadao.fi/governance/markets How conditional markets work and how you can trade them ## Overview Once a proposal has accumulated enough stake, the project takes half of its liquidity from the spot (e.g. META/USDC) market and moves it into a proposal's conditional markets. Traders can then make *conditional trades* over 3 days. **Conditional trades are like normal trades, except they revert if the condition isn't met.** ## Example: Participating in the ORE Market If you thought that ORE would have been worth more than \$19 if they reduced their emissions by 40%, you could have participated in [this market](https://v1.metadao.fi/ore/trade-v4/3PCPkFQQo7sU2DxpqnQNEttiyx1t5kByY2WPjCo1qLEZ): <img alt="" /> If you believed that ORE would go to \$30 if they adopted this change, you could have bought ORE in the pass market. For example, you could have placed a trade of \$1000 for 50 ORE (\$20 per ORE). Then, if the proposal passes, you would have bought ORE at \$20. But if it fails, you wouldn't have bought any ORE. ## How you can preserve & grow your portfolio by trading decision markets ### Case #1 - Bad Proposal Suppose there's a project, EXMPL, that has \$1M in its treasury and a \$1.2M market cap. You own \$10,000 worth of the token. The founder just raised a proposal to send all of the project's money to himself so that he can go on a nice vacation. The market immediately reacts to this information and the token shoots down to a \$900k market cap. But so far, no one has traded the decision markets, so it's trading \$900k in both the pass and fail markets - what should you do? One reasonable course of action would be to sell pass and buy fail. Pass is overvalued at \$900k if you think the token will go to 0 if the founder walks away with all of the money. And fail is undervalued at \$900k if you think that the immediate next proposal will be to liquidate, netting you a nice 11% profit. You're prepared for either scenario. ### Case #2 - Good Proposal Now suppose there's another project called XYZ with \$10M in revenues and a \$100M market cap. So it's trading at a price-to-sales multiple of 10. The founder just created a proposal to add a new business line. You think that this business line will add \$5M of revenue to the project, translating to \$50M in market cap. Here, your course of action should totally depend on the prices of the decision markets. If the pass market is already pricing the token at \$150M, you shouldn't take any trades. But if it's trading at \$110M in the pass market, you probably want to buy. If it's trading at \$200M, you probably want to sell. And if you think that \$100M is the fair value for the project if the proposal fails, you would probably want to buy the fail market at below \$100M and sell it above \$100M. # Introduction to Decision Markets Source: https://docs.metadao.fi/governance/overview So, what is "market-driven governance"? ## First, some background MetaDAO originally started as a governance project - since November 2023 we've run 96 proposals for 14 organizations. Decisions made on MetaDAO include: * [Jito's fee switch decision](https://v1.metadao.fi/jito-dao/trade/CJW4iZPT14sVNzoc4Yibx1LbnY12sA75gZCP9HZk11UA) * [Flash's decision to start passing revenue back to stakers](https://v1.metadao.fi/flash-trade/trade-v4/3kfEHobCtMn4rDCXmo2H735xX6oEacVN1DBuL41wj7az) * [All of Sanctum's governance decisions](https://v1.metadao.fi/sanctum) The difference between governance on MetaDAO and elsewhere is that there isn't any voting, only trading. This system of governance is called decision markets. ## How does it work? TL;DR: * People trade in markets that correspond to "what would be the value of this token if this proposal passed?" and "what would be the value of this token if this proposal failed?" * Organizations accept a proposal when traders think it will make the token's value increase and reject them when traders think it will make the token's value decrease Here's its inventor Robin Hanson to explain the concept: <iframe title="YouTube video player" /> ## Why is it better? Markets have a long track record of predicting the future better than alternatives. For example: * [Prediction markets have historically beaten pollsters at predicting election results.](https://www.biz.uiowa.edu/faculty/trietz/papers/long%20run%20accuracy.pdf) * [Orange juice futures markets have historically predicted the weather better than government forecasts.](https://www.asecib.ase.ro/mps/TheWisdomOfCrowds-JamesSurowiecki.pdf) * [In 1986 when the Challenger Space Shuttle exploded over Cape Canaveral, it took the government 4 months to identify Morton-Thiakol's O-Rings as the root cause. The market had figured it out within 16 minutes.](https://maloney.people.clemson.edu/challenger.pdf) <img alt="" /> ## Why does it matter? We don't know if decision markets are quite at that level of intelligence yet, but they appear to already be better than token-voting at preventing capture. Concretely, this means it is harder to rug ICOs when the funds are stored in a treasury with decision market oversight. Or, in the words of [Kevin Heavey](https://www.umbraresearch.xyz/writings/futarchy), > Decision markets are such a radical improvement over majoritarian DAOs that even in its infancy it should already be ordained as the default governance mechanism, perhaps with training wheels like a security council to veto exploits.<br /><br /> > All DAOs that persist with token voting over decision markets should begin to feel increasingly uncomfortable, because in time it will be assumed that any DAO still carrying on this way is malicious or incompetent... If you want people to share ownership of your business, you either become a normal company with no governance token, or you bind your fate to decision markets and let the market decide.<br /><br /> > *Futarchy as Trustless Joint Ownership*, Umbra Research # Creating Proposals Source: https://docs.metadao.fi/governance/proposals What proposals can do and how they go live Anyone can create a proposal to a project. Proposals can: * Spend USDC from the treasury * Issue new tokens * Update token metadata * Increase or decrease the liquidity provided by the project's treasury Once a proposal is created, holders must stake tokens on it for it to go live. By default, a proposal requires between 200,000 to 1,500,000 tokens (1-15% of the ICOs 10M tokens) staked on it for it to go live. This depends on the version of the DAO and the DAO parameters which can be updated from time to time. Staking is purely to prevent spam and doesn't have lockups or risk of slashing. There can only be one proposal live at once. # Finalizing Proposals Source: https://docs.metadao.fi/governance/twaps How projects decide whether a proposal passes or fails ## TWAPs decide whether proposals pass or fail The goal of futarchy is to accept proposals that increase the value of the project. Unfortunately, you can't just take prices at the end of the proposal because those could be easily manipulated. So instead, we use time-weighted average prices (TWAPs). ## TWAPs are lagged to mitigate the effects of manipulation Normal TWAPs also have their flaws. For example, a Solana validator could manipulate a TWAP by setting the price extremely high for a few slots. If said validator controlled 1% of slots, they could force a proposal through by 100xing the pass price during their slots. We deal with this by using a special form of TWAP we call a lagging price TWAP. In a lagging price TWAP, the number that gets fed into the TWAP isn't the raw price - it's a number that tries to approximate the price but which can only move a certain amount per update. We call the number that gets fed into the TWAP an *observation*. <img alt="" /> To take an example, imagine that a market's initial observation is \$500 and it can change at most \$5 per minute. If market is currently trading at \$550, it will take 10 minutes before the last observation reflects the price. ## 24-Hour Delay Before TWAP Recording Before TWAP recording begins, there is a **24-hour delay period**. This gives traders time to properly price the market and evaluate the proposal before recordings start. This delay is important in a permissionless system—it ensures that participants have adequate time to analyze and react to new proposals rather than being caught off-guard by immediate TWAP calculations. ## Pass Thresholds MetaDAO uses different pass thresholds depending on the proposal type: | Proposal Type | Pass Threshold | | ------------------ | -------------- | | Team Sponsored | -3% | | Non-Team Sponsored | 3% | **Team sponsored proposals** have a negative threshold (-3%), meaning they require slightly less market confidence to pass. The rationale is that teams generally have better context on what's good for their project. **Non-team sponsored proposals** have a positive threshold (3%), making it slightly harder for external proposals to pass than to fail. This provides a conservative default for permissionless governance. <Note> We're actively tuning these parameters. Check the DAO structure onchain to understand exactly what thresholds have been configured for any specific organization. </Note> For more context on the reasoning behind these threshold choices, see [this discussion](https://x.com/metaproph3t/status/1979243370452258837). # Are You Ready? Source: https://docs.metadao.fi/how-launches-work/are-you-ready Determining whether you're prepared and/or a fit for MetaDAO ## MetaDAO is built for early-stage, crypto projects Eventually we'd like to support all kinds of businesses. But today we focus on crypto-native ones because they are most likely to benefit from [community ownership effects](https://docs.metadao.fi). The ideal stage is when you have a working product / users but haven't raised significant capital yet. <img alt="" /> It doesn't need to be pretty - this was an early version of MetaDAO! ## You need to be prepared to build in public and sell your vision If you don't have a large community yet, that's okay! Tokens are one of the most effective community bootstrapping tools. But you do need to be able to **effectively communicate what you're doing and why people should be bullish on you**. Your tokenholders will be globally distributed, which makes online communication - such as X articles and videos - key. We recommend the following: * At least 1 week of public lead up heading into the launch, with well-written articles and graphic tweets explaining what you're doing and why people should be bullish on you. * Monthly updates that cover the state of the business (including your KPIs) and what you're focus will be. * A Telegram group where you're responsive to people that have questions for you. Because your treasury will have market oversight, this communication is not a nice-to-have, it is 100% critical. **Failure to communicate your vision effectively may lead to capital being returned to tokenholders from your treasury.** # Bid Wall Source: https://docs.metadao.fi/how-launches-work/bid-wall How the bid wall supports token price and reduces supply ## Overview **NOTE: The Bid Wall is deprecated.** It was used in one raise and has not been used since. Unless a launch specifically mentions the Bid Wall, assume it will not be used. The **Bid Wall** lets token holders sell tokens back at the project's Net Asset Value (NAV) per token. Tokens sold into it are perma
프로젝트로 돌아가기