bitpro가 원문에서 글자만 모은 내용이에요. 표·그림·수식은 빠지거나 깨질 수 있어요. 전체 3쪽 중 2쪽
have
low
value
to
a
distributed
system
in
isolation,
but
is
highly
valuable
when
operating
alongside
links
from
others.
Indeed,
the
federated
nature
of
the
DoubleZero
project
is
its
core
strength.
Smart
Contract-Defined
Network
The
DoubleZero
protocol
organizes
itself
with
verified
data
stored
in
onchain
smart
contracts.
The
distributed
control
plane
uses
this
information
to
reach
consensus
on
routing
and
prioritization
decisions
for
the
network.
This
provides
a
transparent
and
permissionless
experience
for
both
contributors
and
users.
Contributors
connect
to
the
network
and
set
a
service
level
agreement
enshrined
in
a
smart
contract,
which
includes
endpoint
locations,
bandwidth,
latency,
and
compliant
MTU
size.
They
send
those
details,
along
with
the
initial
duration
of
the
contribution,
to
the
smart
contract.
Validators
and
other
users
can
opt-in
to
predetermined
services
and
routes,
such
as
a
specific
L1’s
traffic,
state
propagation,
and
validator
set,
or
they
can
author
their
own
contract
to
define
a
routing
request.
As
inputs
come
in,
the
distributed
controller
uses
smart
contract
data
to
identify
the
optimal
configuration
for
the
network.
One
key
component
of
this
configuration
is
the
correct
price,
so
that
users
pay
for
the
cost
of
using
the
network
in
proportion
to
the
request
they
impose
on
the
system
and
providers
earn
incentives
for
contributing
to
the
network
in
proportion
to
the
value
they
generate
in
providing
links.
Ultimately,
the
project
aspires
to
offer
tiered
pricing,
where
users
can
pay
for
priority
access
or
base
access
to
a
given
route
to
maximize
network
efficiency.
The
10
DoubleZero
network
aims
to
offer
a
high
degree
of
customization
and
control
to
its
services
and
pass
the
surplus
back
to
providers
–
a
major
advantage
over
the
public
internet,
where
traffic
gets
commingled
regardless
of
priority
Incentives
and
Alignment
The
open
ethos
of
the
DoubleZero
project
hinges
on
internal
alignment
and
reciprocity
by
its
network
contributors.
For
the
network
to
work,
they
must
meet
their
service
level
agreements
and
have
incentives
to
catch
defection
on
the
part
of
others.
A
system
of
checks
and
balances,
based
on
the
same
cryptoeconomic
values
that
secure
proof-of-stake
networks
today,
will
underpin
the
DoubleZero
system
and
ensure
incentives
are
aligned
for
cooperation
rather
than
defection.
For
instance,
links
that
perform
below
their
stated
service
level
agreements
will
be
penalized
and
ineligible
for
rewards
(and
eventually
may
be
excluded
altogether),
while
links
that
meet
those
obligations
will
be
eligible
for
rewards.
Unlike
blockchain
systems,
physical
networks
lack
the
abstract
verifiability
of
a
block
–
where
any
node
anywhere
in
the
world
can
validate
its
correctness.
Physical
networks
need
physical
connections
(peers)
to
verify
integrity,
which
today
is
only
possible
with
redundant
physical
connections.
DoubleZero
will
require
new
innovation
for
single
point
verification.
Network
Effects
The
DoubleZero
project
goes
beyond
a
standard
marketplace,
where
providers
and
users
meet
and
negotiate
bilaterally.
It
is
a
true
network
–
each
link
is
more
valuable
as
part
of
the
whole
than
it
would
be
in
isolation.
Consider
a
link
provider
that
has
a
few
disconnected
links,
which
represent
underutilized
capacity
on
their
internal
networks.
While
the
entity
could
sell
services
over
those
routes
piecemeal,
each
route
would
require
substantial
overhead
in
finding
buyers
and
negotiating
contracts.
More
importantly,
each
link
has
limited
value,
as
it
serves
only
one
particular
route.
But
the
provider
who
offers
those
links
to
DoubleZero
benefits
in
two
ways.
First,
the
process
of
adding
contributions
to
the
platform
is
easy
and
standardized
(all
one
needs
to
do
is
install
and
configure
a
few
switches),
requiring
little
overhead.
Second
and
more
critically,
the
link
grows
in
value
by
its
association
with
neighboring
links.
A
disconnected
link
can
potentially
become
a
highly
connected
link
on
the
DoubleZero
network,
making
it
substantially
more
valuable
than
it
would
be
on
its
own.
Network
effects
are
present
in
many
other
markets.
One
example:
airlines.
A
single
airline
route
between
two
cities
is
rarely
offered
in
isolation,
as
there
is
not
likely
much
customer
demand.
Instead,
they
are
bundled
into
a
carrier’s
larger
network
and
interact
with
other
routes
through
hubs.
These
bundles
are
substantially
more
valuable;
they
become
even
more
valuable
when
the
carrier
joins
an
airline
alliance
and
implicitly
ties
their
routes
with
routes
in
other
parts
of
the
world.
DoubleZero
is
the
platform
that
takes
individual
routes
and
turns
them
into
a
thriving
cross-connected
network.
11
The
DoubleZero
network
can
even
benefit
from
redundant
links,
short
links,
or
low-performance
links.
While
the
network
is
high-performance
and
expansive
holistically,
these
types
of
contributions
add
redundancy,
capacity,
and
interconnectedness.
Thus,
the
DoubleZero
project
can
allow
providers
to
monetize
capacity
that
otherwise
would
have
almost
no
value
in
isolation.
Taken
together,
providers
who
make
unused
capacity
on
their
network
available
to
DoubleZero
face
lower
transaction
frictions
and
generate
more
user
surplus
from
the
network
economics,
especially
when
compared
to
selling
that
capacity
in
isolation.
In
turn,
the
DoubleZero
network
passes
that
surplus
onto
the
providers.
Blockchain
Use
Cases
Blockchains,
as
the
highest-profile
distributed
system
archetype,
holistically
represent
the
strongest
use
case
for
the
DoubleZero
network.
A
blockchain's
dual
objectives
of
being
public
and
performant
often
work
against
one
another
in
the
status
quo.
Across
contexts
as
diverse
as
Layer
1
blockchains,
RPC
nodes,
MEV
systems,
and
Layer
2
chains,
the
DoubleZero
network
can
push
towards
attaining
both.
Figure
6.
A
conceptual
map
of
the
DoubleZero
Network
12
Layer
1
Blockchains
A
Layer
1
blockchain
is
the
distributed
system
that
stands
to
gain
the
most
from
the
DoubleZero
network.
In
the
status
quo,
each
validator
faces
a
firehose
of
inbound
transactions
(including
spam
and
duplicates).
Consensus
is
reached
slowly
as
validators
propose
blocks
and
vote
over
public
internet
paths
prone
to
high
jitter
and
inconsistent
routing.
In
tandem,
users
suffer
from
poor
experiences,
whether
it
be
competing
with
a
flood
of
spam
or
waiting
for
delayed
finality.
Even
today’s
most
performant
blockchains
fall
short
of
providing
both
the
web2-style
experiences
users
expect
and
the
professional
central
venue
trader
experience.
The
industry
has
developed
some
solutions,
but
each
comes
with
disadvantages.
Mempools
serve
as
a
central
holding
pen
for
transactions
(to
lower
the
ingestion
burden
on
individual
validators),
but
this
adds
latency
to
the
system
and
broadcasts
transaction
intentions
well
before
their
inclusions.
Quality-of-service
solutions
have
been
tested
on
blockchains
like
Solana
wherein
validators
accept
transactions
predominantly
from
those
who
have
staked
capital,
but
this
excludes
entities
who
do
not
have
sufficient
stake
from
full
participation,
does
not
guarantee
economic
efficiency,
and
adds
additional
latency
from
the
proxy
step.
Validators
can
invest
more
in
hardware
to
keep
pace,
but
this
of
course
inhibits
the
development
of
a
diverse
and
decentralized
validator
set
and
does
not
address
aggregate
network
performance.
The
DoubleZero
network
offers
a
more
robust
solution
in
two
ways.
First,
it
provides
the
filtering
technology
to
filter
inbound
traffic
that
comes
over
the
public
internet.
This
step
utilizes
scalable
hardware
running
open-source
code,
mitigates
distributed
denial-of-service
attacks,
verifies
signatures,
and
removes
duplicate
transactions.
This
separation
of
filtration,
deduplication,
and
signature
verification
from
block
production,
execution,
and
consensus
frees
up
substantial
resources
to
focus
on
block
production.
This
is
cooperative
infrastructure
sharing,
where
the
system
in
the
aggregate
can
share
resources
rather
than
every
validator
individually
needing
them.
5
Second,
it
routes
the
filtered
traffic
–
whether
user
transactions,
blocks,
or
consensus
votes
–
to
the
validator
set
over
its
dedicated
bandwidth
links
with
minimal
latency
and
jitter.
This
ensures
that
blocks
are
built,
shared,
and
ratified
quickly.
Under
this
networking
paradigm,
high-performance
validator
clients
or
consensus
algorithms
can
come
much
closer
to
their
theoretical
maximums.
Indeed,
this
can
be
optimized
further
as
the
DoubleZero
network
is
expected
to
support
multicast
functionality,
which
allows
for
better
propagation
of
state
transitions,
blocks,
and
shreds.
There
is
one
final
advantage
of
using
the
DoubleZero
network
for
Layer
1
blockchain
communication.
Packets
traversing
over
the
network
are
expected
to
be
traceable
so
that
users
can
verify
their
inclusion
or
exclusion
from
intra-validator
communication.
For
systems
that
are
sensitive
to
concerns
of
censorship,
this
is
a
beneficial
by-product
of
transparency
in
traffic
routing.
5
There
are
many
other
successful
examples
of
cooperative
infrastructure
sharing,
including
mobile
networking,
TowerCos,
or
subsea
fiber
optic
cable
system
consortia.
13
RPC
Nodes
Remote
Procedure
Call
(RPC)
nodes
can
similarly
benefit
from
the
DoubleZero
protocol.
As
the
primary
interface
between
users
and
the
chain,
they
face
especially
severe
filtration
and
communication
challenges.
RPC
nodes
comprise
the
infrastructure
that
mediate
user
interactions
on
a
blockchain.
The
primary
role
of
an
RPC
node
is
to
receive
inbound
transactions
from
users
and
to
forward
those
transactions
to
either
the
leader
or
the
chain's
mempool.
The
secondary
role
is
to
provide
an
updated
view
of
the
chain
to
downstream
applications,
such
as
DeFi
applications,
block
explorers,
or
gas
estimators
that
help
users
form
efficient
transactions.
RPC
nodes
are
effectively
non-voting
validators
–
they
track
state
transitions
on
a
blockchain,
but
do
not
participate
in
consensus.
There
are
three
challenges
that
RPC
nodes
face
that
could
be
mitigated
by
the
DoubleZero
protocol.
First,
RPC
nodes
are
directly
exposed
to
traffic
surges
from
users,
particularly
around
broad
community
events
like
airdrops
or
NFT
mints.
Because
they
specifically
receive
the
transaction
flow
via
the
public
internet,
they
are
especially
vulnerable
to
distributed
denial-of-service
attacks.
Second,
the
role
of
the
RPC
node
is
to
forward
user
transactions
to
the
block
leader
or
the
mempool,
depending
on
the
blockchain.
Transaction
deliverability
matters
immensely
for
an
RPC,
especially
since
the
highest-value
transactions
(e.g.
arbitrages)
tend
to
be
both
competitive
and
time-sensitive.
Resilient
and
low-latency
connections
from
the
RPC
node
to
the
block
leader
or
mempool
can
assist
RPC
nodes
in
these
responsibilities.
Third,
RPC
nodes
return
information
from
the
blockchain
to
downstream
users,
wallets,
and
dApps.
They
are
primary
providers
of
data
about
the
state
of
a
network,
providing
everything
from
wallet-balance
information
to
available
liquidity
for
a
given
trading
pair
on
a
DEX.
In
order
to
do
this,
they
need
to
ingest,
validate,
and
index
changes
as
close
to
real
time
as
possible.
Resilient
and
low-latency
connections
back
from
the
validators
to
the
RPC
nodes
can
ensure
that
RPCs
have
up-to-date
views
of
the
blockchain.
The
DoubleZero
protocol
can
make
the
RPC
ecosystem
more
competitive.
RPCs
already
vie
aggressively
amongst
themselves
on
timeliness
of
information
both
to
and
from
the
chain.
The
DoubleZero
network
opens
an
avenue
for
them
to
improve
service
yet
further.
Maximal
Extractable
Value
The
DoubleZero
network
can
support
a
more
fair
and
open
maximal
extractable
value
(MEV)
ecosystem.
These
systems
are
extremely
latency-sensitive,
such
that
even
small
improvements
in
latency
and
deliverability
can
deliver
additional
value.
MEV
refers
to
the
value
that
block
producers
can
take
by
ordering
transactions
in
a
block
–
by
strategically
adding
a
transaction
to
close
a
price
dislocation
caused
by
a
large
trade.
In
practice,
mature
MEV
systems
typically
situate
themselves
as
adjacent
to
the
validators.
They
receive
proposals
from
external
traders
(known
as
“searchers”),
identify
a
profitable
ordering
of
transactions,
and
forward
the
ordering
to
the
block
leader
along
with
some
additional
payment.
14
Reliability
and
latency
in
communication
matter
on
two
dimensions.
First,
MEV
systems
benefit
from
a
more
real-time
view
of
the
state
of
a
network.
With
fresher
data,
they
can
construct
more
profitable
transaction
ordering,
allowing
them
to
craft
more
efficient
blocks.
Second,
even
holding
the
opportunity
set
fixed,
MEV
systems
that
can
relay
proposals
to
validators
quickly
can
use
the
extra
time
to
find
better
orderings.
Block
construction
is
a
complex
combinatorial
problem
that
requires
approximation
and
simulation
algorithms
to
find
local
optima
–
any
extra
time
allows
those
algorithms
to
run
longer.
Put
another
way,
MEV
systems
benefit
from
faster
retrieval
of
data
(read
operations)
and
faster
delivery
of
blocks
or
bundles
to
the
current
leader
(write
operations).
Increasing
bandwidth
and
reducing
latency
improve
both
of
these
factors.
Layer
2
Blockchains
Layer
2
blockchains
that
use
central
sequencers
or
a
distributed
set
can
utilize
the
DoubleZero
network
too.
In
a
typical
Layer
2,
a
single
sequencer
posts
inbound
transactions
to
a
Layer
1
chain;
a
set
of
Layer
2
validators
then
use
those
to
update
the
chain
state.
There
are
standard
ways
that
a
Layer
2
chain
can
utilize
the
DoubleZero
protocol,
such
as
filtering
inbound
transactions
to
the
sequencer,
posting
to
or
retrieving
from
the
Layer
1
without
latency,
or
verifying
updated
state
among
the
validators
quickly.
There
are
two
more
critical
ways
that
Layer
2
chains
can
benefit
from
the
DoubleZero
network.
First,
most
Layer
2
chains
aspire
to
support
multiple
sequencers
(posting
transactions
either
in
rotation
or
in
tandem)
to
reduce
centralization,
censorship,
and
liveness
risks.
This
architecture
shift
requires
substantial
coordination
between
the
sequencers
to
prevent
wasted
computation
for
both
the
Layer
1
chain
and
the
Layer
2
validator
set.
The
DoubleZero
network
can
smooth
that
communication
between
sequencers.
Second,
many
Layer
2
chains
aspire
to
scale
using
data
availability
layers,
which
store
transaction
data,
smart
contract
data,
and
even
off-chain
data
on
separate
systems
that
can
deliver
information
on
demand.
But
the
efficacy
of
this
modular
architecture
is
limited
by
the
bandwidth
connections
between
the
modules,
and
low-bandwidth
connections
can
lead
to
new
bottlenecks
in
the
underlying
chain.
Again,
the
DoubleZero
network
can
ensure
that
the
data
availability
layers
keep
pace
with
Layer
2
chains.
Other
Blockchain
Contexts
The
DoubleZero
network
offers
advantages
in
other
blockchain
contexts:
state
synchronization,
indexers,
multiple
leaders,
and
network
extensions,
among
others.
One
challenge
with
high-throughput
blockchain
systems
is
onboarding
new
validator
nodes.
These
nodes
must
synchronize
to
the
current
state
by
replaying
transactions
from
the
chain
start,
as
outlined
by
MegaETH
[2024].
For
high-throughput
blockchains,
this
can
impose
too
much
pressure
on
existing
resources
like
bandwidth.
The
new
validator
node
cannot
simply
ingest
transactions
at
the
current
speed
of
the
blockchain
but
must
ingest
substantially
faster
in
order
to
catch
up
to
the
15
current
state.
The
high-bandwidth
connections
of
the
DoubleZero
network
can
be
useful
in
overcoming
these
constraints
and
making
it
easier
for
new
validators
to
join.
By
the
same
principle,
it
can
also
help
validators
that
fall
behind
come
back
online.
As
blockchains
scale,
supporting
infrastructure
like
indexers
will
become
more
important.
Like
RPC
nodes,
indexers
need
to
receive
updated
state
quickly
so
that
their
end
users
can
form
quick
and
reactive
decisions.
State
propagation
through
DoubleZero
reduces
delays
to
indexing
fresh
data,
and
can
help
keep
distributed
indexer
instances
current.
Many
Layer
1
blockchains
aspire
to
have
multiple
leaders
simultaneously
produce
blocks
in
different
parts
of
the
world.
Without
tight
coordination
between
leaders,
though,
this
can
quickly
lead
to
redundant
or
outdated
transactions
and
wasted
compute.
Like
multiple
sequencers
on
Layer
2
chains,
multiple
leaders
on
Layer
1
chains
need
rapid
global
state
synchronization;
and
the
DoubleZero
network
can
facilitate
this
better
than
the
public
internet.
Lastly,
there
are
a
whole
class
of
blockchain
extension
services
that
do
not
fit
nicely
into
the
“Layer
1”
or
“Layer
2”
buckets.
These
uncategorized
services
are
sometimes
referred
to
as
“network
extensions.”
Nearly
every
network
today
has
the
concept
of
a
compute
operation
that
can
be
run
on
only
a
subset
of
a
network’s
validators,
because
it
requires
specialized
hardware
or
software.
ZK
proovers,
GPU
workloads,
and
asynchronous
execution
platforms
all
can
benefit
from
the
increased
bandwidth
and
reduced
latency
links
DoubleZero
provides.
Other
Use
Cases
The
DoubleZero
network
has
uses
beyond
blockchain
technology.
Any
setting
in
which
distributed
systems
have
to
communicate
quickly,
precisely,
and
voluminously
can
benefit
from
its
structure.
This
section
lays
out
four
additional
examples.
Content
Delivery
Networks
At
a
high
level,
content
delivery
networks
(CDNs)
look
similar
to
the
DoubleZero
network.
CDNs
make
content
delivery
more
efficient
for
users
by
filtering
public
requests
and
routing
them
efficiently
through
their
network.
This,
coupled
with
local
caches
that
hold
content,
allows
for
users
to
enjoy
reliable
and
fast
experiences
for
a
given
web
application.
A
new
CDN
can
rely
upon
the
DoubleZero
network
to
bootstrap
itself
more
quickly
and
focus
on
its
core
competencies.
CDNs
excel
at
forecasting
demand
and
provisioning
content
accordingly;
but
in
the
status
quo,
they
must
also
filter
traffic
and
establish
networks
with
low
latencies
and
high
bandwidth
to
offer
an
end
product.
6
A
new
CDN
built
atop
the
DoubleZero
network
could
return
to
those
core
competencies
only,
and
leave
the
filtering
and
routing
to
the
protocol.
6
The
incumbents,
like
Akamai
and
Cloudflare,
mostly
establish
long-term
leases
from
network
service
providers
to
structure
their
network.
16
Moreover,
the
DoubleZero
network
can
boost
the
operations
of
existing
CDNs.
One
major
advantage
of
the
DoubleZero
protocol
is
its
flexibility:
Users
do
not
need
to
contract
for
expansive
and
long-term
leases,
but
can
customize
their
usage
for
specific
routes
and
time
intervals.
Thus,
CDNs
that
maintain
their
own
network
but
lack
coverage
in
certain
regions
or
need
more
bandwidth
across
central
corridors
can
use
DoubleZero
accordingly,
offering
better
experiences
to
users
and
relieving
strain
on
their
networks
alike.
This
could
be
especially
powerful
as
multicast
functionality
comes
to
the
network
and
allows
for
more
efficient
delivery
of
content.
Online
Gaming
Latency
makes
and
breaks
online
games.
Even
mild
lags
ruin
the
user
experience
and
restrict
players
to
simple
turn-based
games.
Traditional
game
developers
have
used
two
models:
peer-to-peer
models
or
central
servers.
The
DoubleZero
network
can
augment
both.
Some
games
use
peer-to-peer
models,
whereby
the
end
players
connect
directly
over
the
public
internet.
7
These
are
relatively
efficient,
particularly
when
there
are
few
players,
but
these
models
are
directly
constrained
by
the
limitations
of
public
internet.
Latency,
constrained
bandwidth,
and
jitter
can
lead
to
frustrated
users.
The
DoubleZero
network,
with
its
dedicated
links
and
its
flexible
usage
model,
can
deliver
stability
to
the
connections
and
make
the
games
more
enjoyable.
Other
games
use
the
model
of
a
central
server
to
which
all
players
connect.
These
models
are
particularly
used
when
there
are
many
players.
Historically,
these
games
have
been
built
atop
cloud
providers,
which
have
their
own
set
of
advantages
and
disadvantages.
Cloud
providers
offer
stable
performance
for
players
close
to
the
edges
of
their
network,
but
p프로젝트로 돌아가기