bitpro가 원문에서 글자만 모은 내용이에요. 표·그림·수식은 빠지거나 깨질 수 있어요. 전체 4쪽 중 1쪽
Basic Attention Token (BAT)
Blockchain Based Digital Advertising
Brave Software
February 10, 2021
Abstract
Digital advertising is broken. The marketplace for online advertising, once domi-
nated by advertisers, publishers and users, has become overrun by “middleman” ad
exchanges, audience segmentation, complicated behavioral and cross-device user
tracking, and opaque cross-party sharing through data management platforms.
Users face unprecedented levels of malvertisements and privacy violations. Mo-
bile advertising results in as much as $23 per month in data charges on the average
user’s data plan, slow page loads, and as much as 21% less battery life. In response,
over 600 million mobile devices and desktops (globally) employ ad blocking soft-
ware and this number is growing. Traditional publishers have lost approximately
66% of their revenue over the past decade, adjusted for inflation. Publishers face
falling revenue, users feel increasingly violated, and advertisers’ ability to assess
effectiveness is diminished. The solution is a decentralized, transparent digital ad
exchange based on Blockchain. The first component is Brave, a fast, open source,
privacy-focused browser that blocks third party ads and trackers, and builds in a
ledger system that measures user attention to reward publishers accordingly. Brave
will now introduce BAT (Basic Attention Token), a token for a decentralized ad
exchange. It compensates the browser user for attention while protecting privacy.
BAT connects advertisers, publishers, and users and is denominated by relevant
user attention, while removing social and economic costs associated with existing
ad networks, e.g., fraud, privacy violations, and malvertising. BAT is a payment
system that rewards and protects the user while giving better conversion to ad-
vertisers and higher yield to publishers. We see BAT and associated technologies
as a future part of web standards, solving the important problem of monetizing
publisher content while protecting user privacy.
1
Contents
1 Value Proposition 3
2 Introduction 3
2.1 An Inefficient and Troubled Market . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
2.2 The Attention Marketplace: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
3 A New Deal: Attention-based Economics on Blockchain 12
3.1 Basic Attention Metrics (BAM) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
3.2 Token Technology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
3.3 Tokens Used as Publisher Payment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
3.4 Tokens for User Applications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17
3.5 Roadmap . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18
4 Business landscape 18
4.1 Competition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18
4.2 BAT Advantage Matrix . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19
4.3 BAT Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19
4.4 Key Team Members . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21
5 Token Launch 22
5.1 Token Launch summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22
5.2 Token Distribution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22
5.3 User Growth Pool . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22
5.4 Budget Allocation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23
6 BAT FAQs 24
7 Appendix 26
7.1 A More Efficient Market: Coase Theorem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26
7.2 A Three-Way Coasean Bargain . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29
7.3 An Analysis of the Stability of the BAT . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 32
2
1 Value Proposition
We propose the BAT as a token of exchange in a secure, anonymous, opt-in advertising
system based in the browser and the mobile app webview. The BAT system provides:
• Users: strong privacy and security when viewing advertisements, improved rele-
vance and performance, and a share of tokens.
• Publishers: improved revenue, better reporting, and less fraud.
• Advertisers: less expensive customer attention, less fraud, and better attribution.
2 Introduction
“Attention has been widely recognized as a commodity, like wheat, pork bellies
or crude oil. Existing industries have long depended on it to drive sales. And
the new industries of the twentieth century turned it into a form of currency
they could mint. Beginning with radio, each new medium would attain its
commercial viability through the resale of what attention it could capture in
exchange for its ’free’ content.” -Tim Wu, Attention Brokers
The promise of advertising technology (“ad-tech”) was to create a more efficient
marketplace for attention. The hope was that the Internet, the latest kind of “new
medium,” would arrive with a transparent and efficient ad marketplace.
In theory, excellence would be rewarded. The best journalism and entertainment
would receive the attention and funding it deserved. Ad tech would “get marketers
closer to their users via data analysis, immediate valuation and distribution.” Data
would be used to “accurately identify audiences, determine the value of those audiences,
and deliver the right messages to them instantly.”[1] In short, users’ attention would be
valued properly.
That didn’t happen. Instead, the ad-tech ecosystem that has evolved over the last
two decades is a bewildering variety of middlemen and complexity. Worse, ad-tech
introduced a host of correlated problems for publishers, advertisers and users. Users
have lost their privacy, face increasing malware, pay high charges to download ads, and
suffer slow speeds. Publishers have lost billions in revenue while fraud has skyrocketed.
And advertisers face poor reporting and targeting.
This paper will review the current state of ad-tech and the predicament of con-
tent producers. It will outline a new solution that creates a transparent and efficient
Blockchain-based marketplace for publishers, advertisers and users, accurately valuing
and rewarding the key driver of Internet content: durable user attention.
2.1 An Inefficient and Troubled Market
Thomas Davenport and JC Beck note that “attention is focused mental engagement
on a particular item of information. Items come into our awareness, we attend to a
3
particular item, and then we decide whether to act.”[2] Attention is, in this sense, a
form of scarcity, which raises fundamental economic questions, which we shall address
momentarily.
Advertising, throughout history, has been used as the primary mechanism to capture
Attention, raise it to a level of Interest to incite some Desire that can then translate
it into Action – otherwise known as AIDA.[3] The earliest forms of advertising date
to ancient China, Egypt and the Middle Ages in Europe. The print form of advertis-
ing began to expand widely with the growth of 19th Century printed products. This
marketplace of advertisers, publishers and users remained relatively straightforward –
despite some additions – even as the new media of radio and television arose.
The rise of the Internet brought the development of a new level of advertising tech-
nology with the promise of higher speed and better information, two critical elements
that had the potential to radically improve the efficiency of the attention marketplace.
Somewhat counter-intuitively, the sheer complexity and opacity that organically devel-
oped has brought the opposite result. The system isn’t working as it should. As the
Chief Brand officer of the largest advertiser, P&G, said recently:
“The days of giving digital a pass are over. It’s time to grow up. It’s time
for action.” [4]
Especially in the last decade, the advertising ecosystem has become more complex
and crowded, with many more players taking a piece of the advertising pie, either
directly or indirectly. The complexity of this ecosystem increases the cost in headcount
and difficulty of the tasks for the digital marketing teams on the advertiser’s side. At
the other end of the system, the typical publisher faces both a shrinking market for the
ad-blocker-free attention, and a shrinking slice of the advertising revenue pie due to the
multitude of third party players who act as economic middlemen in the transaction.
2.2 The Attention Marketplace:
Sales planners currently budgeting for brand advertising are required to account for
an excessive number of intermediaries that stand between the ad and the end user.
Agencies, trading desks, demand side platforms, desktop and mobile network exchanges,
yield optimization, rich media vendors and partnered services often consume significant
portions of creative and delivery ad budget. It is also common for agencies in charge
of packaging brand campaigns to use data aggregators, data management platforms,
data suppliers, analytics, measurement and verification services to fight fraud, enhance
targeting, and confirm attribution. These factors add up to a high transaction cost on
the efficient provision of attention to brand ad campaigns.
4
Publishers also face a number of costs and intermediaries on the receiving side of
the ads served. Publishers pay ad serving fees, operational fees for campaign setup,
deployment and monitoring, publisher analytics tools; also they give up substantial
revenue to some of the same intermediaries that the brand advertisers use via program-
matic ads. Publishers face direct costs of user complaints when malvertising spreads
from exchanges to loyal readers, often with little or no idea of origin and with no help
from the ad exchanges responsible for allowing such ads to serve from their systems.
These diminish net revenue as the overall complexity of the advertising ecosystem raises
headcount and expense.
There is a hidden cost to this complexity. A single ad unit may bounce across
many networks, buy and sell-side ad servers, verification partners and data management
platforms. Publishers lose revenue from each middleman transaction. Each one of
these transactions also detracts from the user experience. Many of the middle players
involve data transfers, which add latency. Any transfers done via script on page eat
into the user’s data plan and battery life on mobile. Users often find their experience
further diminished when the results finally arrive, confounded by a bewildering array
of distracting ads the publisher allowed to be placed in hope of greater revenue.
In addition, the violation of user privacy exacts a significant social cost; economists
have compared violations of user privacy as analogous to environmental pollution.[5]
According to Pew Research, “Fully 91% of adults agree or strongly agree that users have
lost control of how personal information is collected and used by companies.”[6] A large
majority, 64%, believe that the “government should do more to regulate advertisers”
regarding how they use and store personal information. This is not surprising, given
that a visit to a popular media site can often have 70 trackers set loose on the reader.
Fraud is also a major problem afflicting the advertising marketplace. Hackers cre-
ate malicious bots that produce bogus websites that fool advertisers. Internet “bots,”
5
Figure 1: Typical Digital Ad Flow
Figure 2: Typical Tracking on Large Content Sites
6
Figure 3: Data Transferred by Data Elements on News Sites
remote-controlled software running on compromised personal computers or cloud in-
frastructure programmed to engage in criminal activities -siphon billions of dollars each
year from the ad industry. According to Business Intelligence: “These bots create web-
sites filled with infringed content and generate fake traffic through a complex network
of infected computers. In 2016, ad fraud created by internet bots is expected to cost
advertisers $7.2 billion, up from $6.3 billion in 2015, according to a report from the
Association of National Advertises (ANA) and White Ops.”[7] There is no sign of this
level of fraud leveling off or reducing.
Advertisers face fraud, while users are increasingly encountering malvertisements.
Malvertisements are fake ads that trick users into clicking on them and then downloading
malicious code, including ransomware. They can also entice users to visit fake domains
used to steal financial information. According to a RiskIQ report released last year,
“malvertising advert rates [rose] by 132% from 2015 to 2016.” The sites most frequently
hit by malvertising, according to Bromium[8], are news and entertainment sites.
Web users are also not fully aware of the costs they pay for privilege of seeing
advertisements. According to Business Intelligence, one study found that up to 79%
of mobile data transferred during visits to popular publishers was a result of ads. The
researchers compared data usage when a full page loaded without an ad blocker, with
an ad blocker, and with an ad blocker and JavaScript disabled.
The article noted that the researchers concluded that “advertising accounts for half
of all the data used by publisher pages loaded over mobile data networks” during the
tests. The average smartphone user consumes 1.8GB a month. Based on carrier plans
for 2Gb, this means that average users end up paying up to $23 a month to download
ads, trackers, scripts and other related data.[9]
7
Figure 4: Sites Most Frequently Hit By Malvertising
Figure 5: Content Loading Cost Comparison
8
Figure 6: Ad Blocker Growth by Device
A study by the New York Times found the data used by advertising resulted in
significant download times and costs across 50 top publishing sites. On one extreme,
www.boston.com took 30.8 seconds for advertising and 8.2 seconds for editorial. The
article concluded that removing ads saved “more than five seconds of loading time over
a typical cell connection” for the articles studied. The data to load the ads came with
a financial cost as well – the price for the advertising content often outweighs that of
editorial material.
The sum total of malvertisements, load times, data costs, battery life, and privacy
loss has driven users to adopt ad-blocking software. This further reduces publisher
revenues and leaves the remaining ad-viewing audience even harder to target.
Ad blockers are a growing problem for publishers. Studies confirm that users of ad
blocking software prefer the simplicity of navigation of ad-free or nearly ad-free content.
Over 600 million mobile and desktop devices now use ad blocking, according to
Pagefair. It is projected that 86.6M Americans will use an ad blocker in 2017[10].
Younger users are also more likely to adopt ad blocking technology, making the long-
term financial impact of this technology worse than it appears at first glance[11].
This “perfect storm” for publishers has only gotten worse over the last few years
as Google and Facebook have taken more and more share of advertising revenues. To-
gether they claim over 73% of online digital ad revenue, and an astounding 99% of all
growth from 2015 to 2016 in US total online ad budget [12]. The increased attention
for publishers brought by Google and Facebook would seem to be a net positive. But
the traffic driven by social media is of lower quality than direct links. Users who ar-
rive at a news site from social media typically only engage with the site for a third[13]
9
Figure 7: Demographics of Ad Blocker Usage
of the time compared to those who are direct visitors. Distributed content hosting
makes up only 14% of publisher revenues, with the majority of the revenue coming from
Youtube[14]; many publishers have experienced serious commodification problems with
these platforms.
Advertisers on these platforms also face serious challenges. The sheer size of the
platforms make them opaque and difficult to assess the effectiveness of advertising cam-
paigns on their platforms. Since most of the analytics products targeting these platforms
are provided by the platform owner, principal-agent conflicts arise. Some advertisers
have decided that traffic coming from the walled gardens isn’t worth the trouble. Some
have even suggested based on third party analytics that a large proportion of the traffic
is without value to the advertiser[15].
In an effort to expand their walled gardens and to reinforce market dominance by
traffic and data otherwise ingested from users directly on the publisher domain, major
platform players have begun offering alternative content delivery channels with claims
of incentivized placement and a faster, more secure user experience. While Facebook
Instant Articles, Google AMP project and Apple News delivery channels were initially
presented to publishers as opportunities to extend reach and visibility, they ultimately
diminish publishers’ control of their brand narratives and reader relationships, and
divert direct attention away from publisher sites over the long run.
Generally speaking, the publishing industry faces an existential threat. Legacy
publishers have faced declining revenues for decades. Pressures on publishers to create
content optimized for clicks has resulted in cut-backs to long form articles, investigative
journalism, and foreign news bureaus, and has spawned the much lamented social cost
revealingly named “clickbait.” This dysfunctional dynamic has been noticed across the
industry. Marketing budgets continue to climb[16], yet publisher revenues are static or
shrinking[17]. This indicates serious market inefficiencies which can be repaired with a
10
Figure 8: Ad Revenue for Google vs Facebook vs Others
Figure 9: The Fall of Newspaper Ad Revenue
11
simplified and more efficient economic system based on new technologies.
3 A New Deal: Attention-based Economics on Blockchain
The diversity of middle-men and the lack of value-add to the publisher and user make
some sort of simplification of the present online advertising ecosystem inevitable. Present
trends are toward an oligopoly where gatekeeper companies such as Google and Face-
book control the entire online marketing budget with publishers powerless to control
their revenues. Also, as users continue to adopt ad blocking technology the consequent
shrinking of the remaining ad-funded market seems inevitable.
The reality remains: user attention is valuable, but it hasn’t been properly priced
with an efficient and transparent market system. While it has become a platitude
that vast amounts of information are generated on and by the Internet, human beings
are only able to devote a limited amount of attention to certain small subsets of the
information. Information in the modern age is relatively cheap. Human attention paid
to the information is the rare quantity. As Herbert Simon put it in an influential 1971
article:
“. . . in an information-rich world, the wealth of information means a dearth
of something else: a scarcity of whatever it is that information consumes.
What information consumes is rather obvious: it consumes the attention of
its recipients. Hence a wealth of information creates a poverty of attention
and a need to allocate that attention efficiently among the overabundance of
information sources that might consume it.”
Ultimately, a publisher provides information which may be of value to the user.
Users give attention to the publisher in return for information that they value with
their attention. At present, the publisher is paid by monetizing attention via a complex
network of intermediary players through ad networks and other such tools. The pub-
lisher isn’t paid directly for the attention given by the user. The publisher is actually
paid for the indirectly measured attention given by users to ads. Publishers are used to
working with this model for print ads, but web ads remain problematic for many of the
reasons stated above. Users are subjected to the negative externalities that come with
the present advertising ecosystem.
Users thus suffer a form of “electronic pollution” consisting of threats to security,
threats to privacy, costs in inefficient download times, financial costs in extra mobile data
fees, and in the case of 프로젝트로 돌아가기