bitpro가 원문에서 글자만 모은 내용이에요. 표·그림·수식은 빠지거나 깨질 수 있어요. 전체 2쪽 중 2쪽
t pool resources to offer large bounties for intelligence
on the exploiter, or a sleuth might auction a particular method for gathering labels.
Intelligence bought and sold on the Arkham Intel Marketplace is held exclusively by the acquiring
counterparties for a period of 90 days, after which it will be propagated to Arkham for all users to
see. Time-bound exclusivity is necessary so that Arkham is not constrained from putting requested
7
Figure 4: Auction Structure
intelligence on the platform, and to contribute to the ultimate decentralization of intelligence for the
community. If exclusivity were unlimited, then Arkham would not be able to add the same intelligence
to the platform even if acquired independently. Indirect intel verification as described in section 3.5
would allow for unlimited exclusivity.
The user interface for interacting with the Arkham Intel Marketplace will be deployed on the
Arkham Platform. The UI will display a searchable list of the existing intel bounties and auctions on
the marketplace, and provide a portal for posting new bounties and auctions. Bounty and auction
listings display a description of the intel sought or offered, with options to claim or bid.
Bounty posters enter a description of the intelligence sought, the time limit for the bounty, and
the bounty size. They then use their browser wallet to stake the bounty ARKM in the bounty smart
contract. Once the transaction clears, the bounty is posted to the marketplace.
Auction holders enter a public description and set the parameters for the auction, and submit the
intelligence to be sold for review. Once their staking transaction clears, the submission is reviewed
and, if approved, posted to the marketplace under the conditions set by the auctioneer.
3.5 The Intelligence Oracle Problem
Intelligence markets are uniquely challenging in that they require indirect verification. A buyer can’t
directly assess the intelligence prior to a sale, because then they would possess it, and there would be
nothing left to sell.
To get around this problem, buyers often use proxies for intelligence quality, such as the seller’s
reputation, but these are error-prone and invariably constrict possible sources of intelligence. Going off
of reputation, for instance, leaves untapped the well of crypto intelligence sourced by amateur sleuths
who have yet to establish their reputation, or by those wishing to remain anonymous.
Arkham solves this problem by directly verifying intelligence, so marketplace participants know
that intelligence on auction or successfully submitted for a bounty has been vetted by the Arkham
team using proprietary technology.
Eventually, intelligence on the Arkham Intel Marketplace will be verified in a decentralized manner.
This requires solving the oracle problem for crypto intelligence. Arkham is soliciting grant proposals
for work to solve this problem.
The intelligence oracle problem is a level of difficulty above the general oracle problem because of
the requirement for indirect verification. It is not as simple as reliably retrieving the correct piece of
off-chain information. The soundness of the information must be verified in a reliable decentralized
way without direct access by validators.
8
Existing solutions to the general oracle problem, such as Chainlink DONs [2] [5], provide a potential
starting point for work on the intelligence oracle problem. However, DONs currently only address the
problem of oracle decentralization, not indirect verification.
Promising avenues for solving indirect verification include zero-knowledge protocols [6] [4], which
are designed for this purpose. Thus far they have primarily been employed to verify private key validity,
which is less challenging than indirect intelligence verification because it is less subjective. Intelligence
verification always involves some uncertainty and ambiguity, making it especially well-suited to direct
human analysis. However, there are existing methods for zero-knowledge assessment in ambiguous
domains that present promising research avenues.
In sketch, a zero-knowledge decentralized solution to the intelligence oracle problem might involve
a decentralized network of intelligence analyst nodes which verify intelligence that has been concealed
using a zero-knowledge protocol. Compensation for the work of these intelligence validator nodes could
be built into the Arkham Intel Marketplace protocol through allocation of a portion of staked bounties.
A benefit of deriving validator compensation from staked bounties would be that larger bounties would
be prioritized for validation, providing an additional incentive to increase bounty sizes.
The Arkham Intel Marketplace will employ a DON in the intel verification process. The DON
serves to decentralize and secure the intel verification oracle for bounty and auction smart contracts,
but the verification itself remains direct. When an indirect verification method is devised, the DON
can be easily modified to refer to this new method.
3.6 The DATA Program
Arkham’s Decentralized AI Training Accelerator (DATA) Program is a complementary intel-to-earn
system to the marketplace. In the DATA program, sleuths earn ARKM by submitting intelligence for
training Ultra and augmenting the data on the platform. In addition to specific labels and entity attri-
butions, data sources and other leads can be submitted. Arkham reviews submissions and, if approved,
there is an ARKM payout. The size of the payout depends on the value of the intel. Exceptionally
valuable intel can and has received payouts in excess of 1,000 ARKM. The direct submission system
provides sleuths with a revenue stream for their work, while also creating a decentralized community
of intelligence analysts for the platform.
Direct submissions are a means for Arkham to source intelligence and training data directly from
the community, and for sleuths to earn ARKM for intelligence without the uncertainty of auctions and
the restricting specificity of bounties.
High priority intel includes a range of non-address, non-entity submissions, such as data sources
that generate many labels or intelligence on an urgent and high-profile case. Sleuths participate in the
DATA program by submitting intelligence directly on the platform using a simple form in which they
present their findings and justify their validity.
4 The Arkham Exchange
Adding a digital asset trading function to Arkham is a natural extension of its use as a tool for
informing trading decisions. Since the publication of version 1 of the Arkham Whitepaper in July
2023, the importance of on-chain intelligence for the crypto trader has become more clear, in large part
because of Arkham’s presence. As predicted in the Arkham Theses, entity-based crypto intelligence
is becoming a core utility for digital asset traders. The addition of a trading function to their data
utility allows traders to operate more efficiently and seamlessly. This same development occurred in
traditional finance with the Bloomberg Terminal, which serves as both a data and a trading platform.
To meet the demand for liquidity and execution speed, this trading function will be built out
as a full-service centralized exchange. A decentralized model works well for the Intel Marketplace
because crypto intelligence is non-fungible, the market for it is relatively illiquid, and execution speed
is relatively unimportant. Not so for digital assets, which is why the vast majority of digital asset
trading volume takes place on centralized exchanges [10].
9
4.1 Exchange Transparency
Counterparty risk is the primary concern for traders using centralized exchanges [1]. Transparency
is the solution to these concerns. Arkham’s intelligence capabilities uniquely position it to provide
exceptional transparency regarding Arkham Exchange operations.
Exchange on-chain assets and operations will be labeled on the Arkham Platform, enabling users
to verify on-chain reserves and monitor exchange activities. Further exchange specific tracking and
monitoring capabilities will be added to allow for an unprecedented level of transparency into central-
ized exchange operations and reserves. With these developments, the Arkham Exchange will become a
model for exchange transparency and improve the industry standard for centralized exchanges across
the board.
4.2 Towards an OmniPlatform for Traders
With the addition of the Arkham Exchange, Arkham moves closer to serving all of the functions
that a contemporary trader requires. Currently traders use different tools to trade, to do on-chain
analysis, technical analysis, stay up to date on news, etc. Often they use multiple tools for each of
these functions.
Combining all of these functions into a single platform is more efficient, both for the user and for
the platform itself. It is vertical integration for crypto trading. The trader can move more seamlessly
from on-chain investigation to trading and back.
A promising direction for further work is in building out a news function. The intelligence platform
is already a source of truth for breaking crypto news. By adding its own news feature, the platform
news function is able to break on-chain stories more quickly and with more incisive analysis than
existing news platforms. This could be mostly or entirely automated using AI, so that breaking on-
chain movements have incisive news stories published instantaneously, made immediately available to
the Arkham user.
5 ARKM Incentives
In addition to its main function as the currency of the intel-to-earn economy, ARKM powers a system of
incentives designed to generate a positive feedback loop of platform adoption, driving stable, long-term
growth.
In version 1 of this whitepaper, ARKM incentives were limited to the Arkham Intel Marketplace
and plaform. Now, the introduction of the Arkham Exchange to the ARKM ecosystem creates a new
playing field for ARKM incentives, the beginnings of which are outlined below.
The ARKM incentive system has two parts:
• ARKM Rewards: Rewards for actions beneficial to the Arkham ecosystem
• ARKM Discounts: Discounts on digital asset exchange fees for paying in or holding ARKM.
The system of incentives formed by ARKM discounts and rewards supports the token’s core util-
ity to complete an Arkham ecosystem that will stably flourish as the global center for blockchain
intelligence and trading.
5.1 ARKM Rewards
The first component of the ARKM incentive system is the Rewards Program, in which users receive
ARKM for actions beneficial to the Arkham community. Actions for which rewards will be distributed
will vary depending on the state of the ecosystem at a given time, but may include user referrals and
the production of research and analysis.
5.1.1 Grants
ARKM grants will support projects that contribute to the ecosystem, especially work to solve the
intelligence oracle problem towards achieving full marketplace decentralization.
10
5.1.2 Ecosystem Partner Rewards
The vast majority of on-chain sleuths focus on Ethereum. Other blockchains will be able to offer
rewards to Arkham users for contributing on-chain analysis and other content to their communities.
Rewards may be in partner native tokens or in ARKM.
5.2 ARKM Discounts
ARKM Discounts are the other main aspect of the ARKM incentive system. Users earn discounts on
the Arkham platform by using ARKM in two ways:
• Pay-in-ARKM: discount on digital asset exchange fee payments made in ARKM.
• Holding Discount: discount for holding ARKM, varying by holding size. The exact magnitude
of these discounts at any given time will be posted on the Arkham website.
These discounts can be combined, meaning that a user can pay in ARKM and receive the corre-
sponding discount, while also retaining ARKM holdings to receive the holding discount as well.
6 Conclusion
Compared to traditional financial systems, blockchain-based technology enables more complete and
precise analysis of financial activity. The greater power of crypto financial data compared to traditional
data confers a significant advantage upon those who can use it, rendering crypto intelligence tools
essential for serious market participants. Their advent will transform the financial industry. This
transformation, and the recognition of it, has only just begun. It will culminate in the development
and adoption of an all-in-one tool that vertically integrates data, news, and trading functions. Arkham
is designed to be that tool.
References
[1] Acuiti. Q1 2023 Crypto Derivatives Management Insight Report. 15 March 2023.
[2] L. Breidenbach, C. Cachin, B. Chan, A. Coventry, S. Ellis, A. Juels, F. Koushanfar, A. Miller,
B. Magauran, D. Moroz, S. Nazarov, A. Topliceanu, F. Tram‘er, and F. Zhang. Chainlink 2.0:
Next steps in the evolution of decentralized oracle networks. April 2021. https://research.
chain.link/whitepaper-v2.pdf.
[3] Burton-Taylor International Consulting. Market Data Boon: How increasing reliance on data and
analytics is driving continuous growth in spending. November 2022.
[4] V. Buterin. An approximate introduction to how zk-snarks are possible. 26 January 2021. https:
//vitalik.ca/general/2021/01/26/snarks.html.
[5] S. Ellis, A. Juels, and S. Nazarov. ChainLink: A decentralized oracle network. September 2017.
https://research.chain.link/whitepaper-v1.pdf.
[6] S. Goldwasser, S. Micali, and C. Rackoff. The Knowledge Complexity of Interactive Proof Systems.
SIAM Journal on Computing, 18(1):186–208, 1989.
[7] M. Morel. How self-regulation can help crypto thrive. Coindesk, 25 January 2023. https:
//www.coindesk.com/consensus-magazine/2023/01/25/crypto-self-regulation/ .
[8] A. Osipovich. Nasdaq, Nyse Win Court Battle With SEC Over Market
Data. Wall Street Journal , 5 July 2022. https://www.wsj.com/articles/
nasdaq-nyse-win-court-battle-with-sec-over-market-data-11657056514 .
[9] J. Schumpeter. Capitalism, Socialism, and Democracy, chapter VII: The Process of Creative
Destruction. 1942.
11
[10] The Block. DEX to CEX spot trade volume. 6 November 2024.
[11] S. Wan. ZachXBT bids adieu to crypto community requests. CryptoSlate, 9 March 2023. https:
//cryptoslate.com/zachxbt-bids-adieu-to-crypto-community-requests/ .
[12] M. Weber. Die B¨ orse. 1894. https://www.textlog.de/6166.html.
[13] I. Withers and L. White. Dollars in the detail: banks pan for gold in ’data lakes’. 21 June 2019.
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-banks-data-idUSKCN1TM0JG .
12프로젝트로 돌아가기